ANYONE EXPERIENCED CLEANER SHRIMP WALKING ON TOP OF YOUR LPS AND KILL IT???

angelfishlover

Angelfish and Discus freak!!!

Mar 8, 2007

210

0

0

34

Singapore

Real Name

Faiz

• Feb 9, 2008

• #1

Hi I would like to ask if anyone has ever had a cleaner shrimp which walks over ur coral and kill it after several days???My true octos jus melt off.It has been opening but after few days saw the shrimp walking on top of it.Now i wasted Sg$20 getting that coral which is quite expensive in my homeland.For US dollars think it is around 35 bucks.

 

Grins

Girl Reefer...we do exist

May 1, 2007

10,449

0

0

60

Charlotte, NC

• Feb 9, 2008

• #2

I doubt the cleaner killed it by walking on top of it. They'll simply withdraw if irritated. I'd suspect something else was the cause of death.

 

T

tamableanimal

AC Members

Aug 26, 2007

228

0

0

59

Caro, Michigan

• Feb 9, 2008

• #3

As Grins said. Unless it was staying right on it for 3-5 days forcing it to stay retracted. The shrimp won't hurt it.

 

Catpicklesdog

Hindsight is a wonderful thing!

Feb 25, 2007

4,210

0

0

55

Telford, UK

Real Name

Alison

• Feb 9, 2008

• #4

I've got to agree with the others. My cleaner shrimp walk over all of my corals (and anemone) and I haven't lost any. Are sure there isn't a nudi on it?

 

angelfishlover

Angelfish and Discus freak!!!

Mar 8, 2007

210

0

0

34

Singapore

Real Name

Faiz

• Feb 10, 2008

• #5

I didn't find a nudi on it.All my other corals are still alive.I got 2 bubble corals,1 favia,1 cluster acro,1staghorn acro frag,1 3 headed blasto and 1 digi frag.The frogspawn suddenly died.I still have the bones of the frogspawn.

 

saltydunc

AC Members

Apr 11, 2007

1,027

0

36

56

dundee scotland

• Feb 10, 2008

• #6

never heard of shrimps killing corals.....i would guess its something else.....water issues maybe.

 

Grins

Girl Reefer...we do exist

May 1, 2007

10,449

0

0

60

Charlotte, NC

• Feb 10, 2008

• #7

There are some aggressive corals on that list. Might have been chemical warfare.

 

angelfishlover

Angelfish and Discus freak!!!

Mar 8, 2007

210

0

0

34

Singapore

Real Name

Faiz

• Feb 12, 2008

• #8

OMG u might be right.Then which one u think might have killed it???Bubble corals is 4 inches away.The nearest is the acro and favia.

 

Reefscape

I shoot people with a Canon

Staff member

Nov 8, 2006

18,481

8

89

Staffordshire, UK

seethroughmylens.co.uk

Real Name

Blinky

• Feb 12, 2008

• #9

The nearest corals are both agressive...Especially the favia, more so than the acro...could be the answer to your question...

 

Grins

Girl Reefer...we do exist

May 1, 2007

10,449

0

0

60

Charlotte, NC

• Feb 12, 2008

• #10

And I've seen the sweepers on a bubble get more than 4" too.