Mafia 9: The Bloody Coup

[joander123]

I'm voting Joander because of the first few postings. I was willing to overlook them and try to focus on others and see where they were screwing up and then I read the first page again. I also read somewhere where Jo was calling I am guessing "citizens" as townies..... It was only a little while when we all read our roles, why would you call anyone a "townie" in this game, Jo?

I vote to lynch Joander

does anyone want to speak of stretching something? They are townies in the mafia game, they are the same thing in this game. What does it matter if i call them townies or citizens, you still no what i am talking about am i right?

So let me get this straight, if i call them townies instead of citizens, i am a rebel? Makes little to no sense to me....

I think that honestly DD is just trying to start a wagon on me because shes rebel and knows my innocence, and so far shes doing an ok job because i am the leading vote getter. But lets be honest, her job was already started for her because many people were and are still suspicious of me.

i retract my vote for KOTD

not much from him since, i believe that there are better choices.

 

[charlie_stubbs]

as is charlie....big time

Are you trying to blow smoke my way??? I'm trying to be a little more reserved with the new format. I do however, have some thoughts:
Joander- is on alot of lists because of his early vote, yet this is a sound tactic IMHO. As Ice said last game, votes=responses=answers. I have reviewed Jo's posts and nothing is really jumping out at me.
Mee Mee- her defensiveness always concerns me, and if i had to vote now she would be the lucky winner. Of note: She was also defensive last game and was innocent. However, as Mad pointed out,
Emma- still no post??? what happened here?? did she forget she's playing??? I am almost sure Ice would not let her be president (random or not), although she may very well be rebel. It irks me when players commit to playing.

 

[Rbishop]

I agree the townie/citizen justification is very weak. Several folks have done the same thing in this game, probably out of habit from the numerous games.

I do see a need to keep you in my view with the alleged connections to jpap posts. That is just IMO.

 

[Rbishop]

Are you trying to blow smoke my way??? I'm trying to be a little more reserved with the new format. I do however, have some thoughts:
Joander- is on alot of lists because of his early vote, yet this is a sound tactic IMHO. As Ice said last game, votes=responses=answers. I have reviewed Jo's posts and nothing is really jumping out at me.
Mee Mee- her defensiveness always concerns me, and if i had to vote now she would be the lucky winner. Of note: She was also defensive last game and was innocent. However, as Mad pointed out,
Emma- still no post??? what happened here?? did she forget she's playing??? I am almost sure Ice would not let her be president (random or not), although she may very well be rebel. It irks me when players commit to playing.

Not trying to blow smoke charlie, just in a game where one of the major things you look for is descepancies, the change in volume and style of postings really stands out.

 

[Cory Lover]

Ok, here's my "list" for now. There's not a ton to go on yet, but I want to get it out for discussion and reaction.

mee-mee: IMO, she has been very defensive about general observations and seemed to be trying to add confusion early. Also the post count that Rb posted is interesting. And, no this is not in "reprisal" for voting for me. That vote without a case was helpful.

CL: Opposite end of the posting spectrum, seems to be jumping in and reading a single page to get a quick meaningless post out. Z's analysis seemed on point.

Deputy: Same as above and quick to vote.

DD: Just kind of a gut feel on this, but I could be wrong. Her posting style seems like previous games, but she always makes me nervous.

JL: Something just doesn't seem right. I'll re-read and try to post my reasons.

Sov: Her defense of being questioned last night took awhile (could be valid reasons for that), but even when it did come, it was weak IMO. Also, I think she's played enough not to have to do the "I don't get it" thing anymore.

I'd like to see other CCs thoughts today. I'll not vote yet, but if I had to it would be squarely on mee-mee.

/// List Off ///

Plantling- I made a mistake in addressing you about the "me dying early thing". I was actually referring to a list that JL posted (217). Sorry, I had alot of catching up to do after work and my notes apparently were wrong.

Well HN, if you look at how I've played all other games....I'm pretty much playing the same here.

Ok, I'm gonna tell everyone how I play Mafia games so people don't keep pinning me for not putting that much info out. I post what some people would call 'nonsense posts' because I don't have any good info yet and I don't want to make stupid posts. I do that for what ever time is needed before I feel like I have some info, and when I feel like I have found a rebel/wolf/mafia then I start posting (look at the last game). And.....I do feel that I may have found one....Ogre. I have a very bad gut feeling about him....like I did with Mike and Mal in the last game. People I know are going to have a hissy fit that I'm not putting much reasoning behind my vote.....but thats how I play. I let my gut feelings, most times, decide who I am going to vote for.

I vote to lynch Ogre.

CL

 

[Rbishop]

Charlie, how about a list for us to consider? Thanks.

 

[charlie_stubbs]

I'm going to agree with DD on the Joander vote, it's pretty early, but you're already calling us by the wrong name...

my isnt this interesting. Your lynching someone because they called us townies instead of citizens??? Hmmmmmmmm seems pretty weak to me, and the timing is HIGHLY suspect. Lets hope you never get jury duty. Danger starts a Jo train and Deputy is quick to get onboard. Note: I called people townies last game. Apparently, they were supposed to be called villagers.

 

[charlie_stubbs]

my list now as it stands:
mee mee- overall defensiveness
deputy- quick to hop on trains, but doesnt seem to be trying to find any evidence
i dont have a solid third now, but emma lack of posting yet concerns me
Note: when i was mafia i asked for people lists all the time, as i wanted to know if i was on their list. Are you asking because you wanna see if your on any lists yet RB?

 

[Rbishop]

Gut feels are pretty much the norm for day one. Especially with two independent teams out there.....

 

[joander123]

my point exactly CS.

I think the posibility of them both being rebels in the same group and trying to start a train on me because it is already suspicious.