I'm really leaning toward the first picture one, but I try to never buy something without knowing what it is and doing a serious amount of research first. My first step was to find some IDs. They just got both in today i think so the tags weren't even posted yet, which is why I didn't have any verification on what they were. But I think they usually sell their frags for $25-$56 depending on sizing and type.
I wish the photos had turned out better. They both had these mouth like things in their center and on the first photo one the mouth is really bright!
Are you fairly certain the one is a plate coral?