PDA

View Full Version : how many female bettas in a planted 10 gallon?



Lightning Bug
02-05-2010, 4:40 PM
im debating about turning my 10 gallon into a betta sorority. if i go that route how many should i put in there?

jbradt
02-05-2010, 4:41 PM
I don't think more than 1... unless it's VERY heavily planted. Female bettas can be as agressive as the males.

WandaA
02-05-2010, 8:12 PM
I have 6. They get along fine as long as you have lots of places for them to seperate.

RazzleFish
02-05-2010, 8:14 PM
I would say 1. Like JB said, females can be just as agressive as males.

halfmoonplakat
02-05-2010, 8:37 PM
6+
You just have to give them a couple of weeks to nip each other. Keep the water as clean as possible to let their fins heal because they will nip to establish a pecking order.
Female bettas will most likely not be too agressive unless they have been housed alone since birth

Michwol42795
02-05-2010, 8:47 PM
I've heard of tanks like that with many Females in one tank, but I would still recommend just the one.

THE V
02-05-2010, 11:05 PM
I've got 5 in a 10 gallon tank planted tank right now. When I first added them in together they ripped into each other pretty good. All of their fins were really beat up but once they figured out their pecking order they get along great. I'm currently looking for a 70-80 corner pentagon tank to plant and put 20 or so of them into.

Beta's fins heal up amazingly fast. Damage that on other species might take several months to heal, I've seen heal up in a week or two.

Snuffleupagus
02-06-2010, 2:40 AM
try to get more than 5,if you go the multiples route.It helps spread the aggression,so none of he fish get picked on too bad.

Taysius
02-06-2010, 3:50 AM
Some say lots some say single. It just depends on the bettas, just like when you house males with other fish IMO. Years ago I had 2 females with a few guppies in a 2 gallon tank. Now that I know more about fish I would NEVER recommend that. I am just mentioning it to say that no one picked on anyone in that tank.

I would say that if you decide to get around 5ish, get them all at the same time and be prepared to make changes to the set up if need be.

Michwol42795
02-06-2010, 7:57 AM
Some say lots some say single. It just depends on the bettas, just like when you house males with other fish IMO. Years ago I had 2 females with a few guppies in a 2 gallon tank. Now that I know more about fish I would NEVER recommend that. I am just mentioning it to say that no one picked on anyone in that tank.

I would say that if you decide to get around 5ish, get them all at the same time and be prepared to make changes to the set up if need be.

I agree, Bettas have a wide range of personalities. You could try it but be ready with an extra tank to separate them or be prepared to take them back.

iLunar
02-06-2010, 8:03 AM
I'd say 6 so the aggression will be evened throughout the group.

b.greene
02-06-2010, 1:57 PM
I have had 7 together in a 29g. Five were sisters and 2 were added at the same time as the sisters. All but one got along very well. She had to be moved. The tank was absolutely beautiful - very peaceful and slow moving fish. Perfect for my bedroom :-)

thebetta
02-06-2010, 2:06 PM
I agree, Bettas have a wide range of personalities. You could try it but be ready with an extra tank to separate them or be prepared to take them back.
But if you have a larger group the agression will be spread out
Although female bettas may have different personalities, if you find them at a pet store, where thhey have been exposed to other bettas, you should be fine. At a breeders, they will probably share a tank with other female bettas (which a lot of breeders have done IME which I see when I go to buy bettas from them) due to lack of space
I agree with the person in this thread who said that female bettas will only be horribly agressive if you isolate them since birth
If they show signs of agression you do not have to take them back...just give them a few weeks to establish a pecking order
Remember 4+ FEMALE bettas together= peace and love (if you let them establish a pecking order)
This doesnèt work for males though, although they have different personalities just as the females do

Lillyan
02-06-2010, 2:09 PM
I have read 2-3 Gallons per Betta is required, plus a ton of hiding spots, at least one for each fish. The hiding places should also be all over the tank, not just in a corner or along the back wall. Since this will make it harder for them to make a quick getaway.
Also, you should introduce all females to the tank at the same time, so no one fish has had a chance to claim anything. Fighting shouldn't be too rough. If there is a particular girl that is a bully, try separating her for a few days, then reintroduce. If this fails more than 2/3x, you should find her a new home.

thebetta
02-06-2010, 2:21 PM
I agree with the above
You should wait a couple days first before re-introduction and re-removal

Lightning Bug
02-07-2010, 12:19 AM
well first off, thnx for all the feedback guys :)

so 5 to 6 is the number most everyone seems to be agreeing on. that can work for me.

im glad yall said something about not introducing a betta that has been by itself all its life... cause iv got a female crowntail that i was thinking about adding, but she's had her own place for about a year now so i think im gona just leave her where she is. plus i love her too much to see her have to go through the first few weeks of nipping, even if she would end up being the head fishy since her isolation (and then intrusive sorority situation) would probably make her so fighting mad she'd rip and shred better than any of the others.

as far as well planted goes, itll be well planted. its already pretty nice as it is with 2 good pieces of bogwood, java moss, anubias, a sword plant and a little java fern. im already wanting to add more plants anyway so that shouldnt be a problem. there is an open space for swimming, i could probably turn it into a spiral val forest.

any other thoughts?

Michwol42795
02-07-2010, 8:54 AM
Sounds like good plants to me, but since you're adding so many fish at once I'd make sure they have some established filter media set up in the tank so it doesn't go into a cycle.

Lightning Bug
02-08-2010, 9:34 PM
yep. its established :)