Ok, I gotta admit that the Charlie thing had me thrown for a loop and has forced me to rethink my list and some of my suspicions. Here are my thoughts on folks so far in no particular order. My top suspects are highlighted in Red.
We also need to keep in mind that in addition to losing 2 last night, we could lose even more “tonight” if a vial is used.
Ewurm: Definitely looks suspicious to me so far, but I’m not as convinced of their guilt as others seem to be.
Swayde: The fascination with Guppy has gone on for 2 days now and I find it alarming. The first time you floated the idea fine, but to bring it back up today after having seen everyone’s opinions yesterday sounds alarms for me
Ice: Your initial reaction last night to me had me more and more convinced that I was right, but you dropped it too quickly. I am still leery of you, but no longer convinced. I’d have you in yellow, but no one liked my color coded lists. I also am uneasy because of the vote and weak case on you from Swayde.
KOTD: The most suspicious thing is your need to constantly state that you’re innocent, either outright or by innuendo.
Lady G: You were too quick to vote for Guppy and then try to back off of that as soon as others spoke out against it. The vote on mee-mee closely following Ice’s is also suspect to me even though you explained it. You seem to be asking for a lot of input from others this game rather than offering your own. Wondering which way to go is the safest?
Zsandmann: Tough to read since you changed your style of play this game. Makes me wonder why other than you’re tired “of carrying the game”. The irrelevant questions last night seem like nothing more than something to throw out confusion.
DD: No real read yet and that more than anything makes you a bit suspicious to me.
Plantling: I was beginning to get suspicious of you until today. I suffer from the same “tunnel vision” at this point and what I saw from you seemed to be helpful.
Nmrsco: Seems to be winning the battle of the newbs. I think there may be something to the analysis of those that were strongly on him (KOTD, Swayde, & Jpappy).
Jpappy: Playing A LOT different this game. Is that just because of school or is school a good excuse for it? I’m not sure yet.
Jlarson: Not enough posts to even remotely be viewed as helpful to me. Why are you hiding?
bkw: Seems to be questioning people and trying to find evils.
DC: You’d be yellow too. Not a lot of substance to your posts or accusations thus far IMO.
I retract my vote for Ice and vote to genetically test johnlarson66.
I have explained this a couple times...guess I will again, I never intended to actually keep my vote on guppy, I thought maybe throwing her name out there would bring him out, she never came out.
As far as my vote for MM, I had already talked about my suspicions toward her..as did many others, Ice nor anyone else had anything to do with my decision my vote after his was just the way it happened, I had planned on voting way earlier but did not get home in time to do so, it's just that simple.
Yes I have asked others imput, I thought the town was suppose to help each other...and I have explained this also, this is the first game I have played with newbs and really wanted others opinions
Now I think this whole KOTD thing as side tracked everyone. I really don't know what to think of it, him voting himself really threw me.
I am really leaning more toward DD now, she is always very sly and low key and so hard to read, this has made me suspicious of her in every game...right now this is popping out at me the most:
We have to really come together folks.... we are down two innocents on the first night..... not good at all.
mee-mee.... I am so sad to see you go, I too will miss your choclate puffs and I am completely heartbroken to lose you, Charlie.... *sigh* I will keep you tucked under my pillow my charlie prince...
She say's this but NONE of her post since has said anything to really help out in any way. Pretty much the only time she is posting is when someone mentions her, then it is just to defend herself...is this "pulling together" in anyway, not in my book.
DD I am interested in your thoughts, we all know you suspect Ice since you voted him...but do you have any thoughts on anyone else or just those that mention you?
Wow! It got even worse after I went to bed. I am surprised by your play King. I just don't understand. Heck, we all get accused and we all get voted out. It sounds like a bitter Innocent on the surface, but you play a smart game normally, I can't help but be cautious and think this is all a ploy. One that isn't working right now.
IF King is in fact proven Evil, we need to look at who we were voting on BEFORE he voted himself. It could be a protection screen to save Dr. Gene. Just a thought.
Also, as much as I want to believe ewurm is beginning to understand the game, I still have a nag in the back of my mind. If you took one of his Day 1 posts and one of his Day 2 posts and compared them you would swear they were written by two different people. But I'm no longer willing to cast a vote to find out which it is.
I'm leaving my office now for Baton Rouge, see everyone on the other side. I leave you with a list in case I don't make it back before Night.
There are five possible evils, I don't know if that includes the Dr. or not.
KOTD
Lady G
Swayde
johnlarson66
DeputyChief
jpappy789
Plantling
GGF???? (We'll see tonight)
ewurm
DangerDoll
IceH2O
bkw1982
Hooked Newbie
nmrsco
Zsandmann
I 100% agree with this statement, if we look back most were going after Ewurm before this. Do you think they are connected? Would KOTD give himself up to protect him?
As of now my list would have to be:
DD
KOTD
Ewurm
