hi guys newbie help needed on new marine set up

Neenie

Upgrade has arrived people!!
Jan 19, 2007
176
0
0
Romford, UK
I Posted already in the introduction section, someone mentioned I should try posting here? thanks for looking....

Hi guys (from the UK) :help:

We have been browsing your forum and you have loads of info and we appreciate all the help we can get.
We have a Trigon 190, set up for marine, been running with internal filter and external Eheim filter for two weeks now. Added cured live rock last week, have lots of coraline algae few bristle worms, tube worms, snails and lots of little shrimpy things.. all doing well, we also had a Scutus elephant snail as a hitchiker. We've left him in as he seems to be eating the algae from the glass and not harming anything.

We have a couple of questions if anyone can help?

Is this snail ok to keep, we like him!! we are thinking of getting hermits eventually and hope that they won't clash??

Also water has been stable for the last week

PH 8.0
Nitrite 0.2 down to 0 now
SG 1023
Ammonia 0
Temp 25

LFS says it's ok to add a fish as the water is ok, we are limited to the amount of fish due to the size of the tank and didn't want to add something at the start that is not on our wish list just to get the tank cycling, so really wanted to know other than a Chromis/Damsel what would be a good 1st fish to put in.

Thanks in advance for your advice guys, picture of tank so far and of our hitchiker the scutus.....

tank 013.jpg tank 012.jpg
 
Last edited:
Hi there and Welcome..

First off, the Scutus is fine to be in your tank, its just an algae eater..It wont clash with your cleanup crew..

On your parameters;;

PH 8.0 - Raise this to 8.4
Nitrite 0.2 down to 0 now - this is good
SG 1023 - This is good
Ammonia 0 - This is good
Temp 25 - Good also..

You also need to be testing your nitRATES, as this test is an indecation of how much fish poop is in the tank..

How much length of fish can you keep, well, 46 gallon tank, you shold be ok with about 10 inches of adult grown fish..Your is the same size as my fish only..

My opinion on your first fish to have would be a pair of clown fish..Awsome fish, great personality, funny and interact with you loads...

I would not have a damsel anywhere near my tank...ok when they first go in the tank, but turn into nasty swines and believe me, you aint gonna be able to catch the devils when you realise they have got to go...

Other than the clowns, i would go with a gobby or a blenny, look on the internet at the different varieties, research and ensure you can meet the fishes needs..

How much live rock do you have in the tank at the moment?

Oh, and its nice to see another uk mariner on here...

Niko
 
thanks

Hi Niko

Thanks for the advice.... do I need to test for Nitrate as there is no fish in there at the moment? although the snail poops of course......

Also how do we raise the PH slightly?

we have about 20kg of live rock, we were thinking of clowns so it's ok to put a pair in to start with? younger the better i guess? visiting LFS tomorrow.. can't wait. spent the last week looking at the rock and all stuff on it, seems to have replaced the TV!

appreciate your help.. thanks, books all seem to contradict each other.

Neenie
 
Thanks for the advice.... do I need to test for Nitrate as there is no fish in there at the moment? although the snail poops of course......

NitrATE (NO3) is a byproduct of nitrITE, which in turn is a byproduct of ammonia. So, even if you don't have any fish in your tank, when the nitrITES are broken down by the bacteria, they will create NO3. So, yes - it is essential to test for NO3. High levels of NO3 is not good for the tank or its inhabitants ... it is stressful on the fish, and will cause algae blooms in your tank. In a new setup such as yours, it is okay if you NO3 registers at ~10-15 ppm. Ideally, in the long run, you want to try to keep NO3 as close to 0 as possible.

Also how do we raise the PH slightly?

I believe this question was answered above ... your LFS probably carries a PH buffer which should help you raise your tank's PH slowly.

we have about 20kg of live rock, we were thinking of clowns so it's ok to put a pair in to start with? younger the better i guess? visiting LFS tomorrow.. can't wait. spent the last week looking at the rock and all stuff on it, seems to have replaced the TV!

As far as LR goes, it is recommended to have at least 1.5-2.0 lbs of LR per gallon for optimal filtration and overall health of the tank. Right now, you're at about 44lbs or 0.97 lbs per gal. So, you should definitely look into adding some more LR to your tank. You don't have to add all LR cos that will get really expensive .... unless ofcourse you can addord it. You can use some base rock, which is "dead" and stack the LR on and around it. The critters from the LR will eventually move over to the base rock and turn it into LR as well!

As far as your question about the clowns goes ... yes, it is recommended to add the pair at once. Smaller the better since neither would have had a chance to convert to a female yet ... that way they'll be well acquanited with the tank and each other before one decides to change sexes.

Just out of curiosity .... you mention that your LFS mentioned that it was okay to add fish to your tank. However, have you seen the cycle complete for yourself? ie. the ammonia spike and fall and the nitrITE spike and fall? If not, you might want to stress your tank to see if it has indeed completed the cycle. The last thing you want to do is to add fish only to cause a cycle with them in there.

One last thing ... even though its not necessary to do so, I would recommend adding all the LR before you start adding fish. This is just in case some of the LR has become uncured while sitting at your LFS ... adding uncured LR to your tank WILL create another cycle.

appreciate your help.. thanks, books all seem to contradict each other.

Neenie


Not a problem! We're here to help ... do feel free to ask any questions you might have.

Cheers!
Yash
 
Hi

Hi Yash

Thanks a lot for your reply......

Hadn't done the nitrate test so as of this evening the tests are

SG 1023
PH 8.0 still
Nitrite 0
Nitrate 5ppm
Ammonia 0
Temp 26 c


since adding the cured live rock last saturday I must admit the readings haven't peaked on Monday the nitrite was 0.05 on Tuesday went down to 0.02 then wednesday down to 0 where it has stayed..

do you think the tank hasn't cycled at all? if not how to we test it please? as the last thing I want to do is add fish if all is not ok. Plus if the tank hasn't peaked and it needs to peak will this affect the critters and the scutus???

Also by your calculations we need about another 8kg of live rock, is this still so even though we have the internal Juwel filter and the external Eheim filters running??

sorry so many questions but want to get things right from the start and want happy fish of course. :)

Thanks again....

Neenie
 
Hi Neenie,

It is possible that your tank might not have cycled. It depends largely on the amount of bacteria you have in/on your rock. If it is plenty, you might never see a spike. How have you cycled your tank? Did you just add the LR and that’s it? If so, it certainly is a good idea test to see if your tank has indeed cycled. Have a glance at the Cycling Method and Procedures sticky HERE. In the second half of method 1, you’ll see the procedure for testing your tank for the cycle. I did it and it worked out perfectly for me. You didn’t mention an ammonia spike … did you see one at all? Let me know if you have any detailed questions about the “testing the cycle” part … I’ll be more than happy to go over it in detail.

If your tank has not completely cycled, and it causes spikes after you add livestock, it will certainly affect them … how much depends on how severe your spikes are … small spikes won’t do much harm at all, but a severe spike could really harm them.

The best form of filtration in a marine tank is LR itself! If you have enough LR and a nice sand bed, you don’t need any external filtration :) The rock and sand will take care of the filtration for you! Pretty nice eh? Though, if you are planning on using a filter in any case, you could get by with a little less LR than the recommended amount.

Don’t worry about asking questions … there’s no such thing as too many questions … the more you ask, the more informed you’ll be … and the healthier your tank will end up! I’d much rather people ask questions before than jump into something only to find out they goofed up! Also given the expenses involved in the marine hobby, it will be better on your wallet too if you do your research beforehand.

Let us know if you have any more questions.

Cheers!
Yash
 
AquariaCentral.com