Mafia #7 -- The Play

sploke said:
mee-mee, I would really love to see some explanation of this. I've been hounded for two days for being overly skeptical and going against the majority, and now your reason for placing a vote on me is because i let people lead me around? That makes ABSOLUTELY no sense. What does make sense is that your teammate Ice put me on a snitch list, and after finding out that ZS was all over me and he was mafia, you guys have figured out that I am actually innocent and not on the opposing mafia team, and are trying to start a train (which may not be too hard since I was on the snitch list). Either that you've missed about everything I've said this entire game.

I vote to lynch Mee-mee...I think we may have one of Ice's colleagues here.

In other news. MP is bringing flashbacks of MikenDanielle in M6....he was actually innocent, but so freakin confrontational, people were willing to lynch him just to get him out of the game regardless of loyalties. Lots of vague, cryptic messages and high defense without actually saying anything of consequence.

I think JL is innocent...his post style and pattern just mead me to think he really has the town's best interests in mind.

Joander and HN have both made me a bit twitchy but not really anything I can put my finger on thus far.

DC's postings have made me lean mafia as well, but historically he's been kind of in and out of games so its hard to tell if it means anything.
Click to expand...

I agree with the majority of this actually, but the highlighted portion makes no sense to me. Per the rules, If one mafia team investigates a member from the other team they show as innocent. So, how would she know you weren't on the opposing team?
 
sploke said:
In other news. MP is bringing flashbacks of MikenDanielle in M6....he was actually innocent, but so freakin confrontational, people were willing to lynch him just to get him out of the game regardless of loyalties. Lots of vague, cryptic messages and high defense without actually saying anything of consequence.
Click to expand...

This is the part that bothers me. I would like to think that mystery player is innocent. There is a 50/50 chance that they are.

I just wish they would add something and contribute to what we have going on.

I do not think annoying and lame are in themselves reasons for lynching someone.

I do not like the fact that they turned a vote back on me, when I gave them some heat. That seems to be the only real mafia thing they have done.

I would love to hear reasons not to lynch mystery player.
 
Hooked Newbie said:
I agree with the majority of this actually, but the highlighted portion makes no sense to me. Per the rules, If one mafia team investigates a member from the other team they show as innocent. So, how would she know you weren't on the opposing team?
Click to expand...

She wouldn't know, but they could make an educated guess. Ice and ZS were on opposing mafia teams. ZS was really baiting me, trying to get me to make myelf look mafia. When I actually started posting suspicions of him on the first day and subsequently voted for him, he backed off with an "hey its cool man, i think you're innocent now" comment. He then pretty much ignored me when I kept pressing, and voted for him the second day. If Ice's mafia group knows I'm not there, then they can make a pretty fair guess that if I was on ZS's team I would be trying to out him like that. But, if I'm on a few lists, then suddenly appear on a snitch list, its not a huge stretch for one of Ice's teammates to come up with some BS reason to vote in hopes that everyone will jump on board.
 
CRap I just went back and realized that Z and Ice were on the same team...so that nbegates that part of the argument.
 
johnlarson66 said:
It was edited 6 or 7 minutes after it was posted. I think this is the only post that says "edited" on the bottom. I did see KOTD doing it and said something, but it did not say "edited" on the bottom. I think there is a time limit to it.

Also, Mad, you seem to have no concern on what the mystery player said in the first place. I think we were waiting on them to post some "information".
No, it wasn't anything particularly incriminating...there were 2 quotes by Joander and one by you....MP then accused you of being aggressive... I only called them out because the post completely disappeared and was replaced w/ LOL.

Of the choices presented, I still like the idea of lynching mystery player. Here's why I dislike lynching MP at this time. You're acting like the townies are cruising right along lynching mafia, and that we're in great shape. We're really not....yes, we are down 3 mafia, but 2 were killed by competing mafia and the other (Ice) may have only been lynched because King came out as detective. The townies really haven't hit paydirt on their own, yet. Therefore, I'm not willing to just toss MP because we don't know their status....we don't know the majority of player's status. If MP ends up as an innocent, we may need their numbers at some point.

People are freaking that the detective will only get an innocent read on MP. There have been games where the detective was hit on Night 1 and we didn't have their investigations at all. What did we do in that case? We certainly didn't just alphabetize the player's names and just lynch them in order because any one of them might be mafia. We used our brains to determine their status to the best of our abilities and then lynched. Nobody curled up in a fetal position crying 'I'm so scared....' I'm really surprised at the amount of time you've spent tring to get MP lynched for no real reason at this time. You say that 'bad attitude' is a good enough reason to lynch. IMO that's not a good enough reason to lynch....I try to look for signs that the person is actually mafia.

I think we would all benefit from another day of investigations and to see what the mafia do.
Click to expand...
.
 
Ok, apparently I'm in need of some "special" help this game, so I'm listing this out in one place for reference..

Day 1 - Lady G, new mafia, killed on hit by old mafia. Swayde lynched.

Day 2 - IceH2O lynched, old mafia, snitch. ZS, old mafia, don, hit by new mafia.

Ice gives snitch list - Ice, plantling, charlie, sploke.
 
sploke said:
Ok, apparently I'm in need of some "special" help this game, so I'm listing this out in one place for reference..

Day 1 - Lady G, new mafia, killed on hit by old mafia. Swayde lynched.

Day 2 - IceH2O lynched, old mafia, snitch. ZS, old mafia, don, hit by new mafia.

Ice gives snitch list - Ice, plantling, charlie, sploke.
Click to expand...

I am not 100% sure if Ice gave that snitch list. I posted about this before. Could each group have a snitch? Is there an Old and New snitch?
 
Oh thats true JL...I'm going on the assumption that each mafia has its own snitch, so you're right, I don't know why I automatically assumed that came from Ice. It just made sense that if he had to put out a list with one mafia name on it, and he was pretty much gone anyway, he would use his own.
 
mystery player said:
Ya your right, its happened in this game and other games, thought i could catch it and change it but to late......
Click to expand...

anyone one else think of CL when you read this post?
 
Update...thru post 889....

to lynch....

jl66 (1) by mysplr 834

sploke (1) by mee-mee 870

mysplr (2) by charlie 761 jl66 753

hook (2) by Mad 851 Deputy 852

Deputy (1) by Hook 854

meemee (1) by sploke 879

8 of 14 have voted.....

No votes yet from joander, plantling, KOTD, DD, jpap, Wata....


Night fall at 12 Noon today....in about 5 1/2 hrs......

PMs or e-mails can be sent in at any time folks....thanks!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom