Mafia 9: The Bloody Coup
- Thread starter IceH2O
- Start date
Just a totally bad call on my part....I didn't expect to make it past Night #1.
I knew Mee-Mee would go night two. I was solid that Ogre would go next. At that time, I didn't have any positives for a third or fourth rebel, and felt the Prez was safe.
I figured I was doomed to go. So I took a chance. I would have preferred to wait until way later, but as you can see, I left early.
Ice, on each nite, who were the hits that didn't go thru because of the random pick thing?
I knew Mee-Mee would go night two. I was solid that Ogre would go next. At that time, I didn't have any positives for a third or fourth rebel, and felt the Prez was safe.
I figured I was doomed to go. So I took a chance. I would have preferred to wait until way later, but as you can see, I left early.
Ice, on each nite, who were the hits that didn't go thru because of the random pick thing?
Day 1 Zman
Day 2 they both wanted Mad
Day 3 HN
Day 4 RB
Day 5 Both wanted Rb
Day 6 CIA didn't send in a hit
Day 7 there was no shot as both were dead
Day 2 they both wanted Mad
Day 3 HN
Day 4 RB
Day 5 Both wanted Rb
Day 6 CIA didn't send in a hit
Day 7 there was no shot as both were dead
Wait we didn't send a hit? I sent one in for Cl. I'm pretty sure I did because we wanted to go for the win as well...Oh well, I wouldn't have mad a difference anyways.
all the reading i have done about mafia games suggests that each power role lessens the percentage of chances for a mob win. this would appear to be true since i jumped in at game 5 and i have never seen the mafia win. if the ratio is 1 mafium (yes this is the correct when refering to the singular, mafia is the pluralization of mafium) to 2 innocents, perhaps it may be prudent to include an extra mafium for each power role???
Good game guys! I also vote HN for mvp for the good guys (lying about not being the doc) and JPappy for the rebels (if only he had more time, he might have been able to pull off being the doc as DD and KOTD were already suspicious of HN as I would be too since the FBI claimed they investigated HN but didn't take him out).
And what were you thinking, FBI?!!! You knew who the doc was but took out BKW instead? I think that was the beginning of the end for the rebels even though we knew who the doc and prez were. But mistakes were made by us also. In hindsight I shouldn't have gone after JL and Deputy so hard at the beginning. I just figured if I could get one of them lynched, then the CC's would think Ogre and I or Jpappy and I were CC's. I guess I must have been too convincing 'cause it got me killed. Ouch!
And what were you thinking, FBI?!!! You knew who the doc was but took out BKW instead? I think that was the beginning of the end for the rebels even though we knew who the doc and prez were. But mistakes were made by us also. In hindsight I shouldn't have gone after JL and Deputy so hard at the beginning. I just figured if I could get one of them lynched, then the CC's would think Ogre and I or Jpappy and I were CC's. I guess I must have been too convincing 'cause it got me killed. Ouch!
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
Us rebels killing each other is what hurt us. I think having two groups was good. I hope we try it again with two groups of bad guys. It is more fun being bad anyway. Ogre and mee-mee seem to struggle being bad guys, while some of us enjoy it.
It was the FBI's pleasure to kill plantling, she was being a pain right from the start. I think we would do it again... lol
As far as not hitting the Doc, we were going for the win.
We also thought BKW was the president. I did vote for CL when it was my last day alive.
I also think sploke's attempt almost worked, either way it was a good try.
I hope everyone had as much fun as I did.
It was the FBI's pleasure to kill plantling, she was being a pain right from the start. I think we would do it again... lol
As far as not hitting the Doc, we were going for the win.
We also thought BKW was the president. I did vote for CL when it was my last day alive.
I also think sploke's attempt almost worked, either way it was a good try.
I hope everyone had as much fun as I did.
Yeah, if i had gone back and reviewed the rules a bit more re. role knowledge and stuff I probably could have made it a bit believeable. Plus, CL coming out all in favor of KOTD being the detective (since he knew it for sure) was kind of a giveaway, we should have gone for CL instead of BKW, but prob should have taken out HN first.
hindsight is 20/20. My grandpappy used to say "If the dog didnt stop to take a crap he might have caught the rabbit", or "If a frog had wings he wouldnt bump his *** when he jumped".
2 reasons we didn't go for the doc 1) we wanted to go straight after the Prez and we kind of thought bkw might have been. 2) HN had been coming after sploke and I hardcore and we figured if we hit him it would be a dead giveaway of who was FBI. We were left in a pretty weak position when we lost Lady because Sovran never showed and JL was our only person fooling people after a while.
