your newbie-ness has provided a nice cover for you. you come out and post when people mention you. you havent really done anything to prove otherwise, either
Mafia #14 -- The Play
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
your newbie-ness has provided a nice cover for you. you come out and post when people mention you. you havent really done anything to prove otherwise, either
Well it sure has been a busy day. I am very surprised to see that Lady G was the Doc and not the Detective. Sad to see that she was killed though =/ Hopefully neither mafia team knows the identity of the Detective yet, but as others have mentioned, it's likely that at least one of the teams does know because of the Doc's save on Night 2. I am very disappointed in Lady G for cheating though with such an obvious clue in an after death post. I'm going to refrain from voting at this time because, as others have also said, it just doesn't seem right to vote for Blueiz even though she is mafia, because of the way the information was revealed.
Here jl...this was from the werewolf game.
I wish Lg would not have given us that info. I think most people had her as mafia anyways...she would have been lynched soon.
I retract my vote
I don't wanna vote blue tonight. I know I changed my mind about this but I was thinking about how much people yelled at Cl in the werewolf game and it's not right to vote Blue tonight...
Tomorrow night it might be different. Thats who I was planning on voting for tomorrow anyways but I think my vote today might fall on Jensons...not sure...
I don't wanna vote blue tonight. I know I changed my mind about this but I was thinking about how much people yelled at Cl in the werewolf game and it's not right to vote Blue tonight...
Tomorrow night it might be different. Thats who I was planning on voting for tomorrow anyways but I think my vote today might fall on Jensons...not sure...
maybe some mafia don't want to vote a team mate out...
Jl
mad
jpap
we can't help wat lady g did but we now have a definate mafia, and now that we kno bluez is( no matter how we found out) we can't let her go just because of the way it was found out. I vote to lynch blue
Jl
mad
jpap
we can't help wat lady g did but we now have a definate mafia, and now that we kno bluez is( no matter how we found out) we can't let her go just because of the way it was found out. I vote to lynch blue
so between adefinate mafia and a maybe you'd choose the maybe because of how the mafia was found out.
OgreMkV
Father of Earth's Next Emperor
No one has remembered what DD's final posts were? She said that she knew LadyG was not the detective. So the old mafia may very well know the identity of the detective. It's also possible that they just investigated LadyG and knew she was the doc too.
I guess I just don't want to skip over anything at this point.
I guess I just don't want to skip over anything at this point.
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
cooldude, well that is not cool.
While I have already thought that Blue is mafia and the Don for that fact. Also I most likely was going to vote for her.
This is not how the game is to be played or won.
vote change
I vote to lynch uncooldude123
I also respect madcrawdad and jpappy as players of the game, weather they are mafia or not this game, btw I have both as very innocent and you as leaning mafia.
While I am postive Blue is new mafia. I also think that she is not the only mafia left (new or old). While I do not know what to do about Lady G's after death post. I do know that it is not playing fair.
OgreMkV
Father of Earth's Next Emperor
I don't know how helpful it will be, but here are the last few comments about LadyG. After this, DD pretty much called everyone in the game a mafia.
So the old mafia either know who the detective is or just knew that LadyG was the doc.
This seems like someone trying to eliminate some choices so her team can find the detective. So I'm thinking that they found out LadyG and not the detective. This might have been a good play if DD hadn't already admitted to being mafia.
We know this is not true.
So, it seems to me that the detective may be safe for another night. So, I'm going to give Jensons the benefit of the doubt and go after what must be mafia (all though improperly gained information). With that in mind, I retract my vote on Jensons and vote to lynch blue.
The intention is that the detective will investigate Jensons in order to verify her identity tonight. However, we might not know for a while, because the detective, without protection shouldn't come out.
I guess we'll just have to look very carefully for clues in players' posts about if we are lynching the right person or not. I wish LadyG had told us who was investigated innocent.
So the old mafia either know who the detective is or just knew that LadyG was the doc.
This seems like someone trying to eliminate some choices so her team can find the detective. So I'm thinking that they found out LadyG and not the detective. This might have been a good play if DD hadn't already admitted to being mafia.
We know this is not true.
So, it seems to me that the detective may be safe for another night. So, I'm going to give Jensons the benefit of the doubt and go after what must be mafia (all though improperly gained information). With that in mind, I retract my vote on Jensons and vote to lynch blue.
The intention is that the detective will investigate Jensons in order to verify her identity tonight. However, we might not know for a while, because the detective, without protection shouldn't come out.
I guess we'll just have to look very carefully for clues in players' posts about if we are lynching the right person or not. I wish LadyG had told us who was investigated innocent.
