MAFIA 10: Vampires!
- Thread starter IceH2O
- Start date
I think that the Seer/Hunter combination is way too powerful when it only takes 1 hit to end the game. The Seer/Priest might be better, but still is pretty powerful, especially when the priest can stop the lynch (maybe if the priest could only stop the vamp hit?)
Also, the switching of power roles if the Hunter or Seer are turned on the 1st 2 nights is kind of a bust for the vamps.....especially when the Hunter/Seer get automatic contact with each other on Day 1. If one of the power team is turned on Day 1 or 2, the other automatically knows when they get a PM that they have a new power team-mate....I understand that you move the power role, as on nights 1 & 2 you're giving free vamps to the LV, but something to think about for the next game.
BTW, who were the other power roles in this game?
Until Chas came out, we liked DD for Hunter, Z for Seer, and Chas for kidnapper.
~ Mee-Mee!!!! I am so sorry! And darn you Lady G, you totally had me fooled and I was even willing to try and hide away with you to feel safe...*cringes*
Power roles were
Seer- Charlie
Hunter -DD
Priest- Z
Kidnapper- Ewurm
I agree that the power roles should stay with the people. I didn't think about the power roles being switched being so obvious to the other player.
How about if the top vote getter is protected the 2nd highest vote getter is knocked off?
I'm not a fan of any one person blocking the lynch (especially someone who may definitely know a possible lynchee's status, as they're communicating with the seer). Kind of takes the guessing out of the priest role. Same with the hunter when they communicate with the seer, also. Maybe have the Hunter/Priest communicate? Gives them a chance to discuss outside the thread, but nothing is ever really KNOWN to them....still alot of guesswork and logic needs to be used on their part?
Also, one other suggestion....as the lovers (Chas & DD) ended up as power roles, it looks like the roles were hand-picked. I'd prefer that roles were always randomly assigned. I'd be willing to bet that Chas' investigation of rb on night 1 had more to do with who he thought you might put in the role versus anything that rb said or did by that point. I could be wrong, though.
you may be right mad. i reasoned he either began evil, or was turned for his obvious mod powers. you know that feeling you get when you win with pocket three's, i have that feeling. Lady G was never investigated.
I have it set up so that the SEER and Priest can communicate but only after the Seer finds the Priest now.
Also I always hand pick my roles. I don't care if its random, if a newbie (1st or 2nd time player) ended up with the LV role it would have been switched anyway. Ever notice the newbs never have the most important roles?
I could have given the LV to anyone, I just thought with Rb being SO OBVIOUS that he wouldn't be looked at. Reverse psychology.
Also I always hand pick my roles. I don't care if its random, if a newbie (1st or 2nd time player) ended up with the LV role it would have been switched anyway. Ever notice the newbs never have the most important roles?
I could have given the LV to anyone, I just thought with Rb being SO OBVIOUS that he wouldn't be looked at. Reverse psychology.
Dangerdoll
Global Moderator
Ice you stole my thunder. I was the Priest and I had Charlie very much protected! Good game everyone!
Well Double Dee, anyone who doesn't think we should win that best couples poll should eat that boot KOTD always posts!!! I wish we were always on the same team. Wanna get married??? We could hang out more!!!great game guys)
