Mafia #15....The Play....

[plantling]

yes. if you edit very soon after the original post it will not show as an edited post. I'll admit to having done this and then stated the edit to allay suspicion. however a player in a previous game (plantling I think) correctly pointed out that this was in fact in breach of the rules.

Nope, that wasn't me. But if you're talking about Game 4 perhaps it was Neon Julie about JMax's pm post.

*sigh* i give that about one and a half cents.

you really were not singled out...I gave my impressions of your posting is all.

the distancing stuff/possible teams is bs ? sorry but objectively it is not - its there on the thread and is certainly 'possible', as I said. It's a helpful thought as far as I'm concerned.

paranoia ('singled out') however is for me a mafia thing. Especially when I said only that you might be amongst my best mafia suspects at that early stage. Its not like I voted for you.

For now, you have become my best mafia suspect and as it is now about time for me to vote that's what I'm going to do I vote to lynch plantling.

may change *shrug* its just my best guess for now.

The point is that you singled me out as "hiding in the background" and that my posting had contributed nothing. At the time half the players had less posts than I did. Why didn't it strike you that they were hiding?

And because I called you out on it meant I was paranoid and therefore your strongest Mafia suspect? How about I was sticking up for myself? And I find it odd that at the time of this post you didn't find Ogre or Brains more suspect as did everyone else. Your final vote did go on Ogre, but only after it was wayyy late and you said it was partly due to Charlie's case on Ogre. But wait, Charlie's post was before your vote on me. Perhaps you were skimming?

And as I think about it further, the identifying of possible teams was absolutely no way identifying of mafia - I think I even said that.

I'm pretty happy with my vote - I think you're defence was weak and disproportionate to what I said about you. For me that's often a tell.

I didn't say you were identifying Mafia. Rather that you were trying to link an innocent with a mafium. Ogre, Ice, Chaz was one of your proposed teams. I have both Ice and Chaz leaning innocent but Ogre is a known Mafia.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Im not so sure about this HN, when i was mafia i was sure to plant roots to an innocent in the event i was discovered. Although ZS has basically had a bye on day 1, so he better start working his *** off, or i may be more inclined to agree with you
i vote to lynch brains2

There's a big difference this game though. 1/2 the mafia don't know what the other half are doing and are basically as blind as us townies. I think Ogre put the hint out there. Like you said, Z basically had a bye this weekend and hasn't yet contributed. There are a few playing oddly and/or laying low. I chose one. Brains is mafia to me and if needed, I'll switch my vote. We have 8 left to flush though.

 

[Coler]

I didn't say you were identifying Mafia. Rather that you were trying to link an innocent with a mafium. Ogre, Ice, Chaz was one of your proposed teams. I have both Ice and Chaz leaning innocent but Ogre is a known Mafia.

Ogre is now a known mafia but he wasn't then.

 

[Lady G]

I'd like to pint out Weezer edited his post. He is in fact in the game. He had, and I wish I quoted him, quotes pulled on Brains 2 voters and pointed out he thinks they are a team but not sure which team they might be on.

Nice try Weezer, don't worry JM did the same thing as Brains 1 in the Zombie game. I caught hers also.

Was this a post from Weezer? You saw it posted then he posted "Nice game, but I'm not in it" instead is that what you are saying?
I believe you there was an edit, no doubt about that..I can't imagine you would make that up, but I am trying to figure this whole mess out

You've got to love being able to go backwards.


Deny it now Weezer.



Unread Today, 12:01 PM #63
Weezer
Plastic Plant's Live Longer

Weezer's Avatar

Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: "Minnesota - It Gets Chilly Here"
Posts: 3,221

Personal Blog

Private Message

Quote:
Originally Posted by johnlarson66 View Post
I vote to lynch brains2

Now the game is going!
Quote:
Originally Posted by joander123 View Post
hmmm nevermind i'm caught up... wasnt all that much reading really....





ogre.... they could have simply just given out the password... right?

I too dont really like the idea of playing with someone i dont know. Seems fishy, and until i get further info....

I vote to lynch brains2.

This appears to be a team effort, but which team ? there are other players we've heard from that caught my attention. it's way to early to draw conclusions.. I'll be popping in and out today. cleaning the 125...


That post.

Ice, could you please show me what I am suppose to be seeing here? You said the post that was edited had quotes around those who voted Brains, then you post this? What am I missing?

 

[IceH2O]

Was this a post from Weezer? You saw it posted then he posted "Nice game, but I'm not in it" instead is that what you are saying?
I believe you there was an edit, no doubt about that..I can't imagine you would make that up, but I am trying to figure this whole mess out



Ice, could you please show me what I am suppose to be seeing here? You said the post that was edited had quotes around those who voted Brains, then you post this? What am I missing?

If you go through the thread you'll see where I reposted the post and did color changes to it so its easier to read.

Maybe you skimmed by that post thinking it was a repost of unneeded information.

 

[IceH2O]

Lady then look at the 2 posts that weezer made.

If it wasn't edited then why the 2nd post and why chastise me for trying to trick the town?

What business is it of his if he isn't playing? He was trying to post as Brains but again forgot to switch SNs.

 

[charlie_stubbs]

There's a big difference this game though. 1/2 the mafia don't know what the other half are doing and are basically as blind as us townies. I think Ogre put the hint out there. Like you said, Z basically had a bye this weekend and hasn't yet contributed. There are a few playing oddly and/or laying low. I chose one. Brains is mafia to me and if needed, I'll switch my vote. We have 8 left to flush though.

Agreed. To that end, my list:
Brains2- here is the most likely suspect to be a scumbag to me.
CC- early Ice vote is fishy, also is one of three players voting for Ice. The others??? Ogre (confirmed mafium) and Brains2 (soon to be confirmed mafium)

 

[ZSandmann]

Yay Town!!! My wife stole the computer to look at blinds, bleh, and now Amazing Race is on. HN I have been at an engagement party/ camp out all weekend.

 

[Lady G]

If you go through the thread you'll see where I reposted the post and did color changes to it so its easier to read.

Maybe you skimmed by that post thinking it was a repost of unneeded information.

I did see that one, I'll go back again and try to see what you meant.

Lady then look at the 2 posts that weezer made.

If it wasn't edited then why the 2nd post and why chastise me for trying to trick the town?

What business is it of his if he isn't playing? He was trying to post as Brains but again forgot to switch SNs.

I agree with you, I am just trying to figure out the facts. I'm not sure about a few that jumped on with you...but you at this point I think are right.
I did see the two post and still don't understand why they were left, I know last game I saw a post by someone "13" the next time I looked it was gone. Unless of coarse it has become an important event in this game and if they were gone now may confuse even more?
I also do not know why he would of posted in the first place if not Weezer, since well like it has been said "Weezer" is not in the game.

I'm just not sure yet on if I think it proves mafia? If Ogre was "seeming" to protect him/her whatever...could he not of been doing that to try and get us to believe brains2 to be mafia and vote an innocent? Then again, all the mafia do not know each other so Ogre wouldn't know if Brains2 was innocent or not. AHHHHHHHH this round is going to make me flippin nuts!

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Yay Town!!! My wife stole the computer to look at blinds, bleh, and now Amazing Race is on. HN I have been at an engagement party/ camp out all weekend.

Ok, have you read up? If so, who do you suspect at this point? We've missed the input / analysis. Ogre's frequent mention of you and the "built in" excuse for not posting has to be suspicious right?