OK this is quite long and goes up to post 520 or thereabouts.
This is Narwhal talking about Night 1. He's mooting the possibility that in fact Tree is a witch, i.e. that the fact that Tree was left in a tie does not mean he's likely to be innocent. This is a bad theory.
This is Narwhal saying he can see the case and the logic against Wizard. Bear in mind, there was no case or logic to it in reality. Hammerhead got the info from an investigation and ran with it. For narwhal to say he saw a case and logic is a lie.
Wing Nut, known witch, I think its his first couple of posts of the day. He targets C Note. :-
Narwhal again. Here Narwhal is answering a question asked about someone else. It just looks a little like he's trying to appear helpful.
Wing Nut has a little pop at Narwhal. Nothing too damaging.
Narwhal is speaking to Hammerhead here. Again, there was no real thoughts on Wizard (how could there be - it was the start of Day 2). It's just that Hammerhead knew Wizard was high priest because of the investigation :-
In fairness to Narwhal he comes out and says it (I think its Tree he calls obnoxious).
^ Now, this was the fourth or fifth vote on Wiz. I don't know. Is that a little early for the scum to jump on their boss ? They certainly would have needed an exit strategy if they were jumping on at this time.
Scoop is next vote on, I mention in passing. This put Wizard on either five or six votes. That's quite the train.
OK this I believe is possibly significant. This has to be taken as a defence of wizard/effort not to have wizard lynched. Hello BadHaggis welcome to the game :-
Wing, confirmed scum, suspect list :-
A point I would make is that scum nearly always put some fellow scum somewhere on their suspect list. His main list is C Note, Narwhal and Chupa. Gunslinger is on the secondary list, a known innocent. Uh Oh is on the secondary list, a known innocent. Rickets and Bad Haggis make the secondary list. Bad Haggis is described as seemingly helpful. I don't see anywhere where Bad Haggis has actually been helpful.
Narwhal again :-
^ My comment is, this is a game with a turn. Lists help. They help generally in any event. Also, even if it is Day 2 we have a lot of activity by now, with Hammerhead making a strong assertion about Wizard, and the responses to it. Narwhal is opting out.
I was getting scummy vibes from Doomsday during Day 2, somewhat arising from their interactions with Hammerhead and Tree :-
The point I would make is that he's onto Wing, both in this post and in 469. This has to be seen as a pro-town attitude, in light of Wings known status.
Wing Nut provides another list. Remember, scum will always have a team member on their lists. The list is C Note, Narwhal and Chupa.
Now, here's where I get a little queasy about Bad Haggis being a witch. He votes Wizard prior to Hammerhead coming out - I will find the post in question but it is early Day 2 and before the role claim.
I think Bad Haggis' early vote on Wing could be important in their defence so I highlight it in fairness to them.
I think one or more of Narwhal, Chupa and C Note is a witch.
Based on my own thoughts, my pick of those three would be Narwhal.
![[AC] RICKETS](/forums/data/avatars/s/83/83432.jpg?1431345517){kind=avatar}
![[AC] scoop411](/forums/data/avatars/s/83/83913.jpg?1431345518){kind=avatar}
