EMERGENCY!!!

james123

AC Members
Dec 23, 2008
79
0
0
tank 55gal 40lb live rock cpr bakpak skimmer 1 clownfish 1 yellow tang 4 damsels hermit crabs 1 coral banded shrimp. water params amm.=0 ph=8.1 nitrITE=0 Nitrate= 10.

So everything has been fine with my tank until yesterday i addd a new koralia 2 powerhead that i got off of ebay and tonight i was testing my water and i discovered my tang WAS DEAD!!! system has been stable for several months now but my colt coral and button polyps are shrinking by the minute. All of my other fish seem to be in hiding and not really swimming around alot. This may be due to the fact that i had to move some of my rock around to get the tang out, but i cant think of anything else that could be wrong than the powerhead i got had some kind of contaminant on it that i cant test for. i don't know if i should hurry up and do a water change right away or if the stress of getting the tang out is why everything is acting so weird. I don't want to stress things out even more...WHAT SHOULD I DO?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?
 
It is difficult to say what actually happened. In any case, the odds of the problem actually being the Koralia is extremely slim. Do a large water change and test your parameters again.
 
well i did a water change...parameters are normal but everything is still acting like it's in shock. but everything is still alive(BARELY), so i guess i'll do another water change today.
 
Perhaps check the Koralia for stay voltage?

How long was the Tang in the tank prior and how much nori/seaweed was he getting in his diet?

Damsel's have a habit of acting like little demons, especially if there's nobody around to keep them in line. Yellow Tang's on the other hand will become stressed by their own reflection especially if they don't have a space of their own. Being that they are constant grazers by nature this will also cause stress if they don't have a regular (3+ times a day depending on size) source of greens.

It's possible that the damsels were bullying the Tang to the point it died from the stress. I'd suggest thinking twice about keeping those damsels around - they aren't a problem in all cases, but I would say the majority of them do cause problems.

Your water conditions look okay - ideally nitrates should be at zero for the best health of corals, but a reading of 10 isn't uncommon. Are you using a good, reliable test kit to be sure the readings are accurate? I'd say the two events, while quite a coincidence. are probably unrelated.

How long have the corals been in your tank? Did they thrive prior to this, or have they been slowly degrading since putting them in?
 
well ive been doing daily 10% water changes since the initial problem and everything appears to be returning to normal now. The tang was getting plenty of seaweed, by the way, all tank inhabitants have been doing great for several months now up to this point. I threw the koralia away, though, not taking a chance on losing my whole tank over 40 bucks. water conditions good, although it's hard to gett a good reading while doing daily water changes, but once it stabilizes i'll fine tune the Ph. Thanks for all the help, guess i'll be shipping off some damsels and trying to get some other fish.
 
damsels are the fish from hell, while they are active and easy to care for they are mean. I had 4 in my 120 gallon tank and when i would clean the tank the smallest one of them all used to attack my hand.

While most fish respect "The great hand that feeds and moves rocks" this little guy was having no part of that, the first few times he nipped at my hand i couldnt figure out what was going on, then i stuck my arm in the tank and just watched only to find out it was the smallest fish in the tank!



it really was a pretty looking fish, but after i took him to the LFS and they gave me $8 for him; i am sure he is someone else's problem now. LOL

Good to hear your tank is returning to a stable state again.
 
Here is a speculation on the issue. WHAT IF...those PH's had some left over chemical residue on them...inside them that is. Where the wire goes in that also gets water inside the casing to.

Another what if...what iff the motor was going bad and maybe some metals were seeping into the water.? Possible? I know sump pumps going bad do it..but PH i dont know.

ONe more wild speculation:
Stray current...but you would know by invert death on mass...like your snails... stray current wipes them fast... plus you should know by when you place your hand in the tnak and feel a slight tingle...almost like when a cleaner shrimp starts checking out your fingers.

Sorry for the losses....
 
AquariaCentral.com