I haven't seen that JM has been on at all, I can only go by posts made though.
JM isn't acting freaky enough IMO to be a witch. As a bad guy she is usually all over everyone, I'm not seeing it.
Unless of course she was told to lay low, but as active as she has been in past games I don't think she could if she wanted to.
I know I've said I would not post as much but I just can't seem to do it.
Oh Ice that is a good idea also, I would hope for them to use it on a innocent. But yes I think that spell 3 would be best to use the first night. The only other name I would add to the list would be Charlie, since he seems to have good ideas and thoughts also.
Dp, Jmax, King, and the two newbs would be a waste with that one I think since they don't post much anyway. Just thought I'd add who not to use it on.
crap... then i guess i will have to be eliminated..