Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 16
  1. #1
    Senior Member joephys's Avatar
    Usergroup
    AC Members
    Join Date
    Dec 2005
    Last Activity
    12-13-2008 6:16 AM
    Posts
    768

    Physics of the fish tank

    Welcome to my article on physics of the fish tank. I should start out saying that you could easily keep fish with out actually knowing any of this. It is however, in my opinion, interesting and of some value in understanding some of the aspects of aquaria. I have included some examples for tank sizes of 10,29, and 55 gallons, since they seem to be the most common. If you donít have a tank that size you have to do the calculations youíre self. Sorry. Here is my rough table of contents:

    1. Volume
    2. Weight
    3. Pressure
    4. Stress on glass
    5. Buoyancy
    6. More about pressure, including gravel vacís and pythons.
    7. A little bit about electricity. (power usage and cost calculations)
    8. How fast the tank cools.
    9. More than you ever wanted to know about light
    10. Those whacky refracting fishies

    Ok, enough of that, time for the relevant stuff.

    1.
    Just how much water is in my tank?
    This question is asked a lot, so here it is.
    For a rectangle tank, you need to measure the length (L), width (W) and height (H) of the tank, then multiply them together. Volume (V)=LxWxH

    Here are some examples for common tanks.

    10 gallon:

    L= 20 in V=20x10x12
    W= 10 in V=2400 cu.in.
    H= 12 in

    29 gallon:
    L=30 in V=30x12x18
    W=12 in V=6480 cu.in
    H= 18 in

    55 gallon:
    L=48 V= 48x13x20
    W=13 V=12480 cu.in.
    H=20

    For some other odd shaped tanks:

    Hex (all sides same length):
    Find the length of a side (L)
    Find the distance from the center of one flat side, to the opposite flat side (W).
    Find the height of the tank (H).
    V = 3xLxWxH

    Cylinder:
    Find the distance across the tank and divide by 2 (R).
    Find the height of the tank (H).
    V= 3.14 x R^2 x H (Note: R^2=R squared, or RxR)

    Bow fronts can be difficult to measure. If the bow is perfectly circular or parabolic then it maybe possible to calculate the volume, but it is a lot of work and more easily done in different coordinates. I donít want to get into that since I said that I would keep the math on the easier side.

    For volume in gallons you multiply the volume in cubic what ever (inches in the examples) by a water volume constant (B). For inches B= .0043 For feet B = 7.5, thus, gallons=VxB

    Examples:

    10 gallons:
    G= 2400x .0043= 10.3 gal

    29 gallons:
    G= 6480x .0043=27.9 gal

    55 gallons:
    G=12480x .0043= 53.7 gal.


    As you can see, the advertised volumes are not the actual volumes of the tanks.

    2.
    Weight:
    Calculating the actual weight of the aquarium can be quite difficult. You need the weight of the empty tank, all the decorations and gravel in the tank, and the amount of water in the tank. Water weighs 8.5 lbs per gallon, so for the average tank, you can assume about 10-12 lbs per gallons depending on what you have in it. Simply multiply the volume of the tank in gallons by 10 (in these examples) to get an approximate weight.

    10 gallons:
    W= 10x10 =100 lbs

    29 gallons:
    W= 29x10 = 290 lbs

    55 gallons:
    W = 55x10 = 550 lbs

    As you can see, some tanks can get very heavy very fast. The 55 gallon weighs over a quarter of a ton!

    3.
    Oh the pressure!!! Just what is the water pressure down there? Just how deep can your air pump or CO2 go?

    Well, pressure basically the weight of all the air in the atmosphere air and the weight of the water per one unit of area, usually per square inch. Normal atmospheric pressure is 14.7 pounds per square inch (psi). This means that if you draw a square on the ground one inch on each side, all of the air above it, from the ground to the edge of the atmosphere way up there weighs 14.7 lbs. Most measurements of pressure are relative to this. If your pump is rated at 1 psi, it is putting out 15.7 psi, but because the back pressure is 14.7, the net effect is 1 psi. All of our measurements are going to be relative to the atmospheric pressure.

    Water pressure depends only on depth. To find it is simple, just multiply the density of water times its depth. The density of water (d) is .036 pounds per cubic inch (at sea level).
    P= dxh
    Examples:

    10 gallons:
    P= .036x 12 = .43 psi

    29 gallons:
    P= .036x 18 = .65 psi

    55 gallons:
    P= .036x 20= .72 psi.

    If you have a small air pump rated at 1 psi, then it will just barely work in a 55 gallon tank, and its effective pressure out is only about .28 psi.

    4.
    Speaking of pressure, how strong is that silicone anyway?

    Here is one place that things start to get a little more tricky, as this requires calculus. (OH NOW HIT THE BACK BUTTON NOW!!!!) No, no, no, donít worry, its ok, you donít need the calculus to figure it out in your tank, itís just required to find the equation.
    One think you need to know about pressure is that it works in ďpushesĒ in every direction equally, so if the pressure is 10 psi, that means that on the sides of the tank, there are 10 psi.

    To find the force on the side of the tank you simply need to multiply the area of the glass by the pressure. But wait, its not that simple, the pressure changes with depth. This is why the calculus is needed. If you under stand it, its included in the next paragraph. If not, then just ignore it and use the equation in the last line.

    Note: I cannot make an integral sign, so Iíll use int(..) instead.
    F = int( dxWxh dh) dh refers to the variable being integrated with respect to, basically.
    F = Ĺ xdxWxh^2

    To find the force on the side of the tank, just plug the numbers into the above formula.
    Example (front or back walls):

    10 gallons:
    F= Ĺ x .036x20x12^2
    F= 52 lbs.

    29 gallons:
    F= Ĺ x.036x30x18^2
    F=175 lbs.

    55 gallons:
    F= Ĺ x.036x48x20^2
    F= 346 lbs.

    As you can see, there is a lot of force on the sides of a tank. Kind of makes you want to ensure your center brace is there huh? Notices that if you add up the forces on the front, back and side walls, it is more than the weight of the tank!!!

    5.
    While we are still on the topic of water, lets talk about water displacement. I remember a post once where someone asked if, since water displaces the weight of an object, does that mean that rocks weigh less? Well, the short answer is no.

    Archimedes principle states that an object displaces its weight in water if it is floating (and only floating). Basically if something that is 10 lbs is floating, then it displaces 10 lbs of water. The volume of the water displaced is the same volume of the amount of the object under water. That is why ice is mostly under water when it floats (its just slightly lighter than water). When an object doesnít float, its weight is being supported by the bottom of the tank, and not the water, so it displaces its volume, not its weight. Thus rocks weigh the same in the tank as they do outside of it.

    6.
    Back to pressure. Bernoulliís principle stats that the faster a fluid moves, the lower its pressure. This is the basis for the operation of a python. They water flowing out of the faucet is moving and thus at a lower pressure than the air in the hose. Since pressure tries to equalize, the air in the hose lowers as air runs out of the python outlet with the water. This causes the water to be ďsuckedĒ out of the tank. Saying it sucks isnít quite right. When you suck on a straw you donít really suck, you cause the pressure in the atmosphere to push the liquid down and it goes up through the straw since the pressure is lower. Here is a picture to help show this.



    Bernoulliís equation is:

    P1 + (Ĺ x D x V1^2) + DxGxH1 = P2 + (Ĺ x D x V2^2) + DxGxH2. P is atmospheric pressure, D is density of the fluid, V is the velocity of the fluid, G is the rate of gravity, and H is the depth of the

    You can use this to find a flow rate based on pressure. The problem with finding this using a python is that I donít know what the water pressure coming out of your faucet is (and you can vary it). However, with a regular gravel vac, you can calculate this quite easily. The side with the 1ís is going to be the hose output, and the side with the 2ís is going to be the tank. Since the tank pressure is basically the same as the atmospheric pressure the Pís cancel. The tank water is not moving (for practical purposes), so (Ĺ x D x V2^2)=0. We will let the hose output be zero, so DxGxH1 = 0. This leaves us with:
    Ĺ x D x V1^2= D x G x H2
    H2 is the height from the hose outlet to the top of the water in the tank. The Dís cancel and multiplying both sides by 2 we get.
    V1^2=2xGxH2 or V1=sqrt(2xG x H) sqrt=square root.
    Lets just say that the height is about 1.5 feet from the top of the tank water, to the hose out put. Gravity is 32 feet/sec/sec, so
    V1= Sqrt ( 2x32x 1.5) =9.8 feet/ sec = 6.7 mph

    If the radius of the hose is r= 1/8 of an inch, or 1/96 of a foot then the area of its opening is A=Pi x r^2 = 3.14 x (1/48)^2=.00034 square feet

    The flow rate in volume is then, the speed times the area of the opening.
    VxA= 8.9 f/s x .00034 square feet = .003 cubic feet per second. Since 1 gallon is .133 cubic feet, then (.003 cf/s) / (.133 cf/gal)= .023 gal/sec.

    To get sec/gal, take the inverse of .023, which is 1/.023= 44 sec/gal.

    To do a 50% water change in a ten gallon, it takes about 220 seconds, or 3 minutes 40 seconds(5x44). I havenít timed it or measured the actual height from the hose opening to the water surface, but it does sound about right.

    Power filters and power heads use an impeller to push the water away from the opening of the inlet tube. The vacuum that is left causes water to be pulled up into the filter. This is the basic operation of these systems. I would like to elaborate more on it, but this is a more specific application and a hydraulic engineer would probably be able to give some more specific information than I can right now.

    7.
    OK time for a change of subject. Letís talk about something shocking! Electricity.

    First the basics, some common terms.

    Voltage: This is the measure of a difference in charge. If you read 10 volts on a meter, it means that one side is 10 volts more than the other side, it doesnít measure zero volts. We usually take ground to be zero since it is big and convenient.

    Current: This is the flow of charge per second

    Wattage: This is a measure of electrical power, or work per second.
    I wonít get into ohmís law here, since it really isnít important to the discussions. But to calculate power, for most applications, you multiply voltage times current.

    There are grounding probes out there for fish tanks. The idea is that if the tank has a net charge compared to you, and you stick your hand in there, you get shocked. This isnít normally an issue unless you have a heater or filter leaking current, which usually doesnít happen. The grounding probe simply allows any charge in the tank to equalize with ground voltage.

    One of the common wonderings on this site is how much it costs to run their aquarium. To find this simply look up the power ratings, or calculate it, and add them together. NOTE, if lights are on for 12 hours and the heater is only on half the time, then you need to take that into account. I am assuming the filter and air pump are on 24/7. This isnít technically the correct way to look at it. It should be that they the time they are on is halved, but the math works out the same.
    For example:
    150 Watt heater on half the time is 75 watts
    40 Wattís of light on 12 hours a day is 20W.
    8 Watt fliter
    3 Watt air pump

    Add these together to get 106 Watts. Electricity is charged at in kilo-watt hours, so take the wattís times days in a month times 24 hours times the cost of your electricity divided by 1000. This is your monthly cost. Eg.

    106x30x24x.085/1000 = $6.49 per month.

    8.
    Oh no, the fish are getting cold! Its winter and the power has been out all day!

    So how cold does the aquarium actually get? Well as many have probably heard, larger tanks have more stable water. This is true with temperature too. Since heat is only lost at the surface, larger tanks take longer too cool. Compare a pot of hot water with a cup of hot water.
    The world of thermodynamics can get very odd and confusing fairly quickly, but in this case it shouldnít be too complicated. I wonít get into the atomic theory of matter or kinetic theory, as this my over complicate things.

    The first thing that is needed to know is the zeroth law of thermodynamics. It states that if two things with different temperatures come in contact with each other, they will equalize in temperature. This sounds too obvious to state, but it was needed to explain more complex systems. (this is why it is the zeroth law, the first law was already stated, and this is needed before the first law, for the first law to make sense.) The first law of thermodynamics is U= Q-W which seems simple but in practice, its very confusing remembering how to use the values, but I digress. The first law isnít necessary for this article. Since a tank is usually at a higher temperature than the air around it, it looses heat to the air through the glass, and through the surface to the air. To actually find how much heat a tank actually looses is quite difficult because of all of the variable involved, and the different ways that it looses heat, but we can make a rough approximation of this.

    We need to learn about specific heat and conduction. Specific heat is the amount of heat needed to raise something one degree. It is given by the equation:
    Q=mcdT , Where Q is the heat, m is the mass of the object, dT is the change in temperature, and c is the specific heat constant, and is a characteristic of the material.

    For conduction, we have the change in heat, dQ/dt=kA(T1-T2)/L. Where dQ/dt is the rate of change in heat, in our cause it will just be per second to keep things simple. k is the thermal conductivity constant and is a property of the material. T1-T2 is the difference in temperature on each side of the object. L is the length of the object

    First we will need to find the amount of heat lost to the surface of the aquarium. This is made more difficult by the fact that the aquarium is covered. There are different materials, and some openings to let some air in and out. The easiest way is to assume that the top is either open, covered completely by glass, or completely covered by wood or plastic.

    Too keep this example as easy as possible, Iíll assume that all sides of a rectangular aquarium are completely covered by glass that is .0065m (1/4 inch) thick, which will be L. First we need to find the total surface area of the glass in the tank. Iíll figure this out for a 29 gallon tank. Remember the dimensions are 30x12x18 inches or 76.2cm x 30.5cm x 45.7cm
    The front and the back panes of glass are 2 x 76.2 x 45.7 = 6965 square cm.
    The side panes are 2 x 30.5 x 45.7 =2788 square cm.
    The top and bottom are 2 x 76.2 x 30.5=4648 square cm.
    Adding these together gives us 14400 square cm or 1.44 square meters of surface area, which is A.

    We are going to further simplify this by assuming that the room temperature is 20 degrees C (68 degrees f) and stays steady, and that the tanks temperature was at 25.5 degrees C (78 degrees f) when the power goes out (or when the heater fails off.) The k for glass is .84 J/(smC) [joules / (second meter degree C)] (joule is a unit of energy).

    dQ/dt = kA(T1-T2)/L = .84x 1.44(25.5-20)/.0065=1023J/S

    Notice how this doesnít depend on the fact that water is on one side of the glass and air is on the other. This is because of the zeroth law. Regardless of what the materials are, they always try to become in equilibrium temperature with each other.

    Using specific heat we can find how much heat must be lost to change the temperature of the tank to the temperature of the room. The mass of the water in the tank is 106 kg and the specific heat of water is c=4186, and dT is 25.5-20=5.5 C

    Q=mcdT =106 x 4186 x 5.5 = 2440000J

    2440000J / 1023J/S = 2385.5 seconds, or about 40 minutes to cool from 78 degrees to 68 degrees. This is a very very very simplified calculation, and is not very accurate. It doesnít take into account a lot of factors. If your tank is sitting on a wooden stand with a solid wooden top it will loose much less heat through the bottom. Additionally, if your hood is wood, it will reduce heat loss even more. The gravel in your tank has a lower specific heat and will cool more easily than water. Everything radiates heat as well, but it is so small for water that it was neglected. Iíll explain more about this when I talk about light. There are just too many factors to get a completely accurate calculation here, but I would be willing to bet that if you were to try this with a tank with nothing but water in it and glass on all sides, it would be somewhat close to what actually happens. I donít have a spare tank to try it on so I canít confirm its accuracy by experiment.

    9.
    All about Light:

    I could write for hours about light, its one of the most important topics in physics. Everything that you might hear that sounds difficult (quantum physics, atomic physics, nuclear physics ect.) are all related to light. I wonít get into all of that since it doesnít directly relate to the aquarium.

    Light is basically electro-magnetic radiation. It is the same thing as radio waves, micro waves, x rays, gamma rays ectÖ Here are some common parts of the E-M spectrum listed by frequency
    60 Hz, wall frequency (in the US)
    100-10MHz Radio waves
    10MHz-1000GHz Micro waves
    100GHz-40000GHz infrared light (there is over lap with micro waves)
    40000GHz-75000GHz visible light
    75000GHz-1millon GHz Ultra violet light
    1million GHz- 100 million GHz X-rays
    Greater than 100 million GHz Gamma rays

    We are obviously interested in the visible spectrum, which is usually referred to as wave lengths, since it is this, and not frequency that determines color. The wave lengths of visible light range from 400 nm (violet) to 750 nm (red).

    Where does light come from? This is both a difficult and easy question to answer. Light comes from electrons moving from a higher energy state to a lower energy state. Because of the law of conservation of energy, this energy has to go somewhere. It leaves as electromagnetic radiation. Depending on the circumstances, this is sometimes in the form of visible light. Light from the sun comes from two sources, nuclear fusion, and black body radiation. Nuclear fusion is the process of atoms fusing with each other to make heavier atoms. This results in a large change of energy from high levels to low levels, and thus releases a LOT of energy. Black body radiation is the principle that all objects give off some form of radiation. Calling it black body refers to the fact that black things are the ďidealĒ radiators, while white and shiny things do not radiate very much. (This is why it wasnít taken into account for a cooling fish tank. Water isnít very black, and the effect is minimal.)

    The spectrum of light we get from the sun is almost that of an Ideal black body at 5800 degrees K. When you see people say that a 6500K light is best for planted tanks, this is why. The spectrum of light given off by the tube, is what would be given off by an ideal black body at that temperature. The light from the bulb is determined by the chemical coating inside the tube, so the output isnít an exact duplicate of black body radiation. Light usage by plants peaks between 400-425 nm in the blue area, and 625-650 nm in the red range. Most of the other parts of the spectrum are of little use to plants.

    Actinic lights (8000-10000K) have very little red light, which is the most important color for plants. They are used in reef tanks. Blue light has more energy than red light, so it penetrates deeper into the water. This is why the ocean often looks blue. It is also why its important. Since blue light is whatís available, coral and algaeís have adapted to use the blue light.

    Light is measured in lumens, or lux (lumens, per area). Most lighting is fluorescent. Since it is fairly consistent, people usually use a watts per gallon rule. This rule breaks down when you use different sources of light. Fluorescent is used, because it is efficient, and fairly easy to control what color are produced. Incandescent isnít very efficient, and gives of more heat than light. It also doesnít give off a good spectrum for growing plants. Metal halide lamps and mercury vapor lamps donít produce the best spectrums of light, but they put out so much light, that it makes up for this and are good for deep tanks. Be careful with these, they get hot and the oils from your fingers on the glass can cause them to explode!

    10.
    Honey Look, The fish are refracting!!

    Its not a disease, its bending light. When light goes though something of a different density, it changes speed. This change of speed causes it to bend, creating the appearance of things looking closer than they are in an aquarium. This is best illustrated with a picture



    The human brain assumes that light comes in at a straight line. This is the tank looks smaller from the out side, or why you can look at a tank from the corner of it, and see the same thing through both the front pane of glass and the side. Another common phenomena of this is total internal reflection. When looking from inside the water looking out, the light bends the same way and gives a mirror effect. When you get to the proper angle, the light runs along the glass, and past that point, it reflects back off of the glass.

    Not technically physics but relevant math non-the less.

    Ever want to know what your normal level of nitrates will be? Here is how to do it. After a water change measure your nitrate level. The time of your next water change, measure the nitrates again, the difference is A. If you do a 50% water change, you remove 50% of your nitrates. Here is the equation.

    dN/dt = -.50N + A Where N is your total nitrates.

    Basically this equation says that your change in nitrates increase at rate A per interval between water changes, and also decreases at your percent times the total nitrates. When the rate of change is zero, your nitrates stay the same, so this is the equilibrium point. Set the equation to zero, and solve for N. Here is an example. My tank produces 10 nitrates per week, and I do 40 percent water changes once a week, so my equation is

    0 = -.40 N +10
    .40N = 10
    N=25

    This will my usual nitrate level when I do every water change. It is a simple model, and may not always be accurate, since aquariums are not constant, and are always changing. It is fairly close though since the aquarium shouldnít change too much.

    Well, there you have it. I hope I was able to hit the most relevant points. I am sure there were things that I forgot to talk about. If anyone has ideas for topics that I can add, please feel free to suggest them. If anyone has any further questions, again please ask. If you have found any errors, let me know so I can fix them.

    Joephys.
    Last edited by joephys; 04-23-2006 at 9:18 PM.





  2. #2
    I eat spam sumthin fishy's Avatar
    Usergroup
    AC Members
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Location
    cali
    Posts
    1,730
    Quote Originally Posted by joephys
    Light is basically elector-magnetic radiation................. vary efficient...
    Those are the only errors Ive found. You are right, most of this was totally irrelavant to me, but interesting enough that I read the whole thing. Put in the simplest possible terms, I was able to understand the majority of it. GREAT JOB
    Helpful articles

    cycling

    freshwater ich



  3. #3
    Senior Member
    Usergroup
    AC Members
    Join Date
    Apr 2006
    Location
    Wakefield, New Hampshire
    Last Activity
    01-29-2012 12:10 PM
    Posts
    197

    Water Displacement

    5. While we are still on the topic of water, lets talk about water displacement. I remember a post once where someone asked if, since water displaces the weight of an object, does that mean that rocks weigh less? Well, the short answer is no.

    Archimedes principle states that an object displaces its weight in water if it is floating (and only floating). Basically if something that is 10 lbs is floating, then it displaces 10 lbs of water. The volume of the water displaced is the same volume of the amount of the object under water. That is why ice is mostly under water when it floats (its just slightly lighter than water). When an object doesnít float, its weight is being supported by the bottom of the tank, and not the water, so it displaces its volume, not its weight. Thus rocks weigh the same in the tank as they do outside of it.

    An explanation of #5, with a few more details. The answer that the true mass of the object is fixed, is correct. If you were to take a 1000g steel weight with a density of 8.0g/cm3 and add it to an aquarium that was sitting on top of a scale the weight of the aquarium would increase by 1000g. However if you were to place the scale inside the aquarium and put the 1000g weight on the scale you will find that the scale would indicate slightly less than 1000g. The buoyancy effect is still there even if the object sinks. The downward force of the 1000g weight on the submerged scale would be decreased by the weight of the water that it is displacing.

    1000g / 8g/cm3 = 125 cm3 (volume of 1000g weight)

    The volume of the 1000g weight is equal to the volume of the water that it is displacing. Water has a density of 1.0g/cm3

    125cm3 * 1.0g/cm3 = 125g (weight of displaced water)
    1000g - 125g = 875g (value indicated on the scale)

    The scale submerged in the aquarium would indicate that the 1000g weight was only 875g. This is because the pan of the scale would be supporting 875g of the total weight and the water would be supporting the other 125g.

    Being a metrologist I have to compensate for the buoyancy effect in air when making precision mass measurements. The math works the same only the density of air is approx 0.0012g/cm3.

    As for what floats, any thing with a density less than water (<1.0g/cm3), and any object with a density greater than water will sink.
    Last edited by vidiots; 04-23-2006 at 8:23 PM.



  4. #4
    Senior Member
    Usergroup
    AC Members
    Join Date
    Apr 2006
    Location
    Wakefield, New Hampshire
    Last Activity
    01-29-2012 12:10 PM
    Posts
    197

    Pressure Measurement

    A simple way of measuring water pressure is using a ruler to measure its verticle height or depth. Most unit converters will have inches of water listed as a pressure unit to select.
    If you wanted to be ultra precise 1 psi is approximately equal to 27.73 inches of water at 20įC.



  5. #5
    Go Yankees! partsrep's Avatar
    Usergroup
    AC Members
    Join Date
    Mar 2005
    Location
    LI, NY
    Last Activity
    01-26-2008 10:51 PM
    Posts
    107
    Quote Originally Posted by joephys
    Cylinder:
    Find the distance across the tank and divide by 2 (R).
    Find the height of the tank (H).
    V= 3.14 x R^2 x H (Note: R^2=R squared, or RxR)

    Bow fronts can be difficult to measure. If the bow is perfectly circular or parabolic then it maybe possible to calculate the volume, but it is a lot of work and more easily done in different coordinates. I donít want to get into that since I said that I would keep the math on the easier side.
    So I believe a quarter round corner tank would use the same equation as a cylindrical tank divided by four. Would you agree?

    Excellent article Joephys.
    5G Mollies
    10G Krib crib
    10G Malawi fry tank
    20G FW 2-Blue Cobalt Lobsters, Platys, SerpaeTetras, Head &Tailight Tetras
    29G Malawi Cichlid. Yellow Labs and Mbamba
    36G Community, Zebra Danios, Platys, Swordtails, Pleco, Cory Cats, Cardinal Tetras, Glass Cats
    55G Kribensis, Tiger barbs, Balas



  6. #6
    Senior Member
    Usergroup
    AC Members
    Join Date
    Feb 2006
    Location
    Avon, In (suburb of Indianapolis)
    Last Activity
    07-31-2014 1:29 PM
    Posts
    415
    Only error I found was "they" and I think it should have been the. Other than that nice article. I am in physics right now and some of that stuff makes sense. Very interesting.



  7. #7
    Senior Member joephys's Avatar
    Usergroup
    AC Members
    Join Date
    Dec 2005
    Last Activity
    12-13-2008 6:16 AM
    Posts
    768
    Thanks for the proof read sumthin fishy.

    Vidiots, thanks for pointing that out. After reading that I agree I do need to explain it a little better. To me weight=mass x acceleration due to gravity, so the situation you described, I would call the apparent weight in the water. I will update it in a bit.

    You would be correct partsrep.

    I am glad that people are finding it at least some what interesting, and that I did an ok job keeping it in simple terms. I think that is the thing that keeps people away from science, I looks and sounds more difficult than it actually is.



  8. #8
    grand high exhalted poobah beblondie's Avatar
    Usergroup
    AC Members
    Join Date
    Mar 2005
    Posts
    567
    Overall good article 3 probs i noticed
    1.Proper volume needs to be inside measurements (if this was mentioned I missed it)
    2. you need the weight of the empty tank+water weight (see chart here http://www.all-glass.com/services/index.html)
    3. for every 50 lbs of decoration substrate,rocks etc etc. you will displace 2.2 gallons of water
    There can never be enough bichir creature keepers.

    "I am Grey.I stand between the darkness and the light,between the candle and the star."



  9. #9
    Senior Member
    Usergroup
    AC Members
    Join Date
    Apr 2006
    Location
    Wakefield, New Hampshire
    Last Activity
    01-29-2012 12:10 PM
    Posts
    197
    At work I try to avoid using the word "weight" because it can lead to confusion. Instead I try to use "Mass" or "Force". It's difficult because we were all brought up using the word "weight" to mean both of these.
    Last edited by vidiots; 04-24-2006 at 8:00 PM.



  10. #10
    Member
    Usergroup
    AC Members
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Last Activity
    03-03-2010 11:56 AM
    Posts
    74
    I'm a physics-EE major in college, a very well written article.

    Most relevant things in there, not much that isn't important. A good read.


    "3. for every 50 lbs of decoration substrate,rocks etc etc. you will displace 2.2 gallons of water"

    that may be an average... but if something sinks completely, it will displace whatever volume it has. Remember in physics or chemistry when you wanted to find the volume of an irregularly shaped object you place it in a graduated cylinder or the likes and measure the difference in water level. Weight has almost nothing to do with displacement, provided the object sinks. A fiber-glass decoration which wieghs 5 lbs and displaces .5 cu. ft. will displace the same as a .5 cu. ft. chunk of iron weighing much more.
    (didn't get any exact measurements of that , just pulling some examples from my head for principle)

    BTW, what are your credentials, Joephys?
    50G
    20 Cardinal Tetras, 20 Glofish Danios, 1 Male Betta
    4 Cory Catfish, 1 Bamboo Shrimp, 10 Cherry Shrimp



Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Similar Threads

  1. Replies: 23
    Last Post: 03-19-2010, 3:23 AM
  2. What these fish act like...
    By SoBlonde in forum General Freshwater
    Replies: 29
    Last Post: 10-24-2009, 5:16 PM
  3. Stirring the Salts
    By macman7010 in forum Marine Fish Only (FO) / Fish Only With Live Rock (FOWLR)
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 12-07-2004, 9:25 AM

Tags for this Thread

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •