I think DC's logic was that he said he was out partying, and someone said something to the effect of "yeah likely story you're probably just evil". anyone who has played in at least one game with DC knows his history of missed votes and drunk postings...hm if I keep going someone's going to try and start an intervention. Anyway, JM also has a history of posting a fair amount, most of which contain not much actual info, but allusions to having info, and lots of excuses why she can't post. If she spent that time actually posting thoughts instead of excuses, she'd actually contribute a fair amount to the game.