Mafia #13 - The Witches of ACville- the play

[IceH2O]

I'm still interested in seeing who the Warlock has used a spell on.

I'm thinking the Rb probably told them in PM they can't say.

I wouldn't risk it if it was me, after Jpap died last game for hinting he was black mailed.. Whats funny is he could have just refused to be blackmailed and died and not had an innocent die that night. Instead he killed an innocent and himself.

No I saw her lists but she never provided what she said "all in due time" about. At least not in so many words. If you look at my comments, I didn't think she was continuing to hide things, it was more the fact that she never addressed what she thought she had early on. I mean after reading her after death post its clear she was just busy, but when Night was approaching she didn't offer any sort of feedback. That in my experiences is not like her at all, usually if someone even brings up her name they get scathing replies back almost instantly.

I agree but its because her gameplay has mostly been as an evil. When she wasn't answering every post was when I was pretty sure she was innocent.

I do accept you answer and it drops you closer to mid pack.

Ogres last post doesn't make sense to me so he moves up, guess he could take your place on the list,especially since I'm pretty sure I have to many people on it.

 

[ZSandmann]

My vote was a first day vote. I distinctly remember saying that I hadn't found anyone that screamed suspicious through the day. JM caught my attention as well as many others. I'm not sure what else to say on that subject. I play the same way every game and everyone pegs me as guilty, I must have learned my playing style from Coler. I guess just because I don't play like everyone else it means I'm automatically guilty...

Dc's last post. How did she catch your attention? You do have a consistent play style, I'll give you that. I never label anyone automatically guilty, that's a close minded way to play the game. I don't understand why the high posters are always targeted first, I guess it is subliminal as you see their names more often as you read the thread.

I just got home from footbalsal and drank a whisdle lot...I was trying to ply but resalized that at this point read isn't one f my specialties...Jon wcvill be backsf in the morning...He wilsl answer then...

Here is the drunken post. Mistyped words are bolded. If I were drunk and posting I would fat finger the keys but these words don't look like that if you study the key placement. Also, he refers to himself by his real name. What I notice is that there are just a few extra letters added or a few letters deleted from words. At a glance it looks garbled but it isn't at all.

The Red Sox took House's time slot. Hisssssssssss!!!

 

[ZSandmann]

I'm thinking the Rb probably told them in PM they can't say.

I wouldn't risk it if it was me, after Jpap died last game for hinting he was black mailed.. Whats funny is he could have just refused to be blackmailed and died and not had an innocent die that night. Instead he killed an innocent and himself.

I agree but its because her gameplay has mostly been as an evil. When she wasn't answering every post was when I was pretty sure she was innocent.

I do accept you answer and it drops you closer to mid pack.

Ogres last post doesn't make sense to me so he moves up, guess he could take your place on the list,especially since I'm pretty sure I have to many people on it.

True, but it doesn't say in the rules it is verboten. Obviously if the switch spell is used they are not going to say, but the no vote spell is easy enough to verify so it doesn't really matter if it is divulged, just a nugget of info I would like to have.

To be fair I don't remember everyone's roles from game to game, I believe when you say she has been Evil the majority, I barely remember my roles :huh:

Ogre: I haven't really solidified my opinion yet. I find myself agreeing with his posts at times, but he is being very mellow, trying not to cause a stir. Works for Witches, PRs, and Innocents that want to keep playing. Lord knows every game I say I'm going to post less but it never comes to fruition.

 

[ZSandmann]

Kind of surprised at the lack of voting being half way through a day. Last thing we need are untimely deaths, remember you can vote No One now, but I don't recommend it. I personally wish it was removed as a viable option completely.

5/13 Votes
4-BrkD: Charlie (406) jpappy (465) Ogre (495) DD (500)
1-DeputyChief: ZSandmann (505)

 

[plantling]

I still feel as though Plantling might be witch but the posts aren't as harsh as I thought on JM. Could just be that she is on my *** so hard.

Ice, I don't think I was quite as harsh on her as she was on me. My post to her about not using the words "you people" were well intentioned, but she basically implied I wasn't smart enough if I didn't understand what she meant. I dropped it because I didn't want to argue, though Swayde agreed w/me about how those words could be misconstrued. And you claim I was on your *** so hard, but you're the one who rallied votes my way. However, I'm willing to drop it for the time being as you have seemed more and more helpful to the town.

 

[jpappy789]

I'm thinking the Rb probably told them in PM they can't say.

I wouldn't risk it if it was me, after Jpap died last game for hinting he was black mailed.. Whats funny is he could have just refused to be blackmailed and died and not had an innocent die that night. Instead he killed an innocent and himself.

Hey leave last game out of this.:silly:

I actually pmed ogre asking if I could hint at being blackmailed and he never responded so I decided to do it anyways because it would clear Chas and I was afraid he was a pr and I knew I wasn't so it didn't really matter if I died. But nobody listened, especially the mafia so it was kind of worth it...I was just as surprised as everyone else when I was killed because I never actually said "I was blackmailed"...guess that shows how lax our rules are...

anyways

I too am surprised at the lack of participation from some people, mostly DC, KOTD and Brkd, though it kind of is expected...three people who aren't really on anyones good side right now.

 

[plantling]

Rule #1- don't say "darn it I'm innocent!"

Rule #2- don't vote without reasons, especially late in the day

that was to Brkd for the random vote on plant

crap... then i guess i will have to be eliminated..

oh is this a "crap I screwed up big time, I guess I admit to being a witch..."???

nah uh.. i just screwed up. sorry guys.

Rereading through the scenerio last night, I am inclined to believe BrkD was just a bit confused. He seemed to believe he'd messed up by voting without posting a reason and to me, the "sorry guys" was to the town for messing up. So perhaps I'm being snowed by a newbie, but I'm not inclined to vote for him at this moment.

I always have a hard time reading KOTD, but from memory, he did tend to post less and cast throw away votes when he was evil. So perhaps this will draw him out of hiding: I vote to burn KOTD at the stake.

 

[jpappy789]

Rereading through the scenerio last night, I am inclined to believe BrkD was just a bit confused. He seemed to believe he'd messed up by voting without posting a reason and to me, the "sorry guys" was to the town for messing up. So perhaps I'm being snowed by a newbie, but I'm not inclined to vote for him at this moment.

I always have a hard time reading KOTD, but from memory, he did tend to post less and cast throw away votes when he was evil. So perhaps this will draw him out of hiding: I vote to burn KOTD at the stake.

The only thing I don't like about this is that he didn't check back at the actual rules. But I still do not like the plant vote and the silence today so my vote will stay. But DC is my next suspect.

 

[plantling]

Hey leave last game out of this.:silly:

I actually pmed ogre asking if I could hint at being blackmailed and he never responded so I decided to do it anyways because it would clear Chas and I was afraid he was a pr and I knew I wasn't so it didn't really matter if I died. But nobody listened, especially the mafia so it was kind of worth it...I was just as surprised as everyone else when I was killed because I never actually said "I was blackmailed"...guess that shows how lax our rules are...

anyways

I too am surprised at the lack of participation from some people, mostly DC, KOTD and Brkd, though it kind of is expected...three people who aren't really on anyones good side right now.

I thought the rules were that Jp's final vote had to match whatever the Don wanted at the end of the day. I only doubted you and Chaz for a few minutes there Jp. We won anyway thanks in part to your deaths.

 

[plantling]

The only thing I don't like about this is that he didn't check back at the actual rules. But I still do not like the plant vote and the silence today so my vote will stay. But DC is my next suspect.

I really didn't like B's vote for me either, but he seemed to apologize for it so I'm gonna let it be.

DC is another confusing read. When I played New Mafia w/him he did seem to talk about drinking a lot. Z's analysis of his drunken post was interesting but I've never been drunk on a keyboard, so I wouldnt' know.