I read that to mean she will die Night 2. In which case I think the town would benefit from focusing on the active players till then.
Biological Badlands...Mafia #8
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
I read that to mean she will die Night 2. In which case I think the town would benefit from focusing on the active players till then.
Thank you Swayde, I noted that one..but since there are so many other list's since I posted this I will just let it go if that is ok to do. I can't go back and edit it now and since other lists are done it should be fine I think.
Very valid point. I would move my vote, but to whom? I am not convinced Mee-mee is a bad guy and she's always been a great asset for the townies so I'd rather see more out of her before I make up my mind for sure. Ewurm is one of my suspects, but he's so new that it's hard to say for sure and after what all happend with Mike it makes me very hesitant to vote on him since he is actually playing. Nmrsco is gaining suspicion for so very few posts, I'd be most likely to move my vote to him if I decide to move it. Jpap I still have a high suspicion of, but he did come post and at least try and explain his absence and after knowing how bad it sucks to be lynched when you try to say you had RL stuff keeping you busy, I am gun-shy to vote on him.
Then there are CS and Ice who each have one vote on them. I've said before that Ice I am leaning to innocent because he's been very logical and reasonable, unlike last game where he was irrational, back peddling and seriously grasping at straws. CS does seem a bit off this game. I haven't decided if it's in a good way or a bad way yet, and if he IS a townie, I think it would be a bad thing to lose him so early on.
As for everyone else, I just don't have any proof or strong suspicions either way and certainly not anything to justify a vote on.
I agree that voting GGF at this time would not be a good idea. Although I also agree that day 1 is the hardest when it comes to voting. There's so little to go on, but I think we should try. And I just checked and it looks like nmrsco hassn't been active since their last post, so I wouldnt' put my vote there yet either. The strongest case I have is against ewurm. He voted very early for HN and didn't list any reasons until prompted to do so. Then he switched his vote to mee-mee, still no reasons until prompted. Also his "team" post strikes me as a bit suspicious. So, I vote to genetically test ewurm.
Do you guys really think it's such a bad idea to vote off guppy?
I agree ewurm is very suspicious and would like to see more from him/reasons/help..anything more than just voting on someone and half responding to post made about him, but I am trying to not read too much into him just yet as he is new and may really be trying to figure the game out. If on the other hand by night 2 nothing has changed with him I will most likely be putting more thought into him and voting his way.
MM, I do agree has played not quite right I do see suspicion in her and may in the end switch my vote over to her, she has been mainly coming out when her name is mentioned and that makes me nervous too.
My thoughts as far as guppy goes is if s/he isn't going to take the time to help the town at all not even acknowledge the game then what good is it to keep them around? Although if she does end up townie then that weakens the towns chances and I don't like that thought either. I was hoping by at least saying I was going to vote her/his way MAYBE along with the other votes going that way s/he would come out and at least say something. I don't remember anything in the sign-up post about him/her not being able to post much...does anyone know if s/he did say anything about that?
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
All I can say is wow.
What a bunch of lists and action for a day one.
I really think a lot of you are getting a little ahead of yourselves.
There really is not a whole lot to talk about and what happens is that the vocal people are the main focus of what is going on. This will spill over into the other days.
At this point I am concerned about the players that have larger post counts and want to keep an eye on them, but to me the more important ones are the players that have not voted yet. Lack of voting is bad for the town.
Anyone not voting at this point of the game is highly suspect.
Besides that, I see nothing real valuable at this point.
What a bunch of lists and action for a day one.
I really think a lot of you are getting a little ahead of yourselves.
There really is not a whole lot to talk about and what happens is that the vocal people are the main focus of what is going on. This will spill over into the other days.
At this point I am concerned about the players that have larger post counts and want to keep an eye on them, but to me the more important ones are the players that have not voted yet. Lack of voting is bad for the town.
Anyone not voting at this point of the game is highly suspect.
Besides that, I see nothing real valuable at this point.
I beleive we are looking at:
MM-(4): BKW, Ewrum, JL, KOTD
Gup-(3): CS, LG, Swayde
Ice-(1): DD
CS-(1): HN
Nmr-(1): Ice
Jp-(1): MM
Ewurm-(2): Z, Plant
So far we have 13/17 voting leaving: DC, Gup, Jp, Nmr with no vote as of yet.
MM-(4): BKW, Ewrum, JL, KOTD
Gup-(3): CS, LG, Swayde
Ice-(1): DD
CS-(1): HN
Nmr-(1): Ice
Jp-(1): MM
Ewurm-(2): Z, Plant
So far we have 13/17 voting leaving: DC, Gup, Jp, Nmr with no vote as of yet.
I'm planning to make a vote in a few....I've mostly been watching, the night 1 vote is the hardest. We're kind of shooting in the dark on very little evidence. Part of me is kind of hoping some of the people like guppy and nrmsco show up to make the choice easier. For now I'll put in a vote, but it may change later in the day.
I vote to genetically test mee-mee.
I vote to genetically test mee-mee.
By the way I'm not comfortable with just taking out guppy. In fact I kind of find the idea suspect because knocking off innocents, even if they aren't being helpful, has never helped in the past. I also wonder about the allegiances to the town of those that want to.
Not sure what's up w/GGF, I just checked and her last activity was 09-08-2007 02:05 PM, beforethe game started. Oh and fyi Lady G, sometimes pple also list their gender under their public profile. (Just click on their name above their avatar and choose public profile and look at gender. Nmrsc is male and so is ewurm.) There's a chance GGF could have been assigned an evil role, but I doubt it. And if we all form a train on her then when she's lynched we won't learn much from the voting pattern. *Sigh* Have I said how much I don't like voting on the first day?
Well I'll miss nightfall as I'll be in class tonight, but if anyone can come up with a compelling reason I should change my vote, I'll check in before I leave for my class.
