Help breeding EBJD's

azharleydude

AC Members
Oct 18, 2007
45
0
0
Phoenix Arizona
:sim: Woooohoooo! After posting help for sexing my EBJD's and Severums I have found that I have hit the lottery on what I have recieved. I currently have 9 total EBJD's and 5 out of the 9 are females!! Everyone said that it is hard to get females but........ I guess I got way lucky.

So now I am asking for any advise on breeding them. I also have two blue gene Dempseys, one female and one male. How old or big do they have to be to breed and what do I have to do to help promote their breeding?

Thank you all who answered my other post and thank you in advance for anyone willing to help me now.:)
 
i think u need 1 regular female (non ebjd) and a male ebjd to actually breed or vice versa from wat i heard
 
It is my understanding that in order to get EBJD fry one would have to breed a blue to either another blue or a blue gene dempsey. I believe that if you breed to a reg dempsey you will get blue gene dempsey.
Please correct me if I am wrong anyone. This is just what I have been told and why I am asking for help.
Thank you for your responce pebble.
 
okay. . . . basic high school biology, with a twist.

regular dempseys have two copies of the color gene. both copies, let's say, are called B.
blue-gene dempseys, which carry the electric blue gene but are colored normally, have Bb (b being the recessive light-colored gene).
ebjd's carry two copies of the b gene - bb - and therefore express the color.

theoretically, it would make sense to breed two ebjd's together and get all eb fry. the "twist" is that the blue gene carries some form of genetic weakness with it, which results in high mortality of resulting fry. few, if any, will survive. this is similar to the problems in the past with the DD (double dark) gene that produces pure black angelfish.

due to the weakness when breeding two ebjd's, a more effective but time-consuming route is to breed blue gene jd's with each other or with an electric blue. while there will be a lower % of eb fry in each batch, they will overall be more likely to survive.

Breeding a standard JD with an EBJD will result in 100% Blue Gene fry.
Breeding a BGJD with another BGJD will potentially result in 25% standard jd, 50% BGJD, and 25% EBJD.
Breeding a BGJD with an EBJD will result in 50% BG and 50% EB.

Keep in mind that the Punnett Square kind of genetic diagramming is an estimation if what could/should happen, everything being equal. It is not a guarantee of what will actually happen.
 
You can breed blue x blue and get full blue off spring.
 
Actually, you need a blue gene male period, and either a regular female or blue female. Reason is the male must posses the blue gene no matter what.

No matter who you breed the Blue Gene Male with it will take up to 2-3 times before you get any EBJD's in the fry. After that your mix will be roughly 50/50 EBJD's, but all the regulars in the fry will also carry the Blue Gene in them, and they can produce EBJD fry down the line.

As for breeding size, it's the same as normal JD's at round 4" however most males will not try to breed until they reach 6".


Now you ask how do I know this, well the Blue Gene Male I have I got from a breeder friend of mine, who has been breeding EBJD's for the last couple years. His main pair are Blue Gene male, and regular Female, and his fry batches are roughly 50/50 mix, and the regular fry from the batch have the bg in them, as well as the EBJD fry.
 
not quite Mike. wataugachicken is bang on.

EBJD x JD = BGJD ( regular looking but carry the Blue Gene)

EBJD x BGJD = 50% EBJD, 50% BGJD

BGJD x BGJD - 25% EBJD, 25% JD, 50% BGJD

The sexes do not matter. Most people use a Male EBJD but there is someone who currently is using a female EBJD in his breeding program.

As wataugachicken said, breeding EBJD x EBJD would give 100% EBJD but no one has ever been able to do this. Some have had spawns but the fry always die after a few days of free swimming. Maybe as the EBJD morph gets stronger, it may be possible.
 
Wow, ok this is starting to sound complicated. I have 9 JD's in a 210 gallon tank with some severum at this time, and 2 other in a 125 with other severums. The largest is a male of about 4 inches. All others are smaller. 7 of them are EBJD's and 2 are supposivly blue gene. The blue gene are 1 male and 1 female. The remaining EBJD's are 4 males and 5 females.

So here is the million dollar questions...... Should I let them pair up on their own? Or should I seperate them into pairs with their own tank? Can you force a pair or should it happen naturally? How do I know when they pair off? Is there anything that I can do to promote them to actually breed?

This seems to be a good discussion here and I really apprieate all of your help. This topic seems to be so new that there is obviously alot of debate out there about what can be done and what can not.

Are we sure that no one has been able to breed blue to blue? Not even Jeff Rapps????? Sure wish we could get his opinion on this.
 
By the way I just wanted to ad that my one male EBJD is almost solid black, just a few blue patches on his body. I will try and get a pic of him but he is very camera shy.
 
Almost as soon as I posted that last statment I turned around to find my black ones posing for me. Please see "Black EBJD's" in gallery. Let me know what you think.
 
AquariaCentral.com