THE PLAY: Mafia #16 'Till death do we part...

Hooked Newbie said:
Ice-

My concerns are more with your lack of participation than last night's vote. You have actually been the one referring back to it to "show" that you thought DD was innocent and protected her for that reason. I agree with you about the format differences, but look at it this way for one second. You are one of the best players, so if you weren't mafia to begin with, it would stand to reason that you'd be chosen as a partner by one. That is where the possibility of DD being mafia (I suspected it and was wrong) and you being innocent (but expecting to be chosen yourself) came from. Hopefully you're innocent and weren't chosen. Even better if our bickering caused them to PM to "unchoose" you. If you are innocent, I'd expect to see more typical Ice than any of us have seen so far.
Click to expand...

Using that logic then why aren't you chasing after yourself lol or LG RB Plant Jpap DC Charlie, all good players that I could see as someones choice.

I actually think taking someone obvious is a big mistake. I would be more inclined to choose a player that makes it far into the games without many people looking at them.
 
Lady G said:
I took it he was pointing out that Jo was naming all the newb's as suspicious, don't think it was intended against you, JMO.
Click to expand...

Yes, Lg, exactly...I found it odd that niko was that confused about the post but nothing other than that.
 
jpappy789 said:
Ok, makes sense. Just that you keep using that excuse for you thinking DD to be innocent. Innocents make mistakes (as we have just seen) but so do mafia, even vets who are scum. I just don't like how you were so sure that DD was innocent but JMO.
Click to expand...

I couldn't know, I could just tell.

Even mafia don't know this round, they don't know who is mafia or innocent except for their spouse.
 
IceH2O said:
I couldn't know, I could just tell.

Even mafia don't know this round, they don't know who is mafia or innocent except for their spouse.
Click to expand...

Yea but certainty of a players side still makes me nervous no matter the game format.

And I know you werent 100% sure because that would be a dumb thing to say but you fought an awful lot to defend DD.

Which brings me to another point I was wondering about. I am having a hard time deciding whether you were really defending DD or just using that to go after jo and hn...maybe I am looking too far into things...maybe I am just going crazy...maybe my peanut butter and jelly sandwich could fly...:y220d:
 
IceH2O said:
Using that logic then why aren't you chasing after yourself lol or LG RB Plant Jpap DC Charlie, all good players that I could see as someones choice.

I actually think taking someone obvious is a big mistake. I would be more inclined to choose a player that makes it far into the games without many people looking at them.
Click to expand...


Well, I can communicate with myself so I know what I am. Right now, of those you listed I am curious about DC's posting (or lack thereof) and Charlie's "case" for voting Jo which I made mention of in a post to Blue. I haven't gotten to LG yet, I'm watching Jpappy's posts and don't see anthing "sold" yet, and Rb hasn't posted much though I do find his apparent contentment with his only vote (and 2nd overall vote of the game) a bit curious.
 
clown-lover said:
I think this statement can be labled the "Great Understatement" for this game.. I had to read through everything twice and out of all of these people in the last several hours was most of the traffic and I saw JoAnder doing most of the pushing..

However other things that concern me are..

1. Yesterday Liz was extremely vocal, but today she is pretty much no where to be found in this thread. I haven't gone looking to see if she has posted elsewhere as of yet and with it being midnight as I type and my day being long again tomorrow I don't have the time but will do so before the next nightfall... Has she taken our advice and is reading previous games?? I don't know but you think we would have at least heard from her today.. I didn't see anything letting us know she was going to be unavailable today.. Did I miss this?? I don't think I did..
Click to expand...

Yes, I did mention it. When I was defending why I wasn't reading old threads. I said "some days I don't know if I'll be able to be online at all (ie tomorrow)" or something.

Sorry guys. Yesterday I was at school from 7 am, picked up by a friend who I spent the day with at 11 pm and I had to go to bed to wake up for school today.

Today I had school, spent a few hours with the same friend, researched some skin care ingredients, read some reviews, etc etc.... so now I'm catching up,
 
jpappy789 said:
Yea but certainty of a players side still makes me nervous no matter the game format.

And I know you werent 100% sure because that would be a dumb thing to say but you fought an awful lot to defend DD.

Which brings me to another point I was wondering about. I am having a hard time deciding whether you were really defending DD or just using that to go after jo and hn...maybe I am looking too far into things...maybe I am just going crazy...maybe my peanut butter and jelly sandwich could fly...:y220d:
Click to expand...

Actually I started going after you, but they went after me so hard for defending DD that the focus became them. You're still a suspect as I'm sure if you were around you'd be on me as hard at the time but Jo is the one I vowed to get and so he is the one I'm going after.

If you continue to be suspicious to me then I'll make my case. If in the coming days you look less suspicious to me then I won't. Its as simple as that.
 
Aiii this is too much to read and follow :/

I had a gut feeling on Tuesday, something about Jo struck me as a little suspicious, but I couldn't pinpoint it and I didn't want to try to catch anything on him. So I didn't mention it (I don't think I did?)
 
IceH2O said:
To funny. At this point I don't even need to try to continue a case against you as you're doing it for me.

You're voting for Kuhli based on a shot in the dark? Because they haven't been much help?

A lot of people have been not posting much or knocking down doors. Why not mention them, why pick on the newbs when the Vets in hiding are more suspect for not contributing?
Click to expand...


Your vote on me is a shot in the dark too. You have no idea what my role is, therefore it must be a shot in the dark.

Kulhi wasnt much help at all... ever in the whole entire game... then he jumps in and votes DD without even trying to catch up.... and is gone again. Hes acting confused when i dont believe he is, as well as not helping and throwing out careless votes.

Thats were my vote will stay until my demise.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom