My current thoughts:
GGF is almost surely innocent, but if we stake the kidnapper (literally), then we lose her too.
LadyG is posting some seemingly good stuff.
Zsand, DD and Sway seem to be their usual selves at this point.
JL seems to be behaving normally... but with his generally low post count, it's hard to tell.
I'd vote for Ice, but he's... well... nevermind
I'm thinking that the vampires (especially, the new one) will be laying somewhat low. Based on that pathetically shaky logic, I won't be voting for wcol either.
Just to shake the trees a little. I vote to stake (shudder) Charlie_Stubbs.
This is because... I can't get anything from the post search for him more recently than Sept 9. Weird.