ID These?

I *think* that they're Silver Dollars, but I'm honestly not 100% sure.


If the pictures don't help here is my description:

Large eyes, body roughly a quarter and a half in diameter, fins that are small and pointed. Bottom fins have a slight orange tinge. The fish are rather thin and somewhat boney (can see their spine and organs in the ripples of scales). They are solid silver in color and don't seem to be able to close their mouths all the way. They *seem* to have pointed teeth along the inner lip, but I can't tell exactly.

They were fish some friends of my mother needed to get rid of and, thinking them Silver Dollars, I accepted (along with 4 black skirt tetra and a common pleco[tiny pleco right now]). I'm no longer 100% sure now they they're in my tank.

SnakeIce said:

Agreed on previous identification. You might consider other accomodations for them, they view a planted tank as a salad, and it will be eaten.

Click to expand...

Yeah, I knew they were herbivores when I accepted them from my moms friend, but they haven't actually shown any interest in the plants at all - the tank they used to be in had literally just barebones decor (a fake stone ruin and like 2 fake plants in a tall hex) so I'm not even sure they know what plants are yet. If they start chowing down on the plants I'll shift them into my 40g or maybe rehome them to a fish store.

Thanks for confirming the ID everyone! These poor fish were in fairly bad condition when I picked them up (having only ever been fed flake -food) but I hope to get them eating their veggies soon enough - they inhale flakes and algae wafers like no one's business.

Looks to be the first picture, Byron. Thanks again everyone