I totally missed it until JB pointed it out in our townie chat. I knew he was JB after the first day, then when he almost RCed by coming out calling Wiz the high priest I was like omg, this is not JB, I'm playing with a noob.
Ok, so our plan was doomed to fail. What are the chances we'd investigate the High Priest and y'all would investigate the Prophet on night 1...pretty crazy.
When he melted down, I looked back to a post he had right before nightfall. When I re-read it (the one about him feeling like a god if he was right) I realized he was a misguided townie and pulled my vote from him. :nilly: The shame of it is he did well until that whole breakdown.
So the whole reason HH came out as the herbalist was that we were hoping to keep him from being hit since it was obvious he was a PR (and scum tried to hit him night 2 but I blocked it). We were hoping the scum would think Tree was the prophet and move to hit him night 3 so I could protect him...