Biological Badlands...Mafia #8

[KingOfTheDeep]

Ok, I gotta admit that the Charlie thing had me thrown for a loop and has forced me to rethink my list and some of my suspicions. Here are my thoughts on folks so far in no particular order. My top suspects are highlighted in Red.

We also need to keep in mind that in addition to losing 2 last night, we could lose even more “tonight” if a vial is used.


Ewurm: Definitely looks suspicious to me so far, but I’m not as convinced of their guilt as others seem to be.

Swayde: The fascination with Guppy has gone on for 2 days now and I find it alarming. The first time you floated the idea fine, but to bring it back up today after having seen everyone’s opinions yesterday sounds alarms for me.

Ice: Your initial reaction last night to me had me more and more convinced that I was right, but you dropped it too quickly. I am still leery of you, but no longer convinced. I’d have you in yellow, but no one liked my color coded lists. I also am uneasy because of the vote and weak case on you from Swayde.

KOTD: The most suspicious thing is your need to constantly state that you’re innocent, either outright or by innuendo.

Lady G: You were too quick to vote for Guppy and then try to back off of that as soon as others spoke out against it. The vote on mee-mee closely following Ice’s is also suspect to me even though you explained it. You seem to be asking for a lot of input from others this game rather than offering your own. Wondering which way to go is the safest?

Zsandmann: Tough to read since you changed your style of play this game. Makes me wonder why other than you’re tired “of carrying the game”. The irrelevant questions last night seem like nothing more than something to throw out confusion.

DD: No real read yet and that more than anything makes you a bit suspicious to me.

Plantling: I was beginning to get suspicious of you until today. I suffer from the same “tunnel vision” at this point and what I saw from you seemed to be helpful.

Nmrsco: Seems to be winning the battle of the newbs. I think there may be something to the analysis of those that were strongly on him (KOTD, Swayde, & Jpappy).

Jpappy: Playing A LOT different this game. Is that just because of school or is school a good excuse for it? I’m not sure yet.

Jlarson: Not enough posts to even remotely be viewed as helpful to me. Why are you hiding?

bkw: Seems to be questioning people and trying to find evils.

DC: You’d be yellow too. Not a lot of substance to your posts or accusations thus far IMO.


I retract my vote for Ice and vote to genetically test johnlarson66.

lol, this and the fact that i voted for the same people as bkw makes me 100% evil..hilarious

 

[Hooked Newbie]

:footinmouth:

Nothing more than the implied "I'm innocent"?

 

[Swayde]

I don't know why people are so suspicious about me voting for Guppy. Nobody seemed to care that I voted on Jpappy because he hadn't posted yet. He did and he had an explanation and I backed off and went to Guppy, who was the only other person who hadn't posted yet. It seemed like a good plan because it had worked on Jpappy, he got to posting and explaining and actually playing.

I did not vote for Guppy today, nor have I asked anyone to. The only thing I am guilty of today is trying to work with my fellow townies to see if everyone was in agreement or not. I never once tried to talk anyone into voting for Guppy when anyone said they don't think it's a good idea. I voted for Ice, whom I stated several reasons against and he is still my top suspect right now. So what about that makes me look evil?

 

[ZSandmann]

The fact Ice doesn't seem Evil to me for one.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

I don't know why people are so suspicious about me voting for Guppy. Nobody seemed to care that I voted on Jpappy because he hadn't posted yet. He did and he had an explanation and I backed off and went to Guppy, who was the only other person who hadn't posted yet. It seemed like a good plan because it had worked on Jpappy, he got to posting and explaining and actually playing.

I did not vote for Guppy today, nor have I asked anyone to. The only thing I am guilty of today is trying to work with my fellow townies to see if everyone was in agreement or not. I never once tried to talk anyone into voting for Guppy when anyone said they don't think it's a good idea. I voted for Ice, whom I stated several reasons against and he is still my top suspect right now. So what about that makes me look evil?

Like I said, the first time fine. You seem to want to stick with it though. You seem to be looking for an easy safe vote that meets consensus. Just my 2 cents.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

lol, this and the fact that i voted for the same people as bkw makes me 100% evil..hilarious

Mind pointing out where I said you (or anyone else) was 100% evil?

:footinmouth:

 

[Hooked Newbie]

wrong again! :footinmouth:

if and when i am lynched, ice should definitely be a lynch target..you'll all agree after im dead and found to be a townie with normal genetics

I am beginning to be in favor of this experiment you suggest. I guess we should all vote for you to figure out what to do next huh?

 

[Swayde]

Like I said, the first time fine. You seem to want to stick with it though. You seem to be looking for an easy safe vote that meets consensus. Just my 2 cents.

That would make a whole lot more sense if I had not changed my vote from Guppy to Nmsrco and never revoted for Guppy.

 

[ZSandmann]

I haven't been as good at reading people as I thought. I have my suspicions about KOTD, but I am not locked in. JohnLarson's voting is troubling to me. He was locked in on Mee Mee. Doesn't post much. Is that because you don't need too? You're already aware of who to vote for?

Regarding the three votes against me, I can say that there a lot of people reading into my posts too much, seeing twisted meanings that just aren't there. That has also been my problem, as I just don't have any solid info to go on, so I am looking to hard to find someone.

JohnLarson66 popped in to toss in his vote on Mee Mee to take out an innocent. Didn't say much before that. I am studying the voting patterns looking for someone who voted for mee mee, and then someone who voted for someone I believe is innocent including me. John's voting pattern in this short amount of time leads me to believe that he is voting to pick off innocents two weeks in a row.

I retract my vote on KOTD and vote to benetically test JohnLarson66

BTW, if I die, two innocents will have been killed in a row. As the vote stands, the only person on both trains is JohnLarson66. If and when my genetics are revealed, the townies have an easy target. Remember this post when I am gone, or the town is doomed.

I find it interesting you keep going after jl so hard when I've been against you more strongly than anyone. Since Day 1 of Day 1 in fact you've given me the heebie jeebies. And some of your posts seem much more precisely phrased when it really matters, where as, at other times you seem to have the newbie confusies going on. Who writes your scripts?

The fact that you're on my back is exactly why I don't suspect you at all. My posts are confusing you, which is interpreted as evil. I can understand that, I have had that happen, with Mee Mee in particular, and I was wrong. JL on the other hand has basically been on both trains, and I believe that it will result in the town collapsing early, as no one has singled him out yet except for me if I remember correctly. I expect to die tomorrow, and with that I think that the town will understand what I am talking about, but it may be too late.

You must have Churchhill writing for you cause dang it I am starting to believe you. I fully expected to get jumped on when I posted that comment. Evils like to overreact. Same reason I asked the screwy questions last night, reactions. KOTD certainly gave me a reaction with his refusal to answer. The answer wasn't important at all, it was the cooperation. KOTD the more you proclaim innocence the more it sounds like a ploy.

I cancel my vote to test ewurm.

Prove yourself, you have one day to do it.

 

[IceH2O]

I vote to genetically test Iceh2o. The vote change back to Mee-Mee is really bothering me

I explained it, I said even before I did it that I would if I felt that an innocent was going down.

Plus he attempted to cast suspicion on me early on because of a mistake in my list. He did drop it after I explained to him that it was a misunderstanding, and I let it go. Then he tried to defend Jpap by saying it was a holiday weekend, and again I let that go when he said he admitted he again made a mistake, because I understand mistakes can and do happen.

Then he was the first person to point out that he'd changed his avatar and told everyone not to read anything into it, that rang a suspicious bell with me.

Just as political parties have talking points it seems that evil teams also do.I like to keep people on their toes and wanted to see who would take advantage of my faux slip. So far only you and DD are using it as an excuse to vote.

Also, because of his vote on KoTD...I am not sure on KoTD's innoence, but his reason is "your wish is my command" I know there is probably more to it than that, but that's what he said when he voted for him.

Already posted numerous times last night why I was suspicious of KOTD, was being sarcastic with the wish/command comment


It also seems like he's trying kinda hard to defend Ewurm as well.

Just don't see him being evil atm

It just seems there are a lot of little things he's said that are just nagging at me and right now, he's my most likely suspect.

I can accept that, little things can add up to 1 big thing. Just that all your little things are microscopic and add up to next to nothing.

responses in red