PDA

View Full Version : Just Goes To Show Ya. Testing For Calcium.



ReefSparky
02-06-2008, 7:31 PM
I've been testing for Ca since I decided to go reef Nov 1st. I could never get Ca into the 400s, and I decided to buy a 2-part solution. After adding it as the instructions say, Ca elevation was negligible. I was convinced it would be weeks before I saw an accumulation of Ca sufficient to show a real difference in testing. Since Nov 1st I have been testing for Ca with the same test kit. Since I purchased the 2 part solution, I've been testing almost daily with the same results.

I use a Ca testing kit with 3 fluids. First is 7 drops, then the second bottle is 3 drops. The 3rd bottle is the titration bottle, whose number of drops determines what the ppm of Ca is.

What's kinda puzzled me is that the manual for testing states that the addition of the 3 drops of reagent #2 will cause a pink tinge, and if it doesn't; the Ca was below 200ppm. Well, all this time the introduction of the second fluid caused a VERY dark pink. Since day one this has been the case and has never changed.

So two days ago, I bought a package of epsom salts to bring up my Magnesium values in the hopes that this would solve my inability to raise my Ca. Yesterday evening I added 1/3 cu. to my RO/DI topoff water; along with 10ml of part A solution for Ca, and tested. No change. This evening I added another 1/4 cu. of epsom salts and tested again.

For the first time since I began testing, the addition of the second bottle's reagent only caused a SLIGHT pinkish tinge instead of the expected DARK pink. I thought to myself, THIS IS IT! My calcium is getting to where it's supposed to be!!!

I opened the third bottle, and started counting my drops. After 3 drops air sputtered out of the bottle. I was out of #3 solution!!! It was like watching the Superbowl and having a power outage at the 2 min. warning! It was like ordering dessert and getting kicked out of the restaurant before it came!

It was like. . .like having to wait until tomorrow to buy another Ca. test kit!!! http://www.3reef.com/forums/images/smilies/smiley.gifhttp://www.3reef.com/forums/images/smilies/shocked.gifhttp://www.3reef.com/forums/images/smilies/smiley.gif

I'll keep everyone posted.

Ace25
02-06-2008, 8:13 PM
Out of curiousity, why was your CA so low to begin with? Just because of the mg deficiency? I find it extremely hard to get my CA to drop below 400. I do not have SPS corals and I do a lot of water changes.

ReefSparky
02-06-2008, 8:36 PM
Out of curiousity, why was your CA so low to begin with? Just because of the mg deficiency? I find it extremely hard to get my CA to drop below 400. I do not have SPS corals and I do a lot of water changes.

If I only knew. ??? I use Instant Ocean, and I've also used Kent salt mixes. They're both about 360 ppm Ca. immediately after mixing. To date I've not been able to get it above that.

Hopefully tomorrow I'll see that's all history. If that's the case, then your answer would be "Yes. It was just the Magnesium defficiency."

cav
02-06-2008, 8:50 PM
Have you tried using a differnt test kit like the salifert one?

cav
02-06-2008, 9:01 PM
Ive just seen this post somewhere else!

scootrnerd
02-06-2008, 9:06 PM
i have that same tesy kit for ca by nutrafin and the colors on the box look NOTHING like the actual colors in the tube! i just follow the instructions and when it changes to a purplish color i X 20 to get my ppm

ReefSparky
02-07-2008, 3:50 PM
Ive just seen this post somewhere else!

Yes. I post copies in about 5 forums, as I love a wide range of answers. I feel the more input, the better my final decision.