Mafia #14 -- The Play

[clown-lover]

DJ-- Mafia, or really the village idiot, both hold the same page to me. The village idiot will cause trouble for the town by drawing our attention away from the mafia.

Sorry saw this and had to add before I left.. So do you think he is the villiage idiot or mafia.. Because if you believe he is the villiage idiot then you are voting off a townie and giving the mafia more of an advantage against us townies.. Please explain why your phrased this the way you did..

Thanks.

 

[IceH2O]

When someone "hints" they are a power role, then I think they should be called on it. There is no reason to hint it, we can all see the hint. If anything the mafia is at an advantage, because they can discuss the hint outside the thread.

It is not a good practice for any of the power roles to hint what they are. I am fairly sure the people that have the power roles know this and are not hinting anything.

When someone says they "know" something, I think they should back it up. I was not asking the real Detective or Doctor to come out, I was just stating that judgemax could only "know" if she was the Detective, Doctor, or on the same mafia team. I even asked her to maybe change her wording to: "or could you just have a feeling that DJmajor is not the Detectice, but he could be."

I also find it odd that Ogre got a bunch of heat about this, but I did not get any. I brought it on myself.

I don't agree with your thoughts JL. I have hinted pretty much everytime as a PR and not be caught. As the Hunter I even put an archery range in my backyard and had some silver my grandfather left me brought to the blacksmith. No one called me on it, the werewolves didn't catch it either because I wasn't hit.

I think its fine to hint. I think you are taking a big chance though. Its up to the town to decide if you're telling the truth or lying. Its a risk that the PR has to be willing to take.

Its also a mafia tactic used to draw out the PR.

The PRs need to stay quiet, it does the town no good for you to be hit.The Dr knows who the Detective is so they will be protecting them from a hit. If you're about to be lynched then its ok to come out, but thats the only time. The DR can't come out and verify it either so you'll be on your own. They can still protect you from a hit though.

I myself wouldn't want to put the DR in that position unless it was close to the games end and I had a list of people I had investigated that I haven't been able to get the town to lynch.

 

[Swayde]

When someone "hints" they are a power role, then I think they should be called on it. There is no reason to hint it, we can all see the hint. If anything the mafia is at an advantage, because they can discuss the hint outside the thread.

It is not a good practice for any of the power roles to hint what they are. I am fairly sure the people that have the power roles know this and are not hinting anything.

When someone says they "know" something, I think they should back it up. I was not asking the real Detective or Doctor to come out, I was just stating that judgemax could only "know" if she was the Detective, Doctor, or on the same mafia team. I even asked her to maybe change her wording to: "or could you just have a feeling that DJmajor is not the Detectice, but he could be."

I also find it odd that Ogre got a bunch of heat about this, but I did not get any. I brought it on myself.[/quote]

DD is the only person who really brought this up and she doesn't seem to be putting much heat on Ogre over it to me.

 

[IceH2O]

sure, Ice... this one down below.


the bolded area ia where I took it from. Now, the sentence after that goes on about the Don, which I think might take away from the sentence I am having trouble with. I don't know.... maybe it's nothing but I thought it was worth noting is all.

Ok I still don't see it. I took it as him questioning JM , not asking her to come out if she was and not asking anyone else to come out.

I believe you thought you had something. But it didn't pan out.

 

[IceH2O]

DD is the only person who really brought this up and she doesn't seem to be putting much heat on Ogre over it to me.

Thats because she got nipped before her team could back her up. Do you actually see what she sees Sway? Is Ogre trying to pull the DET out?

 

[Swayde]

Nightfall is in less than an hour right? This has got to be the slowest <1 till Nightfall ever.

 

[Swayde]

Thats because she got nipped before her team could back her up. Do you actually see what she sees Sway? Is Ogre trying to pull the DET out?

I do not see it. And I don't see the heat on Ogre over it that JL was referring to either, which is what I was trying to comment on, but the quote got a bit screwed up.

 

[IceH2O]

I see what you mean now, thanks for clearing it up.

JL, if anything the post by Ogre has brought heat onto DD, not him and maybe onto you also.

If DD hadn't mentioned his post it probably would have just been buried under the other posts.

Since she did comment on it but not yours it looks like you 2 could be teammates. Not only did she make me look her way but she drug you with her.

Not saying you guys are vote worthy but definitely will be under the microscope.

 

[FireDancer7905]

Old school
Orge
CL
Jensons
Swayde/Ice

New school
DD
Blue
DC/JL
DJ

Orge-Nothing big stands out to me...but I was saying how I could see Rb making the teams..and he seems to me a good choice for Old School.

CL-I find his post very Mafia"ish" as I am bringing out.

Jensons-Very quiet, doesn't add anything to the game really. I believe her to be a quiet mafia trying to stay low.

Swayde-Is really not playing like herself, not making many cases and also staying low.

Ice-Really I go back and forth on him. His change in style has bothered me some..but I understand why he has changed his style and what he post seems helpful, but he knows how to "seem" helpful. I really just added him as a MAYBE.

DD-Very low key, Very quiet..only comes out to try and throw accusations on small things trying to make them look like big deals.

Blue-Really isn't contributing anything either, has the same list and just makes references to it when asked about her feelings on ppl. When she post to "accuse" someone elses post instead of actually adding the entire quote will copy/paste just parts to try and make her point, so the meaning will look different then what it really was in the original post, and unless someone wants to go threw 100 post to find the original they wont know what it was.

DC-Yes he is always a low poster, but usually comes out at some point. This game he seems to remain low and not add much as far as his own thoughts.

JL-Really not much to stand out, but COULD replace DC.

DJ-obvious reasons

LadyG- I believe that I made some pretty good posts last night. You may be choosing to see them as fluff, but I posted with reasons, etc. Are you tryning to "twist words," as you accuse those of us who feel you are mafia as doing?

I also think that djmajor is in trouble. I was concerned, to point, until he said:

MY VOTE FOR LADY G.
newbia mistake

and then I became VERY concerned. The word "newbia" (I bolded it in his post) reeks of a word thrown around an outside forum by mafia-vets who are razzing a newbie.

I am sticking with my previous vote for LadyG, and am praying that we are lynching a mafia with djmajor.

~brandy

 

[IceH2O]

Sorry guys I won't be here for night fall. A friend needs some help and I owe him, not that a game would prevent me from helping a friend. I'll be back later.