I have a bunch of leather toadstools all over. I have oine that is very big, to big, and is starting to tear apart kind of. One piece broke off and drifted to another rock, will it root and grow up again, or will it die, and should I remove it?
It should grow a new toadstool. Keep an eye on it and make sure it doesn't start to rot, other than that leave it alone (or use a frag method to attch it to ruble so you can place it later) and enjoy your new coral. I would also check your water params as in some but not all cases this can be a survival attempt when they are upset about something in the water.
Probably is but I would still sugest running the tests, maybe I am paranoid but I run water tests any time anything in my tank looks funny or acts weird in any way. Better safe than sorry when dealing with a box of water that has thousands of dollars worth of hard earned money in it.
I agree, what I meant by params being fine is I tested them last night. I knew the piece was going to break off I was just not sure when. So I was curious to know if that would be ok and would root and grow a new one.
This is actually how we ended up with one of the toadstool leathers in our tank. One of the LFSs by us has a nice white toadstool leather and it just dropped a small piece off one day, which started to grow. When it got to be about the size of a quarter, we asked if we could buy it (since he surely wasn't going to frag the larger one and the larger one isn't for sale). He cut it off the rock and sold it to us. It's growing very well in our tank and actually has the nicest shape out of any of the toadstool leathers in our tank. The guy at the LFS told us that toadstools will just drop a frag every now and then once they get to be large enough and conditions are right.