"Fishy" cycling

e_a_olson

AC Members
Mar 20, 2006
15
0
0
water_quality.png.jpg


Here's a chart of the water quality in my 20 gallon tall aquarium. I'm starting to cycle the tank with six 1" tiger barbs. My concerns are that the ammonia level is still high after a water change on 12/8/2007. I did a 2.5 gallon water change (gravel was vacuumed), and treated the water with five drops of Prime (added to the bucket before being filled with fresh water). I am also concerned that my water is high on the alkaline side (7.8), as I have read that ammonia is much more dangerous when the water is alkaline.

Should I perform another small water change? I've also read that when establishing the bacteria in the tank, you want to keep the water changes smaller because you can end up removing the bacteria from the tank with each change. Is that correct? Or is the ammonia a serious enough issue to warrant a 5 gallon (25%) water change?

Edit: I also want to mention that the water temperature is kept at 75 F. I was also wondering if a higher temperature would promote faster bacteria growth.
 
Last edited:
I just performed a 50% water change. Ammonia is back down to 0 mg/L. I will test again tomorrow, and if the water is unacceptable, perform another water change.
 
Last edited:
I just performed a 50% water change. 75% seems like a bit much to change out at once. Should I test the water immediately after performing a water change, or should I give it some time and test again tomorrow?

If you're doing a fishy cycle, there's no such thing as too many water changes. You need to keep Ammonia < .25. Remember, the beneficial bacteria is predominantly in the filter media, gravel, etc. so don't worry about removing the water.
 
Yup. And don't change your filter pads until your tank cycles, and it would also help to cut down on feeding to once every other day.:) Good luck.
 
Ummm...what is the ammonia reading on your tap water...?

If you are using Prime, it will bind the ammonia into a non-toxic form, but it will still be available for your bacteria.

The water changes will not affect the cycle.
 
Ammonia readings for my tap water are 0 mg/L.

I will cut the feedings back to every other day as SM suggested, and perform enough water changes to keep the ammonia below .25 mg/L..
 
Oddly, I can no longer edit my original post. I wanted to change the url of the chart to a permalink, but I'll display it in this post instead. This chart will update as I input new data. As you can see, the ammonia level is down to .5 mg/L, and that is after another 50% water change this evening.

pub


Should I do another 50% change now? That would leave 25% of the water from yesterday in the tank. I'm a bit leary of doing so at this hour, but I suppose I should if I need to get the ammonia level down to less than .25 mg/L.
 
At .5 ammonia, I'd do a 75% change....
 
AquariaCentral.com