Mafia #14 -- The Play

[Lady G]

Ok, Ogre...I have to apologize to you now:footinmouth: I did read your post wrong...the one about DD has helped Lady G more then Lady could have. That was my mistake and I do apologize fully for that! The way it was worded made me read it different than your meaning.
I also have to apologize for the other post...it is in one that Ice posted and it was CL NOT you, now you can jump all over me for mis reading and say I was skimming, I really wasn't...but I do deserve any criticizim you may bring my way for it.:duh:

LadyG, let me explain this very carefully. Tell me what post you are referring to.

If it's the post where I said that DD has been very helpful in convincing me that you are the detective... that's what I meant.

To help you out. Here is every post that I found (without reading every post I ever made in GCC, where I mention DD. Tell me which post you are referring to.

Thank you for this post BTW!








I hope this helps. I'm missing something here.

Ok so I've done something thinking.. And again I want to believe LadyG but that nagging little thing is sitting back in my mind. I haven't had time to fully research it and am not willing to cast a vote until I am more committed to one side or another. But I did go back and read the rules. Here are two things that I think we are ALL forgetting about.



In the past games I have played when someone was saved by the doc Bob's description of the even always included something to the effect of the "Doctor rushed in and applied" something, "Or the Doctor injected " something etc.. Last night we saw that a strategicly placed mirror saved the person. (Bob never said innocent).. In fact he didn't even give us a hint as to who the person was..

Again I WANT to believe LadyG but the timing of her coming out, the number of games she has played at least leads me to believe that she should have a grasp of when it is good for the DET to come out, if at all.. She wasn't in danger last night from a lynch... Its all just tooooooo questionable for me right now. To top that off I had seen DD as being helpful to the town (somewhat) at least more than LadyG had been, or at least that is my recollection when going through posts during the LadyG, Blue and DD catfight.

I know I need to do more research but I have to work today and probably am not going to be back until late. I have a 16 cable install and need to get out of town as it stands.

Can someone else help me out here?



Bob simply due to my work schedule (see signup thread) I'm voting no against this.. And I really want to be able to research what I am not understanding right now. I would appreciate the time to do so.. Thanks.

This is the post that I was thinking was from you, and it must of been CL I asked and didn't get an answer from.

SO now I am asking you CL.....how/where was DD helpful!

 

[Madcrawdad]

I didn't say they were well thought out ideas, they were just thoughts that I had. My top mafia candidates are: Ogre, Mad, Ice, DD, Blue and Cooldude (reasons tba in a separate post soon). I have read every word posted. One of the things people were originally on me for was not posting enough and being a "quiet mafia." So, I post what I'm thinking at the time. Now, I'm being "more mafia." At this point, I wish I had the imaginative powr to roll play. Maybe then I wouldn't get myself into so much trouble.

Reasons given below:

DD: Ok, this one's obvious.

Ogre: Just a feeling. You have been named by DD (not a big reason there) and LG suspects you. I have suspected you from day 2.

Mad: awful quick to jump on me. I'm an easy innocent to take down.

Ice: Same reasons as Mad.

Blue: I thought you were on day 1. If you're not mafia you've gotta be a pr, cuz I just can't seem to get out of my head that you have someting you're nto saying.

Cooldude: Quiet, and your posts have changed quite a bit since people looked at you as mafia.

Regarding your ideas, if you had been reading the thread, you'd have seen that Blue already mentioned the idea that the DD was detective/doc trying to draw the mafia out. As she was stomped on, I'm surprised that you would bring it up again.

You guys (yourself and Blue) are playing such obvious mafia now, my guess is that you're trying to draw an investigation. Coming out so early, LG's days are numbered. Once the Doc is gone, so is LG. As you and Blue were already 'compromised' maybe if you act a little nutty you can draw the investigations and keep your teammates protected until you can hit the doc and LG.

The thing is, I'd be quite comfortable lynching you without any investigation for confirmation.

In order, my favorite candidates for mafia at this point are:

DD
Jensons
Blue
CL
DC

I've given reasons for the 1st 4 in previous posts. But the thing that still bothers me with DC was the post early on Day 2 where he said that he had intended to follow Hooked Newbie's lynch votes.... Two things about this:

1. I believe that he was saying, 'I was led!' on his Chas vote.
2. How the heck would he have known that HN could even be trusted so early in the game?

 

[FireDancer7905]

]and jensons, you have mad and ice as mafia for jumping on you...not the best reasons I would have to say...[/B]

ogre seems like an easy person to question and cooldude is quiet but so are you and I think is pretty jumpy but still not sure what he is

When I know that I'm innocent they are. That's how we often find mafia, isn't it?

 

[Rbishop]

thru post 1392...

all have voted...

13 on DD

1 on lady g

1 0n blueiz


3 1/2 hrs to go.....


PMs or e-mails as required...

 

[Lady G]

Regarding your ideas, if you had been reading the thread, you'd have seen that Blue already mentioned the idea that the DD was detective/doc trying to draw the mafia out. As she was stomped on, I'm surprised that you would bring it up again.

You guys (yourself and Blue) are playing such obvious mafia now, my guess is that you're trying to draw an investigation. Coming out so early, LG's days are numbered. Once the Doc is gone, so is LG. As you and Blue were already 'compromised' maybe if you act a little nutty you can draw the investigations and keep your teammates protected until you can hit the doc and LG.

The thing is, I'd be quite comfortable lynching you without any investigation for confirmation.

In order, my favorite candidates for mafia at this point are:

DD
Jensons
Blue
CL
DC

I've given reasons for the 1st 4 in previous posts. But the thing that still bothers me with DC was the post early on Day 2 where he said that he had intended to follow Hooked Newbie's lynch votes.... Two things about this:

1. I believe that he was saying, 'I was led!' on his Chas vote.
2. How the heck would he have known that HN could even be trusted so early in the game?

Just one thing buggin me about this post here mad...are you saying the Doc is already known my mafia??
Hopefully by the time this happens there will be enough Mafia known it wont matter so much. We have 1 KNOWN mafia, and 3 most likely mafias right now..hopefully will have another KNOWN by tonight.

 

[FireDancer7905]

Regarding your ideas, if you had been reading the thread, you'd have seen that Blue already mentioned the idea that the DD was detective/doc trying to draw the mafia out. As she was stomped on, I'm surprised that you would bring it up again.

You guys (yourself and Blue) are playing such obvious mafia now, my guess is that you're trying to draw an investigation. Coming out so early, LG's days are numbered. Once the Doc is gone, so is LG. As you and Blue were already 'compromised' maybe if you act a little nutty you can draw the investigations and keep your teammates protected until you can hit the doc and LG.

The thing is, I'd be quite comfortable lynching you without any investigation for confirmation.

In order, my favorite candidates for mafia at this point are:

DD
Jensons
Blue
CL
DC

I've given reasons for the 1st 4 in previous posts. But the thing that still bothers me with DC was the post early on Day 2 where he said that he had intended to follow Hooked Newbie's lynch votes.... Two things about this:

1. I believe that he was saying, 'I was led!' on his Chas vote.
2. How the heck would he have known that HN could even be trusted so early in the game?

Go for it. Not mafia.

 

[Lady G]

Not trying to deflect. I think she is most leikely mafai, but I am thrying to think out all possible options. Who can I slip money to to stop the accusations against me?

Hey...isn't it the mafia that takes and gives bribes??:lol2:

 

[OgreMkV]

I'm going to a meeting then to the LFS. I'll be back after the night.

 

[Madcrawdad]

Just one thing buggin me about this post here mad...are you saying the Doc is already known my mafia??
Hopefully by the time this happens there will be enough Mafia known it wont matter so much. We have 1 KNOWN mafia, and 3 most likely mafias right now..hopefully will have another KNOWN by tonight.

The doc may or may not be known. You can bet that they're looking hard, though. Once the doc is found, your tenure as detective will be short...if they can tie up your investigations, getting you to confirm what we probably already know, they can help keep some of their teammates under cover.

 

[Lady G]

The doc may or may not be known. You can bet that they're looking hard, though. Once the doc is found, your tenure as detective will be short...if they can tie up your investigations, getting you to confirm what we probably already know, they can help keep some of their teammates under cover.

Yes, I'm sure they are..but they only get one investigation per night also and a chance at that, alot of ppl to look through before finding them.
I don't know why but your posting makes me feel you want them to find the Doc. Maybe I'm seeing things that aren't there but that was just the feeling I got from that post.