Kash...don't you think the mafia knew Rich was the Det and Pir was lying because Pir is their teammate and they were just trying to get the Det to come out? Or do you think Pir is telling the truth now?
Mafia #77 Game thread- Back to the basics
- Thread starter jpappy789
- Start date
Kash...don't you think the mafia knew Rich was the Det and Pir was lying because Pir is their teammate and they were just trying to get the Det to come out? Or do you think Pir is telling the truth now?
Thank you, Dawg. From what I'm seeing, I think we have players who are still struggling to keep up with many details... who said what? who replied to whom? And all that. It's not easy for us vets either... believe me... lol. It takes us a lot of time to clear up confusing positions and some have been confusing different players by name.
Actually, a bit of a slack in the posting frenzy is a good thing as that allows us more time to review posts, ask questions, double-check facts, and formulate suspicions. We don't need to focus on Zaffy at all anymore but everyone else is still undetermined.
Kash I agree with most of your post to me. The biggest problem I still have is this.
The detective is a huge threat to the scum, but in this case we are talking about last night which is a very specific case. At the point where you told Rich to call his invest he became "walking dead" and nothing, nada, zip as a threat to the scum. You need to consider everything that played out, and the order of nightly events. If Rich names any innocent the scum just hits them. The town learns nothing except the innocents name and we are going to learn one each nightfall anyway. If Rich names a scum they hit Rich.
The detective is a huge threat to the scum, but in this case we are talking about last night which is a very specific case. At the point where you told Rich to call his invest he became "walking dead" and nothing, nada, zip as a threat to the scum. You need to consider everything that played out, and the order of nightly events. If Rich names any innocent the scum just hits them. The town learns nothing except the innocents name and we are going to learn one each nightfall anyway. If Rich names a scum they hit Rich.
just a little FYI...i'm going down to college today and have job orientation tomorrow, and then will be moving in on saturday. i don't expect to have alot on time on the internet, but i'll try my best to get online before saturday afternoon and post/at least read the thread.
Okay, I am home and wanted to get this out of the way.
I have been out of sync with my game from missing so many, but it is time to step up my game and start digging.
UN you are definitely one I am going to dig into.
Are you even reading the game thread? Or do you just check in at the scumden and if no one is there to tell you what has been going on do you then come here and just start posting?
Again, are you reading the game thread? Kashta and I discussed this in the thread fairly thoroughly last night it should be no stretch for you to check it out.
Are you so used to being filled in on what has happened in the game that you can't go back and read it for yourself? You need someone else to pull it for you?
I have been out of sync with my game from missing so many, but it is time to step up my game and start digging.
UN you are definitely one I am going to dig into.
And the vets posting more is a problem at hand how? It seems to me that with the vets posting more we might actually get some content to analyze as opposed to the smoke screen you and pir were putting up D1.
I have to agree here, UN you are wobbling on the fence IMO. It seems to me that a false RC naming an innocent as scum from invest is a pretty good indicator that we have 2 scum revealed. Is this fact making you nervous?
The highlighted was in response to being asked how you knew that rich was the det.
Correct me if I am wrong here. You are stating that Rich attacked Zaffy so you immediately knew Rich was the det?
You are amazing. I wish I had the clairvoyance to differentiate between a PR attacking someone and just a regular old townie attacking someone in these games.
Your story gets weaker and weaker every time you explain it.
Let me explain this to you simply. You made a false RC, and named a confirmed innocent as your invest calling him scum.
This forced the real det. to come out. If you hadn't made the false claim, Rich would not have come out and would probably still be in the game giving us hints as to who he invested and turned up scum.
Of course you already knew this before you "came out" because it was planned in the scum den wasn't it?
Zaffy wasn't really acting that scummy, but for whatever reason, Rich saw something in Zaf.
The mafia teams have always been willing to sacrifice one of theirs for the good of the team. You have played enough games to see the posts about Ice throwing one of his teammates under the bus. It makes one of their own golden in the eyes of the town.
Rich became "dead man walking" as soon as pir false claimed. That is it end of story. Why do you insist on rehashing something that is not going to help the town at all?
No, I'm saying that I picked up on him being det, I didn't know for sure, but I figured if I saw it, the mob would.
I though he was scum...
I honestly didn't plan on that. I was trying to get hit by the mob so he would have a chance.
