Snail killers

oscaremmy

Keeper of the Frogdog
Feb 27, 2008
379
0
0
East Central Indiana, USA
Okay, I admit it - I have problems directly killing the pond snails in my new 10g planted tank. AC member Irishspy has warned me to eradicate them before they take over my tank and eat my plants. For now I have put two of the three that were in the tank (still looking for the other fugitive), plus a batch of their eggs into a clean half-gallon jar of water with some food, while I give this some thought. The jar is a kind of holding cell while these kids await trial but maybe it will also double as death row.

Not wishing to release these snails into the stream at the foot of our land, I have a dilemma that many of you will find laughable, because I am sure experienced aquarists would not hesitate to crush these as live food for my other fish...I'd feel guilty about doing that though - you know, all God's creatures, etc...

But I have no problem paying for a hit man or, more correctly, a 'hit fish' who will undertake the contract in return for food and shelter and maybe a new identity to elude the FBI (Fish Bureau of Investigation).

Thing is this; I wanted this heavily planted tank to house serpae or neon tetras and dwarf corys, because of the peaty substrate I have used. If I hire a hit fish, it would need to co-exist with these other breeds after all snails were slain in cold blood, so I need a fish which is not a psychopath. It is a 10g tank, so no Oscars! (Anyway, oscars are remorseless assassins, as I know from past experience).

Suggestions? I considered hiring a dwarf gourami...would this co-exist peacefully with neons and corys?
 
The snails will not eat healthy plants, only the decaying plant matter. They should only overpopulate your tank if their is ample food source (either too much fish food, or unhealthy plants). They can usually be controlled by increasin wc's and gravel vacs and reducing feeding. Hope that this helps. I don't really think there is any community fish that you could add to a 10g to eat the snails.
 
Not a lot of choices for snail eaters in such a small tank that you wish to house other fish in. Sorry to say that your options are outright killing of the snails yourself or living with them. Crushing them as treats for cories isn't as bad as it sounds. And they will eventually sort out their population by themselves as msjinkzd mentions. They only overpopulate with excess food. And they won't eat healthy plants.

I love having snails in my planted tanks. They eat any leftover food, eat bits of algae and make for a more diverse ecosystem. They are great survivors as well.
 
That makes me feel better...I haven't seen any plant damage with the snails in there, even in my more established tank. I have watched them vacuuming the silty peat off the leaves in the new tank, leaving clean leaves behind, so these kids should be safe to return to their new home. What about bioload though? How many pond snails equals one inch of fish? Given a choice, I'd take fish. If they will help to balance the tank by eating decaying plant matter, they can stay alive.
 
I don't really factor them into the bioload as their population will fluctuate with the food supply. You do not have to pick between fish and pond snails. My advice is to just be diligent with your maintenance and it will be fine.
 
I don't really factor them into the bioload as their population will fluctuate with the food supply. You do not have to pick between fish and pond snails. My advice is to just be diligent with your maintenance and it will be fine.


Great...I can hear cheering from the jar.:clap::y220e::clap::y220e::clap:
 
Thanks from the inmates, with pics

We are back in our comfy home now, with plenty of space to stretch our leg and enough food to last several lifetimes :)

snail2 22 March 2008.JPG snail home.JPG snail1 22 March 2008.JPG new tank 22 March 2008.JPG
 
Nice tank...and I think I see him cheering! :D
 
AquariaCentral.com