fishie111
01-03-2008, 9:43 AM
I have 3 tanks that I want to convert to live plants and I'm looking for advice on a good substrate to start with. I want to stay low-tech. I'm planning to upgrade my lights from the stock hoods to the AH Supply kits (36 watts for two 20H's and 55 watts for the 28G).
Here's are the plants that I ordered (several are rhizome plants or floaters so substrate doesn't matter):
Crypts: 1 Wendtii Green, 1 Wendtii Red, 1 Lutea
Stem Plants: Ludwigia Repens, Rotala Indica, Water Wisteria, Camboda, Anacharis
Swords: 1 Amazon Sword, 1 Marble Queen Sword
Floaters: Hornwort
Java Fern: 2 Lace variety, 3x3 mat of standard variety
Anubias: 1 Nana, 1 Hastafolia, 1 Barteri (growing on driftwood)
I want to try a few things and see what I like and what grows well.
One of the 20H's has not been set-up yet. One is in operation with a 1in layer of natural colored aquarium gravel from Walmart that I can either add to or remove. I bought regular Este natural-colored gravel for the other 20H, but I can return this. The 28G is in operation with just a scattered layer of 1-2 in diameter riverstone covering the bare bottom (it houses goldies)- I'd like to keep the stone, but would put substrate under it for the plants.
So, my question is, with these types of plants, should I go with plain aquarium gravel, should I invest in something specifically for plants (and if so, Flourite or Eco-Complete?), or should I try to find some kind of finer particle in a presumably cheaper, non-plant specific substrate (play sand?).
I've read so many opinions online that I am not at all sure what to do!! My plants will arrive tomorrow or Saturday- and I can't get anything plant-specific locally- I'd have to mail order it (I could set up a 10G holding tank for the plants while I wait).
Here's are the plants that I ordered (several are rhizome plants or floaters so substrate doesn't matter):
Crypts: 1 Wendtii Green, 1 Wendtii Red, 1 Lutea
Stem Plants: Ludwigia Repens, Rotala Indica, Water Wisteria, Camboda, Anacharis
Swords: 1 Amazon Sword, 1 Marble Queen Sword
Floaters: Hornwort
Java Fern: 2 Lace variety, 3x3 mat of standard variety
Anubias: 1 Nana, 1 Hastafolia, 1 Barteri (growing on driftwood)
I want to try a few things and see what I like and what grows well.
One of the 20H's has not been set-up yet. One is in operation with a 1in layer of natural colored aquarium gravel from Walmart that I can either add to or remove. I bought regular Este natural-colored gravel for the other 20H, but I can return this. The 28G is in operation with just a scattered layer of 1-2 in diameter riverstone covering the bare bottom (it houses goldies)- I'd like to keep the stone, but would put substrate under it for the plants.
So, my question is, with these types of plants, should I go with plain aquarium gravel, should I invest in something specifically for plants (and if so, Flourite or Eco-Complete?), or should I try to find some kind of finer particle in a presumably cheaper, non-plant specific substrate (play sand?).
I've read so many opinions online that I am not at all sure what to do!! My plants will arrive tomorrow or Saturday- and I can't get anything plant-specific locally- I'd have to mail order it (I could set up a 10G holding tank for the plants while I wait).