Mafia #12

I very well may change my vote before night falls tomorrow, but I still have a "bad" feeling about Jpappy and I really want to hear from him. The timing of his first post along with the timely disappearance last night don't feel right to me. Other than that, the only "oddity" I see from today is LG's mistake in her post to DP/Jpappy. Interesting for someone that's been very detailed and organized in past games...

The quiet ones always make me nervous too, usual suspects there... KOTD, JL, Rb, etc.

KOTD is always quiet, and occasionally gets the boot for it. I can't tell either way about him based solely on his lack of posting. I hope he decides to play this time. RB always shows up here and there, I am looking forward to him giving some info. JL is always a tough read for me. He usually is quiet and then shows up with a glut of posts, I expect that to be the case again. We'll see what he has to say too.
 
I was hoping to post more today but the vamps at the blood bank sucked the life out of me and now I have a killer headache.

The Ice/DD debate is not unexpected but also unsettling, it's early guys, yes look for slips but no need to go for blood.

jpappy is looking more and more like a scapegoat, I'm not seeing any "evilness".

ewurm is being quiet, still not ready to back out of my vote just yet. Need more input!

There are several folks laying very low right now and those would be my biggest suspects, by saying nothing you say it all IMO.

Day 1 - 6/17 Votes - Saturday at about 9PM Central Time
1-Hooked Newbie: johnlarson66 (12) Swayde (103)
1-ewurm: ZSandmann (72)
3-jpappy789: Hooked Newbie (76) IceH2O (78) Charlie_stubbs (124) DangerDoll (131)
1-Charlie Stubss: IceH2O (129)
0-Dwarf Puffers: Dwarf Puffers (23)

I am not being quiet. I posted quite a bit last night. This morning I was running errands, then did some cleaning and made dinner. You will see posts from me frequently at night, and maybe in the morning if I am not too busy.
 
Not to be a party pooper, but I don't plan on a list for day One. I do have the normal concerns over how some of the players have jid exceedingly well in previous games and they should be cause for all of us to watch....

Folks like jpap, jl, judge, charlie, hooked, lady G


Those names are in no particular order of importance and I do not have any major concerns to their posts as of yet.

I suspect every one right now, even myself since I have still not found the missing 2 vials from the last game...:nilly:
 
i generally agree with this jappy. the fact is the timing of your "list" is very suspect. So was the timing of your "volunteer" work. There are some suspicious posts from you but it was the list that really tripped the switch for me. i vote to lynch jpappy

Pappy, really the reason why I picked up on your accusation was because of the post alone. While you said it's not serious, you still went ahead and posted a long post to seemingly help the town of your so called picked up hints. That in of itself, has gotten my suspicious of you, my friend. Are you forgetting we were a team not so long ago, yes, just last game, dear? This was pretty smart actually, you pushed that list to look like the helper of the town but IMO, it was posted way too soon. Sure there should be suspicions, I am not disputing that, however I am disputing the fact that you even felt compelled to post the list so early in the game. I would totally be suggesting folks do that to make it look like they were most innocent if I was from the Mafia group.... that has me raising eyebrows on you, sugar.

actually, I am quite surprised you are going this route, Ice. You are still accusing folks of "weak reasons", which puts me on a high alert at this time. I don't know what the reason for it is, maybe I am just tired of that being an excuse. I would have thought you would have been more wise than to claim "the ol' weak reason" bit again. I totally agree with Charlie and his vote though, and am glad I am not the only one who finds pappy's list a bit premature and too "trying to seem friendly" so early in the game. Weak reason, I don't think so, I just think because the post was suspected so early is what's got you a bit nervous. I don't think I have to say it but I will, you have made it to my SL (Suspect List).

I vote to lynch pappy

I still do not see what the big deal is on this "list" it was nothing odd, maybe a bit early but he wasn't saying "this person IS Mafia, this person ISN"T" just a few observations as I saw it.
Added comment to DD, you make mention of the "weak" word, kinda the word of last game...but wasn't Ice innocent and you mafia last game?
 
Given the fact that I think we need to "beat the grass" and she is posting so much less so far this game than previous... I retract my vote for Jpappy (for now) and vote to ynch mee-mee. I very well may go back to Jpappy and if I do, feel free to point me out as the "train" starter since I voted that way first. He is still quite suspicious to me so far.
 
No votes from... Jmax, Jpappy, KOTD, LadyG, mee-mee, Plantling, Rb, or Sovran.

Votes are a way to get reactions and gather information IMO. Why none yet? It's a long day with plenty of time to change. Not voting looks like laying low to me.
 
Guess you could add swayde and dwarf to that list since they have retracted their previous votes.

Still contemplating things here..fine lines, hooked, between starting a train, jumping ship, distancing and laying low.

;)
 
There should be more action tomorrow. This 1st day was actually 72 hrs from game start to end of 1st day. I guess Ogre waited since the game started so late he didn't count the 1st night.

I too would love to hear the thoughts of the quiet ones. Doesn't do us or yourselves any good to lurk, all that happens is we lynch an innocent. The only ones with reason to lurk are mafia. That way we kill ourselves off and they don't need to do a thing.
 
Guess you could add swayde and dwarf to that list since they have retracted their previous votes.

Still contemplating things here..fine lines, hooked, between starting a train, jumping ship, distancing and laying low.

;)

True enough. Feel free to point out what you think I may be "guilty" of. That could be good info for the town.
 
AquariaCentral.com