Mafia #7 -- The Play

KingOfTheDeep said:
ok..after reading a few pages

my list looks like this...in no particular order

HN
Charlie
Jo
Deputy
mee-mee

these are people I believe could be the last 5 mafia.
Click to expand...

edited list

HN
Charlie
Jo
Deputy/jpappy
mee-mee
 
i'm aslo starting to suspect the mystery player..their posts are about as informative as a paper bag..it seems to me they only post to point out their words being "twisted" or to question any votes on themselves.

s/he's a little too lazy for my liking..im starting to believe there may be some ulterior motives to this character..
 
KingOfTheDeep said:
hm..not good

i was was not aware the night would begin at 12pm today, or else i would have voted.

i did get an investigation in, unfortunately i was unable to find a mafia..sorry guys

JL is innocent..

im going to go over some posts tonight so i can come up with some sort of list..

but for now

i vote to lynch hooked newbie
Click to expand...

Well thanks for the bit about JL66, it now puts a mafia target on his back, but it saves me lots of typing, as the whole 'let's lynch MP' had him leaning way mafia for me....


So now we have a pool of known innocents to work from...

Known Innocents
KOTD
Wata
JL66
Madcrawdad -> I realize that I'm only known to myself but I'm putting myself there because it will help with my own analysis.

There's only room for 2 more townies on the above list.... Who are they? Let's try to study who is left...

Suspects -> 5 are mafia, 2 are townies
Hooked Newbie
Mee-mee
JPappy
Plantling
Joander
Charlie Stubbs
Deputy Chief JR
(Note: I've purposely left Mystery Player out of the analysis as their status will just confuse things since we no longer really know how many townie or mafia slots there really are)


Now, I don't really expect the known innocents (or true remaining townies) to assume my innocence....

Known innocents feel free to toss me into the suspect pool and think about who would fill the remaining 3 townie slots.

True unknown innocents feel free to toss me into the suspect pool and include yourself in the known innocents pool. Then think about who would fill the remaining 2 townie slots...


Finally, JL66, I know you're hellbent on lynching MP at this time. For the town's sake, I really wish you would set aside your issue with MP and at least concentrate on some other suspects. I realize that MP may be mafia, but a random lynch at this point could hurt us. If we're really going to random lynch, I'd prefer that it come from the suspect pool above, as there's a 5 in 7 chance of hitting mafia there...(5 in 8 if you toss me back in, which is still better than the 50/50 we face with lynching MP). That said, though, I'd really prefer we don't random lynch anyone.

Unless you feel that you have great evidence that MP is mafia (and your evidence doesn't just include the fact that MP has irritated you), I really wish we would deal with them further down the road.
 
Jo- I think he is mafia through and through. I will not come off this vote regardless of whether or not a train forms on me. He switched off me late (10 minutes left) to vote for Sploke. I don’t believe he cares who goes as long as he nd his buddies are safe.

DC- Very little input until put on the spot. Loves the defensive vote, posts only when his name is mentioned, and hasn’t been much help to the town IMO.

Jpappy- Most posts are complete nonsense and of no help whatsoever to the town. Didn’t even bother to vote last night.

Mystery- I don’t see much that’s been helpful so far. I was willing to give the benefit of the doubt the first day, but he/she went after and voted for a now known innocent (JL).


Same list, same suspects. Feel free to lynch me, but please compare this list afterwards with the names that have been voting innocents off. If I’m not lynched, please investigate me KOTD.

I vote to lynch Joander.

 
Sorry to hear that us innocents have lost sploke and DD, i didn't really have the opportunity to game play with them, maybe next time.....



charlie_stubbs said:
wow. i see you've been making friends since i was away mystery player. don't think because i am moving my vote i think your less guilty. you are mafia, i'd bet my dog on it. But the others don't wanna lynch you yet, but i don't understand why. I am suspicious of Sploke, and have been the whole game. The whole invisible thing. My problem is, what if he isn't mafia?? What if he was invisible because he is the doc??? I was hoping King would investigate Sploke before we lynch him. Seems like thats not going to happen.
I vote to lynch Sploke.
Click to expand...

I'd would bet my LARGEST fish that your some kind of player, maybe the others are starting to see the real you.....

charlie_stubbs said:
trust me, i wanted you investigated more than lynched. if others would go along i would say lynch MP and investigate you. Seems noone else agrees with this.
Click to expand...

Again the lynch train.....running scared i think....

johnlarson66 said:
The thing that concerns me a lot with sploke is the payback vote of mee-mee. There was not a good reason to do that. sploke even saw the errors in their own explination.

Why people are unwilling to ride my lynch train of the mystery player, I have no clue.

Let's just hope KOTD finds another mafia. Let's also hope that the mafia kill each other.
Click to expand...

Because now CS is looking extremely suspicious......

johnlarson66 said:
Am I correct in seeing that KOTD did not vote?

KOTD, we really need you to lead us and be active in the game, I hope you have put in an investigation.

It was a mistake not to vote for mp. Unless KOTD comes with a positive ID on a mafia member, I am not changing.

I vote for mystery player
Click to expand...

First you voted for me then you recanted, now your voteting for me again, It is evident your also have second thoughts about me...

charlie_stubbs said:
i vote to lynch the mystery player.
subject to change if King has identified another mafia
Click to expand...

This was also a quick decision, you know I'm on track about you, i feel you have some thing to hide, as long as I'm around, your very nervious....

charlie_stubbs said:
if we had investigated sploke and lynched MP we would not be in this mess. I hope King sent in his investigation. Today i will help lead the charge to have mystery player lynched. Much can be said about who was not hit. JL, Mad, myself and HN are the best canditates for investigation. If King did not turn up another mafium, then Mystery Player must be lynched. Anyone that disagrees with this is suspect at this point IMHO.
Click to expand...

You have been on the lynch train before i had a chance to make a real post

your last highlighted sentence sounds like a mafia statement, are you mafia ? I would also like to point out you gave no condolences what so ever to the lynched and hit players, almost seems that your happy about it, also very suspisious... My list is as follows..

CS, Voted me off before i started the game,
HN,
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Side note ---- i will be out until later tonight --------
 
charlie_stubbs said:
This is solid gold!!!!! John your role playing is beyond reproach.

Warm tears stain Charlie saddened face. Poor Danger. Charlie has always been a little sweet on his beloved friend, and now he will never get the chance to propose to her. Marry her. Have children with her and a big screen television and many pets. His sadness quickly boils to rage. "Darn you mafia scumbags!!!!", he exclaims, pounding his fist on his old wooden desk. Charlie thoughts turn quicky to revenge. He hears a noise outside. It is the stranger. Charlie bolts out the door. The stranger will pay for what he has done to his beloved. Charlie screams Dangers name. The stranger hears it plain. Charlie decides he is going to send this stranger straight to hell with the music of his snapping bones in his ears.
Click to expand...

charlie_stubbs said:
Ashamed, Charlie startes at his shoes as he walks pasts Sploke's house . He thinks of Sploke's wife, and of the child that will never her get to know her father. All Sploke was ever guilty of was being an oddball. And Charlie helped hang him for it. His condolences to Sploke's wife seemed to give her little comfort. Maybe a bikini wax would cheer her up. Charlie decides to send her a coupon, first thing tomorrow morning.
Click to expand...
Here are my posts MP. Where do you read that i seem happy about the lynch or hit. More twisting of words, my mysterious friend??? Just popped in to cause a little more confusion??? Off to a meeting??? So about your list:
DD- dead. innocent.
JL- proven innocent
CS- unknown innocent.
would you like to change the players on that list yet?? I have a list of known innocents and there are two spots left open. I assume the names on your list would fill in these spots.
 
Madcrawdad said:
Well thanks for the bit about JL66, it now puts a mafia target on his back, but it saves me lots of typing, as the whole 'let's lynch MP' had him leaning way mafia for me....


.
Click to expand...


pretty sure the mafia already knew he was innocent...:screwy:


sorry, this needs to be added

most of you dont seem to happy about me naming innocents as i find them, should i stop, and let them be lynched while the mafia sits back and laughs?

if a innocent player is suspected of being mafia, that takes heat off of actual mafia players, if that innocent is proven to be innocent, it puts the heat back on mafia players and makes it easier to pick them out.

any of the mafia from game 6(including me) know of this..mikendanielle was like a goat for us, as long as he was around it was easy for us to work since all the suspicion was on him.

i stated that innocents would be named as i find them without naming roles that would benefit the town, if you guys don't want innocents named, then what should i tell you all when an investigation comes through innocent? either way the mafia will know i found an innocent..i may be ranting..but this type of thing is starting to **** me off.

having known innocents DOES benefit the town..
 
Last edited:
MP you keep saying i started a train on you before you had a chance to make a "real" post. 24 hours later you still haven't made one. Your first list (DD,JL,CS) has three innocents on it. Your voted for who we now know is a known innocent (JL) and why again??? Oh yeah, because he voted for you. Now you gives us another list you give no reason why HN is on your list, and you add i am on it because i voted for you. Hmmmmmmmm....is the whole town wearing blinders??? How is this guy helping us??? Mafia Game 8 guest starring MP??? MP the others don't seem to think your a threat, but your not fooling me princess. The free ride is over.
 
Madcrawdad said:
Well thanks for the bit about JL66, it now puts a mafia target on his back, but it saves me lots of typing, as the whole 'let's lynch MP' had him leaning way mafia for me....


So now we have a pool of known innocents to work from...

Known Innocents
KOTD
Wata
JL66
Madcrawdad -> I realize that I'm only known to myself but I'm putting myself there because it will help with my own analysis.

There's only room for 2 more townies on the above list.... Who are they? Let's try to study who is left...

Suspects -> 5 are mafia, 2 are townies
Hooked Newbie
Mee-mee
JPappy
Plantling
Joander
Charlie Stubbs
Deputy Chief JR
(Note: I've purposely left Mystery Player out of the analysis as their status will just confuse things since we no longer really know how many townie or mafia slots there really are)


Now, I don't really expect the known innocents (or true remaining townies) to assume my innocence....

Known innocents feel free to toss me into the suspect pool and think about who would fill the remaining 3 townie slots.

True unknown innocents feel free to toss me into the suspect pool and include yourself in the known innocents pool. Then think about who would fill the remaining 2 townie slots...


Finally, JL66, I know you're hellbent on lynching MP at this time. For the town's sake, I really wish you would set aside your issue with MP and at least concentrate on some other suspects. I realize that MP may be mafia, but a random lynch at this point could hurt us. If we're really going to random lynch, I'd prefer that it come from the suspect pool above, as there's a 5 in 7 chance of hitting mafia there...(5 in 8 if you toss me back in, which is still better than the 50/50 we face with lynching MP). That said, though, I'd really prefer we don't random lynch anyone.

Unless you feel that you have great evidence that MP is mafia (and your evidence doesn't just include the fact that MP has irritated you), I really wish we would deal with them further down the road.
Click to expand...
There is also a one in seven chance we hit the doc. You are hellbent on saving the MP for later Mad. Let's see, his first list had three innocents on it. He voted for JL, who we now know is innocent. His next list has HN and me. His reason, cause i tried to vote him off. Really helpful isn't he. So when should we deal with MP??? After we lynch the doc??? I'm pretty suspicious of anyone that feels "MP" should be dealt with later.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom