Mafia #14 -- The Play

[IceH2O]

I'm tending to side w/ LG also... I wouldn't worry about your scenario yet, Ice. If not detective, LG wouldn't know DD was Don, as the other mafia team shows innocent on investigation... LG and DD would have to be on the same team for that info to be known.

After outing DD, LG would not be able to provide any positive mafia IDs other than those on her own team. It's unlikely that she'd name her entire team.... As the mafia is all around us (likely 7-8 mafia v. 7-8 townies?) chances are that she'll find more.... If she hits a real dry spell in finding other scum, I'd say we could worry about your scenario.

OK your right, as I was typing out why it was possible still I remembered that all the mafia come back innocent. I was wrong earlier about the Don not showing innocent.

That seals the deal for me.

I was talking about LGs post. To many posts fell in between.

 

[IceH2O]

huh? Blue I can see... explain your reasoning for me please. If I can answer a question I will.

Gut jump I guess. It looked to that point that you were trying pretty hard to point out she was lying and not saying much about DDs claim.

I see you've mellowed out some and are willing to listen to her. I can understand the suspicion as I was also till I read her responses.

 

[Lady G]

I believe you... more and more.

Thing only thing that worries me would be you taking the name of the one person that we know we can trust when the mafia go after you.

Ok, really I have to go but wanted to answer this first....I don't know at this point I don't think I will reveal it, but at the same time if I went the Doc would protect me...although the only way this could happen is if the Doc came off protecting me, which I don't think they will.

 

[IceH2O]

I believe you... more and more.

Thing only thing that worries me would be you taking the name of the one person that we know we can trust when the mafia go after you.

See its little posts like these that bother me about you Ogre.

You come out attacking LG then mellow and get on her side then slip in something like this.

 

[OgreMkV]

Yeah, like I said, there were quiet a few posts when I originally posted that long set of quotes.

I agree that she's the detective now. My biggest problem with the whole thing was that she came out at all and who she investigated first, but she's answered that question and it's reasonable... not the way I would do it, but reasonable.

 

[OgreMkV]

Ok, really I have to go but wanted to answer this first....I don't know at this point I don't think I will reveal it, but at the same time if I went the Doc would protect me...although the only way this could happen is if the Doc came off protecting me, which I don't think they will.

I reread the Doc's rules and unlike previous games, he can protect you each night... so my objection is withdrawn.

 

[judgemax]

I had to sign back on, As I sat here thinking(while cutting out tiny tombstones ironically) I tried last game, to claim detective, I had names of investigations, I had those, because as mafia you get investigations, I am a little nervous here, I want to believe LG, so If my thinking is of base, please tell me.

Is it possible, that She is mafia, and that was the result of her investigation? That dd is the don of the other mafia? why would she suddenly change her from old school, why would it matter, what school she is in, and why would she push that?. Seems to me, maybe LG is the other don? There were alot of valid points brought up about blues late reaction to switching to dd?..

Again. I could be wrong, BUT, I couldn't figure out why she didn't get the results from her investigation?, could be because she was on the loosing end of the coin toss, and the dr believed that they couldn't communicate?..I don't know, I am having a hard time with this.


I still feel very much that BLUE is guilty, DD is also ringing guilty, because of her play style, in the last few games, she started almost angry , and settled, she was innocent, this time, shes back to old helpful DD?

I am Leary Of LADY G, although I always feel that way towards her.

this game has me stumped right now!

any opinions on this?..

 

[judgemax]

awe shoot can not edit, first paragraph should read switching off blue and on to dd....

 

[Swayde]

I had to sign back on, As I sat here thinking(while cutting out tiny tombstones ironically) I tried last game, to claim detective, I had names of investigations, I had those, because as mafia you get investigations, I am a little nervous here, I want to believe LG, so If my thinking is of base, please tell me.

Is it possible, that She is mafia, and that was the result of her investigation? That dd is the don of the other mafia? why would she suddenly change her from old school, why would it matter, what school she is in, and why would she push that?. Seems to me, maybe LG is the other don? There were alot of valid points brought up about blues late reaction to switching to dd?..

Again. I could be wrong, BUT, I couldn't figure out why she didn't get the results from her investigation?, could be because she was on the loosing end of the coin toss, and the dr believed that they couldn't communicate?..I don't know, I am having a hard time with this.


I still feel very much that BLUE is guilty, DD is also ringing guilty, because of her play style, in the last few games, she started almost angry , and settled, she was innocent, this time, shes back to old helpful DD?

I am Leary Of LADY G, although I always feel that way towards her.

this game has me stumped right now!

any opinions on this?..

If LG was mafia and she investigated the other team's Don, it would show up as Innocent.

 

[judgemax]

again, can't edit, I understand, that she says she got an innocent back, and doesn't want to reveal the name, that kinda seams convenient. again, if I am willing to except ,that I am. just nervous about this whole situation.