Unless your tank is 60G or less I would get the 24W. However I use the 9W on my 60 on a wall timer 12 hours per day at night and it works great and my 60 tank faces a northern window across the room. All my other 24W (4) work great on my larger tank all on 12 hour wall timers. Only occasionally will I have to turn them on 24/7 if I know in advance a bloom is about to be triggered by some medications or new sand.
The only down side is they are not portable like some can be made and again if tuned properly, but who want to be playing musical chairs with tank equipment?