eSHa Oodinex

[sapgranth25]

hello there,
has anyone used this product eSHa Oodinex to combat white spot?

is this product 100% safe with soft corals live rock inverts fan worms hermits turbo snails?

I'm currently using it within my mini 29gal reef tank to treat white spot also I'm adding seachems garlic to the fishes food has anyone ever had success with eSHa Oodinex also has anyone ever had problems when using this product with there inverts are corals

also how long dose the 3day treatment last?
advice please

[sapgranth25]

anyone please

[Crown Royal]

By "white spot" I assume you mean marine ich (cryptocaryon irritans).

The only two scientifically documented ways of eradicating this creature are both NOT reefsafe: copper and hyposalinity.

Until someone shows me a controlled study indicating otherwise, any "reef safe" marine ich treatments are hit and miss at best, dangerous at worst.

[Crown Royal]

Just occured to me by the name of the product that it may be geared towards amyloodinium or "marine velvet" rather than ich. Similar in appearance, velvet looks less like grains of salt on the fish and more like a dull white velvety sheen.

You must first determine which parasite you have before proceeding with treatment. Of the two, ich is the more challenging parasite.

Here's a nice article on velvet:

http://www.reefkeeping.com/issues/2004-07/sp/feature/index.php

Links to Steven Pro's excellent 2-parter on marine ich is contained in this article at the bottom of the introduction (just before "Treatment Option 1: Natural Immunity")

[sapgranth25]

BUT THE PRODUCT eSHa Oodinex says it cures marine ich velvet & many more fungus parasites

that's why i wanna know if people have used it & success with eSHa Oodinex
but thank you with your help & replying