Mafia #13 - The Witches of ACville- the play

[OgreMkV]

Looking back at this again. Why is pappy not on the list? You say there are 6 unknowns, but you omitted pappy.

heh... it was jpappy's list. But I think I covered him nicely in the rest of the post.

Z, you are defending jpappy, you have done so at least twice. He's as much of a witch as you are.


Guys, I know what you think. This isn't a last ditch effort to save myself. Ice, I would appreciate it you didn't use your spell against me, it would be bad for the town. Remember what happened last time?

Anyway, you can believe me or not. The evidence is there, just as plain as day. I'll also say that it's a darn sight more evidence than Z has put out so far.

 

[charlie_stubbs]

With who is left, I would like thoughts on Ogre

Here are my thoughts Double Dee.

Either Ogre or Jpap is a witch. I don't think they're both witches, as Ogre has justed named Jpap as one of his suspects.

I vote to burn Jpap at the stake.

 

[charlie_stubbs]

heh... it was jpappy's list. But I think I covered him nicely in the rest of the post.

Z, you are defending jpappy, you have done so at least twice. He's as much of a witch as you are.


Guys, I know what you think. This isn't a last ditch effort to save myself. Ice, I would appreciate it you didn't use your spell against me, it would be bad for the town. Remember what happened last time?

Anyway, you can believe me or not. The evidence is there, just as plain as day. I'll also say that it's a darn sight more evidence than Z has put out so far.

I really dont know whether to believe you or not.

My vote is to use the spell on Jpap.

 

[DeputyChiefJR]

DC if you can't protect yourself, Ice would be the best bet. As he is most likely really the Warlock and he could turn one of them to our side. And I'm sorry for doubting you. Was the drunken post real or were you playing it up to hide your role?

It was real...haha, I got trashed and felt chatty and helpful and realized I couldn't type very well. I'll get Ice next.

 

[Swayde]

DC - I don't think it's a good idea to mention who you are protecting, or even discuss it. That information is not necessary for us, but would be quite helpful to the witches.

DD - I am not so sure about Ogre right now. There was one post he'd made earlier that seemed to scream witch at me, but now I am not so sure.

I do believe KoTD and Jpappy are witches...the case on Z is bad, my feeling on Ogre is still not good, but not all bad either....no real opinion on anyone else (aside from DC who I will still give benefit of doubt to about the Herbalist thing and Ice for being the Warlock)


I vote to burn KoTD at the stake.

 

[jpappy789]

Well I have been completely off this game, I will admit that, and if that warrants a vote so be it but all I can say is that the witches are really leading the town in the wrong direction. I confused witches for PR's. A lot of people admit to that so I guess I will say that as that's really the only defense I have...

With the people who are unknown I think plant, ogre, kotd, and Zs are withces. I would possibly throw Chas in there in place of some one else. Vote for me if you want but I think this list is accurate and will be proven quite true when I am gone.

I am not giving up yet but I would like to just let you all know my thoughts and I can see a train forming on me soon...

 

[KingOfTheDeep]

DC - I don't think it's a good idea to mention who you are protecting, or even discuss it. That information is not necessary for us, but would be quite helpful to the witches.

DD - I am not so sure about Ogre right now. There was one post he'd made earlier that seemed to scream witch at me, but now I am not so sure.

I do believe KoTD and Jpappy are witches...the case on Z is bad, my feeling on Ogre is still not good, but not all bad either....no real opinion on anyone else (aside from DC who I will still give benefit of doubt to about the Herbalist thing and Ice for being the Warlock)


I vote to burn KoTD at the stake.

so why the vote on me, with no explanation except "i think kotd and jpappy are witches"

why?

you and pappy are looking awfully suspicious lately...

 

[plantling]

lmao

i get him and brk confused all the time

i vote to burn brk

This would be plausible if bkw and brk were both in the game, but they aren't.

That's certainly a flashback to Mee-Mee pickin on someone not even in the game....

I got the same feeling, Swayde.

so why the vote on me, with no explanation except "i think kotd and jpappy are witches"

why?

you and pappy are looking awfully suspicious lately...

Why is Swayde looking so suspicious lately? She's been actively in the game all game long and IMO done nothing witchy. More than I can say for you. You never did address people's comments and concerns about you. And for you to suddenly be casting suspicion on her, I think you have an agenda. Once again my vote will be on you.

I vote to burn KoTD at the Stake.

DD, I don't know what to think about Ogre. I want to believe him, but Ogre came right out and professed KoTD's innocence as if it were solid gold, and KoTD came in and voted BrK at the very last w/Ogre being in the lead, I believe.

Ice, use the spell on who you think is most witchy. I know we've had our differences but perhaps I sensed the Wharlock.

DC, do your thing. Just don't let on what you're doing.

 

[IceH2O]

Jm that whole "you guys" and stuff did make you look highly suspicious to me last game. I am also very wary of your excuses. You had tons of excuses last game for why you weren't posting, even though you actually were quite active. I see your excuses beginning again. I do believe they are real excuses, however, I think they are unnecessary to give us a laundry list of every activity and to cover your butt so much. Makes you look like your trying to hide something and appear to be a townie, when your really not.

I retract my vote on KOTD. I vote to burn DC at the stake. I have to agree with Lady G that the fact BrkD may have slipped up is notable. I am concerned that DC has not posted much and his only effort at a post since his name was mentioned was an excuse with some typos to say he was drunk. I think he's a much more likely candidate at this time for a witch than KoTD who I still think has a destiny with evil due to all the 13's

Aye DD and Lady G both have bats in their avatars, so why just pick JM? I know you didn't Z, I am just agreeing with your post. The question is for Lady G since she's the one who singled out JM for the bat.

I don't happen to think the spell thingys are clues though. RB usually only gives game related clues during Nightfall.

I am actually considering going back to my random vote because I don't see anything from anyone worth burning them for. Nothing has popped out at me as overly suspicious. I don't have any strong hunches on anyone or even any small evil feelings about anyone. I think my witch-o-meter is busted =/

I wish we knew how many witches there were. I like being able to say okay, there are 5 bad guys and 10 good guys and then I can categorize people accordingly...the top 10 people I think are innocent or a few bad guys and the shady, in-between folks and then pick out the person I think is most lkely evil. This not knowing how many there are kinda throws a wrench into that strategy though and so I have to assume everyone is a witch, but I know a few are definitely good power roles and then it really gets hard....argggh...can't think =/

I still do not have a strong opinion on anyone. I am very tempted to burn myself because I don't feel I am being any help to the town at all this round. It could be my new allergy medicine making my brain so fuzzy, or it could be just that nobody has managed to set off any bells yet for me.

I was very surprised to see Lady G killed off. I think this means 1 of 2 things...

1) The witches assumed the herbalist would be protecting one of the usual suspects who gets killed off fast.

2) The usual suspects who get killed off fast are all witches so they took out someone they felt would be a threat.

I guess there is a 3rd reason as well. Maybe they want us to give more thought to her lists and theories. I personally don't think the spell things are really clues, but they may want us to believe they are because they don't hint at any of them and Lady G seemed to be pushing them very hard.

I'm thinking Ogre, Z, CS, Ice and DD are going to be the people I will be watching most closely today, however, I don't trust anyone and on a scale of 1-10 (10 being innocent) I'd have these five as 3's with everyone else at 4's =/

I vote to burn DC at the stake. I expected to have heard back from him by now after his last post last night. He's the strongest suspect I have, which I admit isn't as strong as I'd normally like to vote on someone.

This does not make a lot of sense. BrkD was still leading votes and now you just tied DC up with him...how would your vote have been wasted when your voting on the person leading in votes, especially if you do believe him/her to be a witch? Ogre, this worries me, I am very close to switching off DC and voting you because of this.

Actually I will switch my vote. I don't like that post at all Ogre.

I retract my vote from DC and vote to burn Ogre at the stake.

I wasn't sure I wanted to accept Sways innocence based on an investigation so I pulled her important posts. Thankfully I only had to go through 56 of them. I was really surprised at that number. I thought she had been on way more then that.

I don't really have time now to break then down but maybe others can then I'll be able to tonight. One thing I noticed is she is, as Ogre would say, very non committal. One quote that really threw me was the I'm of no help, feel like I'm of no help to the town. I claimed this as a bad guy when I kept lynching innocents. But I can see it being used this game by an innocent. None of our top suspects lists didn't have innocents in it.

Well I have been completely off this game, I will admit that, and if that warrants a vote so be it but all I can say is that the witches are really leading the town in the wrong direction. I confused witches for PR's. A lot of people admit to that so I guess I will say that as that's really the only defense I have...

With the people who are unknown I think plant, ogre, kotd, and Zs are withces. I would possibly throw Chas in there in place of some one else. Vote for me if you want but I think this list is accurate and will be proven quite true when I am gone.

I am not giving up yet but I would like to just let you all know my thoughts and I can see a train forming on me soon...

I actually think the witches are sitting back and letting us rip each other down. I would consider your list but I'm not real sure about you yet. I have to admit all those names have been people I suspect.

 

[charlie_stubbs]

so why the vote on me, with no explanation except "i think kotd and jpappy are witches"

why?

you and pappy are looking awfully suspicious lately...

King you havent answered what you meant by you confuse Brk with Bkw all the time??? I think you meant in your chat room.