Fish Aggression, white spots and a request for advice...

Subliminal

AC Members
Feb 21, 2007
1,806
0
0
50
Princeton, NJ
Hey guys,

Here's my deal:

I've a 55g tank stocked with a good amount of rock, softies, snails, a few cleaner shrimp, and the following fish:

Thompson Tang
Coral Beaut
2 Percs
2 Damsels

Now here's the problem:

My coral beauty pretty much relentlessly messes with my tang.

My tang has been showing white spots lately

Yesterday a white spot showed up on the tail section of the coral beauty



Now, all the fish look healthy, swim like crazy, and eat like horses. But, the tang really never has a moments peace unless he hides under the rock stack.

The cleaner shrimp seem more than happy to provide services, but whenever the tang stops by the cleaners (either of the cleaners, as they've taken up different locations), the coral beauty just keeps searching until he finds the tang and then chases him away.

Now, the tang does it back to the coral beauty sometimes, although I would guess it's not the majority of the time.

So, I'm kind of scared for my fish. And a little dissapointed that the tang hides so often now.

Out of the two fish, I like the tang quite a bit more than the angel. I like the angel, too, as it's very pretty, but it just doesn't do it for me like the tang.

I don't have an extra tank to put fish into to get them healthy, and if I try to stick a net in the tank, the fish hide until I remove it.

I've thought about just leaving the net in there overnight for them to get used to, but it still begs the question of what I would do with the fish if I got it out of the tank.

So, I'm not really sure what to do at this point:

Leave well enough alone and hope for the best.

Remove one fish or the other

Just not sure. I wouldn't be against getting rid of the coral beauty, but since I seem to have some white spots on those two fish, it seems like getting rid of them would be difficult, becuase who's going to want a sick fish...and couple that with the fact I'm not sure if that's the best course anyway...

Which brings me to my post. I like my little fishies, and don't want them to start dying on me.

Thanks,

damon
 
if it was my tank, i would get the ich dealt with from the fish, and then make a formed decision on which one to keep and take the other to the LFS for credit.

It seems that by now, they are not going to be able to settle into the same aquarium as eachother, so, for the sake of raising stress levels in the entire tank more than what they already are, one of them has to give way...

Prolly not what you want to be hearing Damon, but that is my honest opinion mate..

Niko
 
No, I don't have much problem with getting rid of the angel, honestly. He's pretty, but kind of a pain in the butt.

However, I just don't really know how to proceed with the ich thing.

Like, if the stress levels in the tank went way down, would the ich take care of itself? And if not, do I disassemble the entire tank to get the fish out, buy a new tank for a QT, and buy the accessories to keep the fish alive.

Sigh...what a bummer this is. And to think I thought the corals would be the hard part.
 
Hi Damon, I'd definately get another tank for QT I have one and it has literally been a lifesaver. One way I've read to catch a fish (think It was G/mans thread) is to float a bag in your tank with some food in and let the fish swim in. From what I've heard (I may be wrong ) but ich needs to be treated with copper-based medication and you can't do this in your main tank because of your inverts.
 
My tank is actually a bevvy of hiding spots. I picked rock specifically for the amount of holes in it. Lol. The coral beauty actually just swims through the entire rock structure looking for the tang.

I'm actually thinking of moving stuff around a bit. Making 2 'islands' of live rock so that there's an open spot in the middle of the tank. It seems like that might work. Only time will tell, though, of course.

I'm also in the process of trying to get rid of my cichlids to free up my 29g.
 
Like, if the stress levels in the tank went way down, would the ich take care of itself?

I'm sure you're tired of hearing this from me, but here goes. In my personal opinion, and from personal experience, the answer to your question is yes, the ich could very possibly clear up on its own.

The spot on the angelfish may be nothing at all. Fish pick up a spot of something here and there, you see it for a day or two and then it disappears.

I would catch the angelfish and get it out of the system. Your LFS should have a place that they quarantine new fish, so if the spot is still there they can deal with it as they see fit.

Best of luck,

Paul
 
Thanks, Paul. I'm trying to get rid of my cichlids in the 29 (Got a guy who wants them, just have to get them to him!) and I'm going to turn that 29g into a SW tank. It will be an almost immediate home to a coral beauty. ;)
 
AquariaCentral.com