Werewolf Game 1

[IceH2O]

if Z turns out to be a wolf, i'm sure they weren't willing to cast him out so quickly. If Z is innocent, Swade has accomplished little with this ploy, other than to lose a good player from her team. Unless Z is lynched and proven innocent, Sway cannot be lying.

Coler isn't saying Z is wolf and being cast out.

He is talking about DP.

What do you mean Sway would have accomplished little? If we believe her and follow then we lose 2 innocents one of which could become wolf.Then thats another entire day that we have to waste a vote on Sway to get 1 wolf while they take another innocent. So basically its give up 1 wolf for 3 innocents of the 3 innocents they might gain another wolf. They break even we lose population.

 

[charlie_stubbs]

I have my doubts as well, but i think that if this is a set-up and Z does not turn out to be a wolf, Swayde, Charlie, and Mike will have to be running for their lives. I don't see how, if they are wolves, they would expose themselves so obviously by standing by a liar. If it is an evil plot, this may be a way to turn attention away from the last people we were looking at - joander and bkw.

I agree. But i am fearless and believe Swayde has done what she thought was her best play. Z is a wolf. If Z is not a wolf, then there are NO Wolves. There is NO spoon. (hahahaha JL that one made me laugh fit to split.)

 

[IceH2O]

are you saying you wont vote for Z?

It means exactly that unless something crazy happens to make me trust Sway.

Right now Sway has shot up my list and the top 3 are

Bkw

Jo

Sway

We don't know how many wolves there are. Ogre says the Barons men say at least 3. If they started with 3 or 4 and lost one I can see a turn happening.

DP was one. I think DP was thrown under the bus.

 

[bkw1982]

The reason i trust swayde is becasue i dont think the wolves will risk it this early in the game. and what are the odds of them turning swayde? Will know tomarrow when z turns to be villiger or wolf. If z is villiger then the villigae has its next target, if he is wolf then we can go from there.

Only thing that would screw everyone up is if the wolves get a new wolf every night, that would just suck, ogre i think u need to let us know hoe many wolves there are or atleast how many times they can get a new wolf or when they can get a new wolf, the lack of this information suxs.

Lastly swayde didnt need to come out as seer to convince the villiage, she coulda just set back and stayed hidden, becasue most of the villiage thought she was innocent anyways

 

[IceH2O]

I want to see what the PM to Sway said.

Copy and Paste the PM to us Sway. Its allowed, you just can't copy and paste the one that names your role.

 

[charlie_stubbs]

Coler isn't saying Z is wolf and being cast out.

He is talking about DP.

What do you mean Sway would have accomplished little? If we believe her and follow then we lose 2 innocents one of which could become wolf.Then thats another entire day that we have to waste a vote on Sway to get 1 wolf while they take another innocent. So basically its give up 1 wolf for 3 innocents of the 3 innocents they might gain another wolf. They break even we lose population.

hmmmmmmmmmm...ice your giving me an ulcer and my head hurts from considering the possibilites. Are you against lynching Z or aren't you?? It comes down to do we believe her or not. I haven't got a reason to doubt her, but also don't want to run blind off a cliff either. Z did however try to start a lynch wagon on me, and i know i'm innocent, so that isn't helping matters much. bkw was also aboard that particular lynch wagon.

 

[wataugachicken]

The "jo talk' came after Night fell, there was not very much suspicion in Jo's direction until Jo showed up right after voting ended. Swayde had to put her choice in of who to 'see' before the controversy began.

 

[charlie_stubbs]

poor Z. first my novel this morning and now this. not your lucky day methinks.

 

[charlie_stubbs]

first the old lady with the tank screws ya and now Swayde does too. Where are you Z you nasty rascal. Answer these charges!!!!!

 

[Swayde]

I chose Zsandmann because in the last game there was a ton of confusion caused by me going after him and I wanted to find out which side he was on figuring he'd be a great ally, or an enemy worth finding out about. I just wanted to know, I did not suspect he was a werewolf when I sent in my request.

I am awaiting a response from Ogre to find out if I can copy & paste what I was told. There is absolutely no doubt though that he could be anything other than evil.

Ice, I did not feel comfortable withholding the information with the possibility that I could be attacked for the succesful hit on DP. There is no proof that DP was being lazy or anything. It's more likely he was just trying to not make any slip ups or draw any attention on himself.

There are no secret identities or anything like that. It will be very easy to find out if I am lying or not as soon as Zsandmann is dead. Is it worth it to take the risk that I am lying? No, I don't think so. I am simply doing what I feel is the best for the Village as a whole and I do believe this is a very good opportunity for us. I don't know about you, but I do play to win.