Stocking suggestions 25g

kidlet

AC Members
Mar 9, 2007
35
0
0
Here's what we have in our 25g tank. I'm pretty sure we're overstocked (stupidly let the fish salesman convince me to purchase a few more fish than I had originally intended) but wanted confirmation as well as suggestions on where to cut back:

8 zebra danios (we cycled with these)
4 platys
2 dwarf gouramis (they're the shiny blue/red ones so I'm assuming they're both male but they seem to be getting along fine)
1 chocolate brown pleco (my husband bought this one and I know it's going to be too big for our tank)

My ammonia and nitrites are nil, nitrates are around 5. Lots of poop in the tank though - yuck - so requires a couple water changes a week. I think the pleco poops more than he eats.

I thought about returning 1 platy and 3 danios and the pleco (need to get something smaller than the pleco - otos?). Would that still be too many fish? Ideas? Sure, they all seem to have room now, but I know they're just going to get bigger.

Also - when returning fish, what do you put them in? My Ziplock bags smell really plastic-y and I don't want to hurt the fish...

Thanks in advance!
 
lets see. the zebra danios will stay relatively small. I dont see a problem with 8 myself. plecos do tend to poop alot... I don't really know anything about platys. The dwarf gouramis will never get that big either. I actually tend to think you are quite fine with those fish. As long as you keep to a strict water change routine and maintain healthy water, I don't see any problems.
 
pleco will have to go sooner or later, they are big waste producers
 
I would take the pleco back, and maybe one Dwarf Gourami, and get appr. 5 panda cories.
 
take the pleco back and some danios, get 6 Rummynose Tetras, IMO they are much more colourful and interesting than cardinals or neons.
 
if you take back the danios that you cycled with...please tell me you don't shop at my local store. I surely don't want to buy your damaged fish by mistake!

Sorry I would never return fish that went through a tank cycle....that is unfair to them or the unsuspecting next buyer.
 
AquariaCentral.com