Maybe I missed something...how do we know wata is supposed to be the detective?
Mafia #7 -- The Play
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
Maybe I missed something...how do we know wata is supposed to be the detective?
What i was saying before is that now that suspicion has been cast upon Ice as the snitch, the mafia are more than likely going to take him out this night or the next because he is able to compromise their position and name names. this is also why i was wondering if the snitch knows ALL the mafia members or just the ones on his team.
i don't know how much of a threat the snitch really is - we didn't have anything like that in the werewolf game. i think, though, if the mafia is threatened enough by the snitch that they will get rid of him asap, we should focus on finding a second mafia, so we get two tonight with both a hit and a lynch. does that make sense? and if ice survives after this night, we simply don't have to listen to anything he says. all we want is the snitch list.
i don't know how much of a threat the snitch really is - we didn't have anything like that in the werewolf game. i think, though, if the mafia is threatened enough by the snitch that they will get rid of him asap, we should focus on finding a second mafia, so we get two tonight with both a hit and a lynch. does that make sense? and if ice survives after this night, we simply don't have to listen to anything he says. all we want is the snitch list.
It would make sense to me that the snitch would only know the mafia members on his or her own team, not both.
The snitch is somewhat helpful, but last time when we had one I think it caused as much confusion as help. I was mafia that time so it was interesting to watch.
The snitch is somewhat helpful, but last time when we had one I think it caused as much confusion as help. I was mafia that time so it was interesting to watch.
Dangerdoll
Global Moderator
that's because Ice claimed Wata was, what I don't get though is that since Ice knows he is getting lynched tonight, why in the world would you out Wata if you are for the town?
First of all, no, i am not the detective. I was just writing my thoughts and seeing where they went. . . being thought of as the Det. was not something i had anticipated.
I am not really defending Ice. . . i know it seems that way unfortunately. What I am trying to get across is that Ice may certainly be mafia, but I don't feel comfortable with the way KOTD has gone about trying to convince everyone, with his "100% wink wink". His methods made me suspicious of him. I gues that since no one else has come out of the woodwork and claimed the Det. role, he very well might be telling the truth. I just still have a bad feeling about him, his methods, and his different role-play. Maybe his play is only different because he's been hiding an ace in his pocket all along.
I am not really defending Ice. . . i know it seems that way unfortunately. What I am trying to get across is that Ice may certainly be mafia, but I don't feel comfortable with the way KOTD has gone about trying to convince everyone, with his "100% wink wink". His methods made me suspicious of him. I gues that since no one else has come out of the woodwork and claimed the Det. role, he very well might be telling the truth. I just still have a bad feeling about him, his methods, and his different role-play. Maybe his play is only different because he's been hiding an ace in his pocket all along.
my posts 421 and 381, in both of those i mention Ice and my suspicions of KOTD. Ice might BE mafia, but i still don't trust KOTD.
So you're not all that familiar with the snitch? That was the wrong thing to say Ms. Chicken... you see the snitch first appeared in Game 6. Although you weren't a player, I believe that you followed that game religiously. Don't even try to deny it.
If folks look at the sign-up post for the Werewolf Game (the game immediately following Game 6) they will see that you were the 1st to sign up for the werewolf game. Also they will see that you admit that you were reading Game 6. Reading it closely enough that you claim to know who 2 mafia members were. You also made some other observations about game 6 in that same thread (some after BKW outed Chas as the snitch). Posts #2, #153, and #178 in that sign-up thread are pretty damning, wouldn't you say?
I would recommend that townies read the Werewolf sign-up thread (see link below). Pay attention to posts #2, #153, and #178. After reading, does anyone still believe that Wata doesn't know much about the snitch?
Ms. Wata, I do believe I've exposed you....
Werewolf signup link: http://www.aquariacentral.com/forums/showthread.php?t=120399
post 2 - turns out i was wrong in who i thought
post 153 - was in response to people talking about Rb, not the snitch. Rb's little stories had everyone running in circles
post 178 - so what?
You didn't really expose me, Mad. . . anyone who played in that game or the WW game knows that i was constantly lurking in game 6. that's the difference though - i was lurking, not playing. if i had to go by the reaction of the townspeople to the Snitch, well, charlie had them completely confused over the names. they didn't know who to investigate, or vote for, or anything. i've bee wondering if, since the teams are smaller in this game, that if the snitch only knows the mafia on his own team, maybe we will have an easier time of deciphering the list if Ice doesn't get lynched. I have also wondered in a few posts how important the snitch is to the mafia - if they are very likely to take him out tonight or the next night, then we should start looking for other suspects and let the mafia do our job as well. i for one would like to have at least one snitch list to work with.
post 153 - was in response to people talking about Rb, not the snitch. Rb's little stories had everyone running in circles
post 178 - so what?
You didn't really expose me, Mad. . . anyone who played in that game or the WW game knows that i was constantly lurking in game 6. that's the difference though - i was lurking, not playing. if i had to go by the reaction of the townspeople to the Snitch, well, charlie had them completely confused over the names. they didn't know who to investigate, or vote for, or anything. i've bee wondering if, since the teams are smaller in this game, that if the snitch only knows the mafia on his own team, maybe we will have an easier time of deciphering the list if Ice doesn't get lynched. I have also wondered in a few posts how important the snitch is to the mafia - if they are very likely to take him out tonight or the next night, then we should start looking for other suspects and let the mafia do our job as well. i for one would like to have at least one snitch list to work with.
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
Still trying to cast doubt.
Your statements like this make you look more and more mafia. You would have been better off claiming to be the "real" detective.
We will know to trust KOTD after tonight.
