What's the smallest tank that can be successfully cycled?

gingerinaustin

AC Members
Apr 11, 2007
205
0
0
So, while I'm waiting for my 55 gallon tank to cycle, I'm already thinking about my next tank. :D

The 55 gallon is my first big tank; my very first tank was a tiny 2 gallon tank which I kept on my dining table with a betta in it. Although Spot developed fin rot about 2 weeks after I brought him home (Petsmart or Petco, don't remember which), he lived about 3 years. Despite a multitude of antibiotics and other remedies, his fins never grew back to their former glory. There were no decorations in the tank other than a fake silk plant. I changed the water every week and conditioned the water with Prime.

I'm thinking about getting another similar tank and another betta. But I would rather not have to do a 100% water change on a betta tank every week. I'm also thinking about moving the cardinal tetras from the 55 gallon, since they don't seem to be compatible with any of the larger fish I'd like to put in there.

So, my question is (actually, I have two): what is the smallest tank that can reasonably be cycled? I've heard smaller tanks are harder to cycle and keep cycled. I know a 10 gallon can be cycled but that's too big for the dining table. Can a 2 gallon be cycled? What about a 5 gallon?

And secondly, could 7 cardinal tetras live happily with a betta? (Or, at least more happily than they would be living with 'peaceful' cichlids or rainbow fish?) Or am I looking at a third tank in my future?:help:
 
It's all premised upon the bioload to the nitrfication potential of your established bacteria colonies. Another way of saying this I guess would be bioload vs. surface area potential for the colonies.

Obviously a filter is a key component traditionally, but I would definately encourage you to 1) stick to a tank that will fit a filter, and 2) avoid a population that produces a bioload exceeding the tank's abilities.

For example, I can raise Brime Shrimp in a Dixie cup fairly easily and have a couple hundred of them and not exceed the bioload of the volume, but eventually I would need to change the water (even if "cycled", assuming that's posisble)...I just don;t have the tools to do so adequetly.

Okay, WAY more than you were asking for, but I was just talking to my LFS owner about this in fact. Anyways, there are some fairly cheap setups for 5G tanks that would work wonderfully IMO, and I would think your Betta would be happier for it. If this is on a table are you considering the wires at all? If a traditional "cycled" tank, it will need a filter (and maybe a heater too?)

As to your 2nd Q; 7 Cardinals in NO way could live with a Betta in a 2 or 5 G tank! Just won't work... If you wnated these together, now you are talking about that 10G you spoke of.
 
Thanks, ct. My 2 (or was it 2 1/2?) gallon came with an UGF but I never used it. It did have a 25W heater in it. The 100% water changes got kinda old after, oh, a year or so for both me and Spot; partial water changes sound much more doable. My dining table backs up against a stone wall and there is an outlet there. I'd like to have some gravel and maybe even a single low-light live plant in there. Sounds like a 5 gallon with filter and heater may be the way to go. And thanks for the info on the tetras. I'm not sure what we're going to do with them.
 
I have a cycled 2 gallon betta tank. I use a Red Sea Nano HOB filter on it with some extra Eheim bio-media stuffed in the filter to slow the flow. No fin rot problems at all and stable water parameters, even if I skip a water change. I do still change about 75% of the water weekly just because it's easy to do.
 
yeah i have a 2.5 that i cycled by putting 2 neons in for a day, took them out and did a small water change (1pt. maybe) now i got some endlers and two ghost shrimp and i'm planning to geta betta soon.
i got the whisper 3i on there fir filteration, used to have a whipser 5 but that was too big and sucked up the sand till it jammed.
personally if you just get a desk lamp and put it kind of close to the tank, depending on your room temp, you could keep the tank about 74-76*F
 
AquariaCentral.com