Unsure if plant is aquatic or not...grrr

Aphotic Phoenix

Graver Girl
Jun 5, 2007
585
0
0
Virginia, USA
There are several plants in my aquarium that I know aren't aquatic. They haven't died on me yet, and will be replaced with something actually aquatic once they start looking poorly.

I have a sword plant however which I'm just not sure about. Some sources say it's not aquatic, some sources say it is...and it's doing rather well (compared to the other ones). I had to split it today to give some of the newer leaves a bit more growth room and light...the original 3-4 plants has become more like 5 or 6 and the roots had spread a good 6 inches under the substrate. Granted the growth isn't explosive or anything...no CO2, ferts, and an undetermined amount of wattage because I moved some sort of compact fluorescent floor lamp over part of the tank which isn't marked for wattage.

Just thought I'd ask here before I drove half an hour just to check the label on a plant...
Has anyone had similar successful growth of a non-aquatic?
 
Some non-aquatics can live quite awhile submerged, but are sure to die. Dracaena sanderiana (often sold as Lucky Bamboo) have been known to live over a year underwater.

What was the name of this sword?
 
Picture?
 
heh...was trying to avoid showing off my horrid aquascaping but anyway...

This is about as close as I can get...there is a mild current in the tank so everything blurs when I try to take a more macro shot...
spit_image.php

Darn lazy Ottos have not been doing their job obviously!!!

And full tank shot before I split the plants up a bit...
spit_image.php

I know the ones to the side and back aren't aquatic...
 
That looks like an aquatic sword to me.

I suspect you had several plantlets started in the same pot as swords generally propogate via runners, not by splitting.

They will grow immersed or emersed, If you have a plain old amazon sword or closely related cultivar, it will get very large.

They're heavy root feeders, so either provide an occasional root tab or inject some liquid ferts into the substrate around them.
 
I suspect you had several plantlets started in the same pot as swords generally propogate via runners

Thanks for the info. ^_^ I prob. shouldn't have said "splitting" as it really was much more of an "untangling". The heavy root feeding thing also makes sense considering the pretty impressive root growth they had. I have experience with terrestrial plants since I've worked in a greenhouse before, but my aquatic plant exposure has been a bit limited.

I'm looking into replacing our hood, and rigging up some DIY CO2 in the future so as they get a bit bigger I'll attempt to move them farther back if they do start getting large.
 
Looks aquatic to me also. What name was it sold under?
 
It looks like an Amazon Sword (E. bleheri) to me, but sometimes those big chain stores sells similar-looking but non-aquatic plants. Usually in the tubes.

If it's rooting though, it should be aquatic.
 
AquariaCentral.com