Mafia #14 -- The Play

[Lady G]

HMMMM, DD is gone now? Think she's off in chat trying to figure out what to do?

 

[clown-lover]

YEAH, right I'm going to tell you that one! HA:thumbsup:

I got my Pm...the one I chose for tonight was innocent, I'm sorry no matter how much it is asked of me, I can not tell you this name as it would put a fellow townie in danger

I respect that very much and wouldn't want you to give out one of our names.. Again LadyG I still have my questions. I'm gonna have to research DD a LOT.. I also need to see if there are any hints from your own posts that make me believe you are the detective. I'm gonna give you a break..

Again if you are the detective please accept my apologies for using my strong arm tactics on you.. But again realize that if DD doesn't come back like you said you might as well UD because I will be back on you as well as everyone else.

I have to go study for my Level III test. I wish I had time to continue more this evening but I don't.

 

[Blueiz]

why would you ask, if they come out, we would be screwed.

I am not fully convinced LG is the detective. I asked to see what her response would be. I know that if the doctor came out we would be screwed, that is obvious. I see a lot of off the wall questions such as the one I just asked, asked to see what the response will be.

 

[Swayde]

only the mafia would ask who was saved last night....

Why would the mafia need to ask who was saved? Wouldn't they know who's name they submitted for a hit? I would think the mafia would be more interested in who was investigated....isn't that right Blueiz?

 

[Lady G]

Well, since the person I investigated is innocent...I can tell you it wasn't Jensons, Blue or CL...so they are all still suspicious to me. I do know we will get a Mafia Don tomorrow night! With that I can sleep better! I chose the hardest for me to read first so I could quit trying to guess on them.

 

[clown-lover]

CL, in a matter of minutes you've gone from casting a vote to lynch LG to now saying that your willing to give her a chance. It's kind of strange that you'd back off so quickly seeing that you came out pretty strongly against LG right at daybreak.

Read my post from the night before where I said I was going to vote for her the next day.. With her claiming to be the Det right before nightfall I had my suspicions.. I still do but she is coming up with the right answers so far.. Thats why.. And like I said my brain hurts. This is a lot to get my head around right now...

I'm not gonna say I'm "confused" but if you have read anything else of what has transpired can you honestly say you don't have questions?? Please.

 

[Lady G]

I respect that very much and wouldn't want you to give out one of our names.. Again LadyG I still have my questions. I'm gonna have to research DD a LOT.. I also need to see if there are any hints from your own posts that make me believe you are the detective. I'm gonna give you a break..

Again if you are the detective please accept my apologies for using my strong arm tactics on you.. But again realize that if DD doesn't come back like you said you might as well UD because I will be back on you as well as everyone else.

I have to go study for my Level III test. I wish I had time to continue more this evening but I don't.

I will CL!! If she comes back anything different, I will take one for the team! Then look up Rb and kick his arse!!!

 

[OgreMkV]

Can I just say, "What the frack is going on?" My thoughts

Vote change....I unvote Blue and vote to lynch DD....the Old School Don!
I do not expect every one to switch their vote this can wait until tomorrow....but I'm not sure there will be a tomorrow for me, and if the mafia is going to "hit" me to0night I **** sure want a known mafia out there.

Sorry I had to leave and thought I'd be back sooner, sorry for the confusion, I was trying to just build a case against her but don't know that I will have time.

I am pretty sure Dj is mafia but I can ASSURE you DD is and the DON!!!!

CL- is that a big enough case for ya!:raspberry:

Whyand why should we believe you?

LadyG, are you the detective? That would be the only reason that you could ASSURE us....... now I'm worried.

Me too...

Jensons I wouldn't say something like THAT if I couldn't back it:thm:

Crazy.

Very interesting.

Not the phrase I would use. Maybe, 'Oh ****!"

:nilly:

My head hurts! :duh:

You ain't the only one.

Jpappy: And now it looks liek I'm trying to out the Det, if it is LadyG. Great.Hope this doesn;t push mpre eople on me, it was just a reaction to her posts. I do think that the Det would be a bit more discreet than the current candidates are currently. I really, really don't want it to be LadyG. I do think that fj is mafia, though. Especially after that post.

I would hope so too...

G, be serious.... you haven't even hinted that you were on me the entire day, all of a sudden, I am the don? Clever, how you are now claiming the detective after today's conversation....

So there!

I know she is not the detective folks.

Because?

BAH! To h*ll with it. I don't think she is, and I don't think you are either (though you know I love you girl!). I'm waiting for nightfall now.

I'm leaning this way myself at this point.

I will not be saying who gets investigated or NAMING innocents, this will put others at risk. As the Doc will need to protect me we have talked and figured this is best. When a mafia is found it will be known in the mean time will play as normal

I'm not sure that makes sense. If you are the detective, then you're dead real soon. We could use a core of players to build around. With even two innocents known, we get better odds of lynching mafia.

Yes we will all find out tomorrow when you are lynched and it says...old school mafia

Tell me why we're trusting you at this point.

I don't either.. Remember RB used to post that he has seen mafia successfully say they are the detective for a time... This has to be a ruse on her part.

If DD is the DON I'll eat my mousepad..

I wouldn't say anything like that until this is all cleared the heck up.

well, i guess that mens , I vote to lynch DD


I can't believe DJ was innocent? WTF?..

I can understand that too.

please tell me, how someone with such a rational mind, can say that you don't believe she is the detective now?..I don't get it?..

I want to know why you trust her explicitly. I'm not saying her claim isn't possible, but it doesn't sound real good to me at this time.

No Detective in their right mind is going to come out this early.. Unless they are just stupid..

Totally agree.

Ok so your the detective.. If you are.. I want to believe you.. I REALLY DO.. Why didn't you try to get the town to go for her.. You could have alluded to her more.. Voted for her instead of Blue.. Why?? This time evading the question is not going to work.. You need to answer this for me to believe you.

No kidding

only the mafia would ask who was saved last night....

Disagree. One group of mafia already knows, the other probably doesn't care. I think it's safe to say who was protected though. This is about the only thing that has me believing in LadyG at this point.

Because anyone can SAY they are the detective.. If she was why didn't she spend the last two IRL days trying to convince us instead of voting for Blue.. Lets be rational here and not jump on her bus..

I can agree... to a point, but you're being VERY against it. The doctor save is pretty convincing.

Going from reading in a previous post that the doctor knows who the detective is, if I believe what you are saying now, does this make you the doctor?

huh?

I haven't got word on tonights investigation....only had one other as of now and that was DD, she came back Don, I picked her first because she is one of the hardest for me to read.

NO, she is NOT the DOC!

This sounds weird. When I was ref, I'd send out the results before I posted the good morning post. I don't know how rb does it, and we know he posts the night posts SLOWLY! So maybe.

I can't wrap my head around this....Lady G. If you are the Detective, please explain why you decided to come out so close to Nightfall when you were no where near in danger of being lynched. The Doctor clearly would know you were the Detective and if you both felt you were in that much danger, why not just have the Doctor protect you, wait to see how this day was going to play out a bit and then make a decision from there.

Logically, it does not make any sense to me why you would come out when you did.

Agreed.

We need a live detective more than we need one mafia dead. We need ALL the mafia dead. As a group, we do have amazing powers to pick out mafia and maybe one lead is enough to go on, but...

Hell I don't know.

Concern List is still
JMax
DD
LadyG - detective?!
DJ - innocent sigh
blue? Does this mean that you really think blue is mafia or was she a convenient distraction?

That still bothers me too.

OK LadyG, my big question is "Why DD as your first night investigation?" I mean, I'm glad you picked out a mafia and all, but why her and why reveal now? OK, two questions.

I'm sure there's been lots of posts while I wrote this, so I'll catch up and go from there.

 

[Madcrawdad]

Read my post from the night before where I said I was going to vote for her the next day.. With her claiming to be the Det right before nightfall I had my suspicions.. I still do but she is coming up with the right answers so far.. Thats why.. And like I said my brain hurts. This is a lot to get my head around right now...

I'm not gonna say I'm "confused" but if you have read anything else of what has transpired can you honestly say you don't have questions?? Please.

Yes, I have questions, but I kind of want to see how it plays out. In your first posts today, though, you came out quite strongly trying to discredit LG. First you voted to lynch, then in a post that quickly followed you said that a person would have to be stupid to come out as detective....not exactly questioning. It looks like your mind was made up at that point to immediately discredit her.

I noticed that you said that 'your brain hurts' quite a bit lately....that is kind of the same as saying 'I'm so confused,' isn't it?

 

[OgreMkV]

Again to attempt to forestall the mad rush... in the interest of discussion and because a few of those posts were insanely mafia like I vote to lynch Blueiz.

I will probably switch later.

In the interest of full disclosure, this is driving me nuts. I read one post that says she's the det, and I think, "Yeah, I can see that." Then I read the next post that says something isn't right and I think, "Yeah, I can see that too."

So you investigated DD first and she's a Don.
You did not investigate blue, jensons, or clownlover, even though they are your top suspects?

You investigated people that are hard to read...

I can see that. I don't think I agree with it, but I can see the logic behind your plan. We have plenty of time, so let's work this out and decide, as a town, if we should follow LadyG.

To be honest, as I write this, I'm leaning more and more her way. I still think discussion is better than a lack of discussion, so I'll keep my vote where it is for now.