Mafia #7 -- The Play
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
Okay, so it's all coming back to you now, good.... Now, I just can't seem to figure out why you claimed to not really know anything about snitch. Apparently the information was there, you just needed to dig a little deeper. Interesting.
actually, i went back to the mafia 6 game and read what happened.
but you're still not seeing what i'm saying. I KNOW how the townspeople reacted. They lynched him. What i DON'T know is what the mafia would have done if the townsfolk had not taken care of the problem. Do you see what i mean? That is what i have been wondering about all along, not the reaction i can see, from the townspeople (here and Game 6), but the unseen mafia reaction that has not been shown. Is the snitch a major threat to the mafia? If the townspeople hadn't lynched charlie, would the mafia have hit him? If we do not lynch Ice, will the mafia hit him anyway?
but you're still not seeing what i'm saying. I KNOW how the townspeople reacted. They lynched him. What i DON'T know is what the mafia would have done if the townsfolk had not taken care of the problem. Do you see what i mean? That is what i have been wondering about all along, not the reaction i can see, from the townspeople (here and Game 6), but the unseen mafia reaction that has not been shown. Is the snitch a major threat to the mafia? If the townspeople hadn't lynched charlie, would the mafia have hit him? If we do not lynch Ice, will the mafia hit him anyway?
Holy Cow! Good Morning Town. Did you all stay up all Night working on this? 
If Ice isn't Mafia after that Doctor bit then I don't know who is. Today is my off day so you'll be seeing me a good bit, although I do have chores the wife gave me to do. 
sploke and mee-mee have not voted yet. Yet they both posted last Night. Here's the tally I believe.
Game Day 2 will end at 9 PM EST Friday, 08/31
13/15 Votes – NO VOTE: Mee-Mee, sploke
1-Joander123: Hooked Newbie (275)
10-IceH2O: johnlarson66 (286) joander123 (288) Plantling (299) KOTD (308) DangerDoll (339) DeputyChief (341) Charlie_stubbs (415) johnlarson66 (427) ZSandmann (461) MadCrawdad (462) jpappy (482)
0-jpappy789: Zsandmann (287)
2-KOTD: Charlie_stubbs (290) IceH2O (232) watuagachicken (348) jpappy789 (375) ZSandmann (380)
0-ZSandmann: johnlarson66 (324)
wchicken: If you aren't with Ice why are you still defending him? You say you aren't, that you are only saying we still shouldn't trust King, yet you still are voting for King currently. I would say I trust that King is the real Det. about 90%. There are really three options:
A) King is the real Detective, he investigated Ice and found he was Old Mafia, and the Snitch just as he says.
B) King is Old Mafia, he saw Ice about to be lynched and decided to use it to make himself look Innocent. But he would make-up the Snitch bit since Ice isn't allowed to tell anyone on his team he is the Snitch.
C) King is New Mafia, he is fairly certain Ice is Old Mafia and wants to use it to make himself look Innocnent. But once again the Snitch part makes this a very tough thing to believe as that is easily checked upon death of Ice.
So, I think there is about a 90% chance A is correct, 5% B, 5% C
[FONT="][/FONT]
If Ice isn't Mafia after that Doctor bit then I don't know who is. Today is my off day so you'll be seeing me a good bit, although I do have chores the wife gave me to do. sploke and mee-mee have not voted yet. Yet they both posted last Night. Here's the tally I believe.
Game Day 2 will end at 9 PM EST Friday, 08/31
13/15 Votes – NO VOTE: Mee-Mee, sploke
1-Joander123: Hooked Newbie (275)
10-IceH2O: johnlarson66 (286) joander123 (288) Plantling (299) KOTD (308) DangerDoll (339) DeputyChief (341) Charlie_stubbs (415) johnlarson66 (427) ZSandmann (461) MadCrawdad (462) jpappy (482)
0-jpappy789: Zsandmann (287)
2-KOTD: Charlie_stubbs (290) IceH2O (232) watuagachicken (348) jpappy789 (375) ZSandmann (380)
0-ZSandmann: johnlarson66 (324)
wchicken: If you aren't with Ice why are you still defending him? You say you aren't, that you are only saying we still shouldn't trust King, yet you still are voting for King currently. I would say I trust that King is the real Det. about 90%. There are really three options:
A) King is the real Detective, he investigated Ice and found he was Old Mafia, and the Snitch just as he says.
B) King is Old Mafia, he saw Ice about to be lynched and decided to use it to make himself look Innocent. But he would make-up the Snitch bit since Ice isn't allowed to tell anyone on his team he is the Snitch.
C) King is New Mafia, he is fairly certain Ice is Old Mafia and wants to use it to make himself look Innocnent. But once again the Snitch part makes this a very tough thing to believe as that is easily checked upon death of Ice.
So, I think there is about a 90% chance A is correct, 5% B, 5% C
[FONT="][/FONT]
Mad this is a great catch BTW, I'll admit I had you very slightly leaning Mafia but this observation has pumped you up on my list. Which I'll post as soon as I grab breakfast. BRB.
Partly my vote is still on KOTD because i want people, since everyone is pretty satisfied with voting for Ice, to start looking for new suspects. unfortunately, that new suspect seems to be me, and I'm not going to vote for myself.
I realize what you are saying, just can't figure out why you would add 'we didn't have that in the werewolf game.' As if to imply, 'I have no experience with the snitch,' when in actuality you probably followed game 6 more closely than some of the folks playing.
But King isn't a new suspect either???
HN has that stray vote on joander, but you haven't jumped over there.
You haven't tried to start a new candidate.
You haven't done anything really. Just say on King who will very soon be outted as either Detective or Liar. And if you look at my previous post you can see which way most of think that will go.
My List:
Lady G
IceH2O - 2
Wataugachicken - 3
joander123 - 4
sploke – 4
DeputyChiefJR - 5
Dangerdoll - 5
johnlarson66 - 5
mee-mee - 5
plantling - 5
Charlie_Stubbs - 6
Hooked Newbie - 6
MadCrawdad - 7
jpappy789 - 7
KingOfTheDeep - 8
Zsandmann
[FONT="]Swayed
[/FONT]
Now back to my Pops Cereal. Mmmmmmmm. Sandy tucks into his cereal, sitting on the couch in his modest Dogcatcher home. When the wife's away he gets to play. But right now playing is sitting on the sofa in his boxer's, eating Pops, and watching Sportscenter.[FONT="]
[/FONT]
HN has that stray vote on joander, but you haven't jumped over there.
You haven't tried to start a new candidate.
You haven't done anything really. Just say on King who will very soon be outted as either Detective or Liar. And if you look at my previous post you can see which way most of think that will go.
My List:
Lady G
IceH2O - 2
Wataugachicken - 3
joander123 - 4
sploke – 4
DeputyChiefJR - 5
Dangerdoll - 5
johnlarson66 - 5
mee-mee - 5
plantling - 5
Charlie_Stubbs - 6
Hooked Newbie - 6
MadCrawdad - 7
jpappy789 - 7
KingOfTheDeep - 8
Zsandmann
[FONT="]Swayed
[/FONT]
Now back to my Pops Cereal. Mmmmmmmm. Sandy tucks into his cereal, sitting on the couch in his modest Dogcatcher home. When the wife's away he gets to play. But right now playing is sitting on the sofa in his boxer's, eating Pops, and watching Sportscenter.
[FONT="][/FONT]
That doesn't ake any sense. So you put your vote on the det..? Why don't YOU look for another suspect?
well, in the werewolf game i started off as innocent and then got turned into a werewolf, so if there had been some kind of snitch in the game when i had been turned, i would have been able to get a feeling for what the role meant from both sides of the game. i would have had the innocent view, and then after turning, if the snitch was still alive, i would have been able to understand the WW point of view and see how important the snitch might have been. since we didn't have a snitch, that wasn't one of the roles that i was able to get 2 understandings of.
