True but ewurm did nail jl on like the second day. So until B comes up with some good evidence he is on my list
Mafia #13 - The Witches of ACville- the play
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
True but ewurm did nail jl on like the second day. So until B comes up with some good evidence he is on my list
Early lunch so a quick reply.
I'm going to hold my vote for now, I want to actually be able to process the posts I had listed and tear them down before I make any rash judgments.
I'm going to hold my vote for now, I want to actually be able to process the posts I had listed and tear them down before I make any rash judgments.
Well we know now it wasn't distancing don't we. Looks like a list of 2 known innocents and 1 unknown innocent.
Again Ice, you are all trying to misrepresent me. It was not a list. It was a comment EARLY on in the game about you and Lady G. You are the one who had Lady G on a list w/me (and DD, Z, and Ogre) and insinuated that even though I mentioned LG also, it was only to for distancing. Distancing my foot! She's a known innocent but you also being an innocent is yet to be proven and is very much in question IMO.
Sorry.I missed the top quote.
Originally Posted by plantling
Wow! Some early votes already. Though Ice and Lady G do seem to know a bit about witches. Hmmmm...
Wanted to point out one of her 1st posts are already throwing suspicion my way. I know she mentions LG also but it could be distancing.
This is the post where Ice first says I was trying to distance myself from LG. It was in response to my early comment about their knowledge of witches. He had her on his witch list and insinuated that I was distancing. I merely had her on my "notes of interest" post. But he is trying to hang me for it. Isn't this the pot calling the kettle?
Dangerdoll
Global Moderator
I had my vote on JM because I thought for sure, she must be witchy. I contemplated moving my vote but things just seemed to point her more and more toward the witchy way due to her not even responding to our votes. She never really even tried to defend herself. Yes, she was busy but the board showed that she was here, so being here why couldn't she at least put something out there to change our minds. I am not saying she is at fault for not being here, but I am saying she didn't defend herself in the least when I believe she could have.
As far as who I think might be guilty. Well, Brk does seem to sit on my list for his last minute scramble for the vote in the minutes before night. First he voted charlie, then no one, then in a last minute attempt, voted Plant. Maybe he voted plant so he didn't have to be questioned why he was voting Judge. He also looks guilty for putting a vote out earlier without reason, and then a few posts later, posts reason. 2 strange ones if you ask me. Again, I will say that this shows me that because he is new, he ran back to the board after discussing with his cronies that he needs to put out reasons in order not to look so "suspicious". When all along, we would have probably passed his vote over with a little leniency because he is in fact the newbie to the game.
I don't want to say the other newbie is on my alert but the simple fact is, that he is. Call it a language barrier or what have you but it seems to me, he is forcing the cryptic talk. Half the time, I haven't the slightest clue as to what he is saying. He tries blaming his hours for his meek attempt at the game, f which I find a poor excuse. If anything, it helps him think a lot more than a lot of us. Yet, he does not try to correct his play or his messages, he simply doesn't post.
DC... well, that drunk post kinda blew me away. I think it woulda been better if he didn't post at all and came back the next day with a hangover post.... as was mentioned, the last thing I would be thnking about if I came home that drunk where my post showed so many typos, all I would be thinking about is sleep. The post seems phony and may have been planted so that he was not questioned for his low posting that day.
King for picking out in my spell explanations that LG must be witchy. He seemed to read it and immediately believe this was it. There should be no other explanation.... perhaps it's because he didn't have one..... chose the easy way out and continued back to the "lay low" strategy of some mafia/witchy roles.
Ogre for discrediting the spells as hints for the town completely. Yes, one or two may be nonsense but rb's track records show that he does hint. When I was mafia and had my team, we were completely sweeping the town until rb came out with those hints of his. This leads me to also suspect Z and Pappy though they are each leaning innocent.
Those that just give me shakey feelings are Ice and Charlie. Both very good players with a lot to say. I haven't pin pointed exactly what bothers me on each, but I do get a weeird feeling from each.
This also bothers me about Sway, however I am not sold on her being guilty or innocent yet. Just wantd to make a note of it.
I did not get a PM last night
As far as who I think might be guilty. Well, Brk does seem to sit on my list for his last minute scramble for the vote in the minutes before night. First he voted charlie, then no one, then in a last minute attempt, voted Plant. Maybe he voted plant so he didn't have to be questioned why he was voting Judge. He also looks guilty for putting a vote out earlier without reason, and then a few posts later, posts reason. 2 strange ones if you ask me. Again, I will say that this shows me that because he is new, he ran back to the board after discussing with his cronies that he needs to put out reasons in order not to look so "suspicious". When all along, we would have probably passed his vote over with a little leniency because he is in fact the newbie to the game.
I don't want to say the other newbie is on my alert but the simple fact is, that he is. Call it a language barrier or what have you but it seems to me, he is forcing the cryptic talk. Half the time, I haven't the slightest clue as to what he is saying. He tries blaming his hours for his meek attempt at the game, f which I find a poor excuse. If anything, it helps him think a lot more than a lot of us. Yet, he does not try to correct his play or his messages, he simply doesn't post.
DC... well, that drunk post kinda blew me away. I think it woulda been better if he didn't post at all and came back the next day with a hangover post.... as was mentioned, the last thing I would be thnking about if I came home that drunk where my post showed so many typos, all I would be thinking about is sleep. The post seems phony and may have been planted so that he was not questioned for his low posting that day.
King for picking out in my spell explanations that LG must be witchy. He seemed to read it and immediately believe this was it. There should be no other explanation.... perhaps it's because he didn't have one..... chose the easy way out and continued back to the "lay low" strategy of some mafia/witchy roles.
Ogre for discrediting the spells as hints for the town completely. Yes, one or two may be nonsense but rb's track records show that he does hint. When I was mafia and had my team, we were completely sweeping the town until rb came out with those hints of his. This leads me to also suspect Z and Pappy though they are each leaning innocent.
Those that just give me shakey feelings are Ice and Charlie. Both very good players with a lot to say. I haven't pin pointed exactly what bothers me on each, but I do get a weeird feeling from each.
This also bothers me about Sway, however I am not sold on her being guilty or innocent yet. Just wantd to make a note of it.
I did not get a PM last night
DD I really like your insight. Although it is out of character for you this post eases my earlier suspicions of you.
Ice the reason I asked Lg if she would switch was because she said herself she would switch to plant because she didn't really like her jm vote but plant only had 3 at the time while jm had 5. Then b switched off of jm, probably becuase he didn't want to get blamed for the vote with no reason and I thought lg would end up switching to plant because it made a difference so I asked but it was already night by then...I wasn't trying to push a plant vote. If I were a witch, why wouldn't I just let jm die? Just to clarify...
