Mafia #15....The Play....

[IceH2O]

Brains

Since I'm your top suspect may I ask.....

Wheres the vote?

 

[joander123]

Brains wont vote for you ice. He knows hes done for... and is simply trying to make last a last ditch effort to take you down with him. Or thats my thoughts at least....

 

[Dangerdoll]

hmmm.... list. I don;t have too much time right now to explain too much but will do my best and give better explanations in the morning.

Brains, of course due to the inconsistencies, the refusal to defend themself, the obvious untruths

G, for her attempt to drive a train on me, the more she said, the more it was apparent she was twisting things. If she was not twisting, she sure was ripping things to hold different meanings.

Cavie, bkw... not enough info from them and for that, it makes me nervous.

Everyone else, still suspicious but these are those that stick out at the moment. I will post more in the morning.

 

[johnlarson66]

Does it matter at this point WHO Brains is? I don't think so. They appear to be mafia and need to go. Wild theories can easily be thrown out. I searched the site and the only other posts that contain the word "towards" hyphonated as "to-wards" were made by djlen. Is Brans actually djlen? Who cares?! They are mafia.

:iagree:

I do not care who brains2 is.

I think this is a big distraction and will be glad to be past it.

I also think that the mafia have a fairly good shot at hitting one of there own in the closet players.

I think day 3 will be interesting. I will post a scaled list then.

 

[ZSandmann]

What do you mean no one is talking about anyone but Brains?

I've posted about JL and CCM twice, questioned Coler questioning LG

HN is questioned Z

Coler is question Plantling

Charlie is calling out CCM and Z and LG

Plantling is questioning Coler and CCM

KOTD is posting on Z

JM is mentioning LG DD JL

Z is on Plantling

Sorry I see a lot of looking at others besides Brains.

Good run down Ice, while brains is most obviously Mafia there are still 7 more to be found, by tracking who is after who we can begin to make connections. But it is tough as there are really four teams to deal with.

Sorry I havent had a chance to post much, been busy working. I have went through the posts today and what stands out to me the most is how inconsistent, confused, and going in all differnt directions singling ppl out Lady G is.. Lady G goes to one person right after the other out of the blue trying to build a case against them. The one I see she has not tried to build a case against is brains, only questioned the weezer-brains deal.. Brains was recieving the most attention and was in line and possibly still is to be lynched next nightfall. Lady G and Brains are really looking like mafia to me. I will hold my vote off for now as to who to lynch.

I wouldn't say she is all over the place but she is being extremely quote happy, I don't mind that when building a case, but on Day 2 in a game format like this quoting every one of someones posts is redundant and uneeded IMO. I can summarize without pulling all those posts.

vote change

I vote to lynch Brains2

I do not like mystery players or the concept behind them. While I do not think that are allowed to tell the truth on who they are, I think the game will be better without such a distraction.

As far as people thinking I am mafia because of my role playing, OMGUS!

The last time I really attempted to role play was the werewolf game, I was all into it, but then ZS and company hit me.

My role playing has no bearing on me being innocent nor mafia.

Mike was behind your lynching in that game but your RP is first class and I really enjoy it. Keep it up please. You and Charlie kill me.

Post 5, I'm already labeled, JL Seems alittle to eager to get the plot up and running..

Again ICE labeling me as weezer in the beginning..

DD remembered this, even tho she was corrected and found to be inaccurate.. wow.. never considering i could be a townie..

JL suddenly changes his vote, in a very uncharacteristic short post.. perhaps another pm from ICE

Just playing along with the boys, or team member ?
All these before ICE's plot..

Again following the leader..

Wow ICE i hope you still feel that way. Lets see if you've changed your Mafia mind..

While going through the post's i couldn't help but notice DD'S apparent interest in what ICE wants to do, and other interesting things , that were pointed out, I must keep reading..i don't know much about pc's. I'm a very busy mom of 2 boy's, and going to school p/t , so all this talk is new to me. i have answered all of ICE's questions the best i can.
JL is suspicious to me, for his early post, and the later sudden change. i appreciate the open mind some of you have, i hope to keep playing and help get another Maf..
I'm still going through the post's before i vote, I belive ICE is part of the Mafia - 4 ..

No one else caught this part? I got a chuckle out of it. This everyone is posting their theories I'll get mine out there. Look at the type, bolded blue. Who else types in bolded blue? RB. :lipssealedsmilie:

You must have missed my post from yesterday. I will be working long hours at work. And don't have much but 2-3 hours to read the game and post. Alot of posting has gone on so far, and the only person that really sticks out right now is CCM. Just like plantling's post 314. But I am going to state my reasons for him.

His post 23==he votes for Ice for no other reason that to put in a vote.
post 27==just to say a random vote to DD
post 124==talks about cs being confused and the random voting of cs. (that is how he plays when he is an innocent, getting reactions to his posts).And didn't CCM just do the same thing. Random vote on Ice.

But right now I really don't know who to vote for. CCM is my strongest lynching right now.

CCM has not even posted today and they are the only one that sticks out to you? Wha????

Great job at catching this Lady G.

We thought that since I was not on anyones mafia list, it would be good for me to vote brains2 out. This would be a great way to save myself and have brains2 die, since there are 4 of us, being down to 3 will not be a big deal. It would be best to save me while we can. Next we will distance ourselves from each other. Now if I can only help save the 2 other people on my mafia team of evil.

Keep up the great work!

As you said, sarcasm does not translate to text, I read this about 4 times before "getting" that you were joking. I was thinking, WOW.

Judge, I don't see why you would hold this from the town whether you would feel silly or not. A bad suggestion or idea is the one that's not stated.

In JM's defense since the "List That Shall Not Be Named" she never tells everything she thinks she knows. We always have to wring her like a dish rag to get thoughts from her. I do not think brains is MM. I think it is either Weezer or someone Rb asked to play and Weezer just chimed in at a bad time (or was MM), or it is Rb as I suggested above.

Whew!!! Caught up now. Hoorah!

 

[ZSandmann]

And everyone's asleep...

 

[charlie_stubbs]

there are certain players that are posting as little as they can get away with.

while posting little in the first few days is a strategy that might work for them, i don't intend to let them hide in the shadows.

my list:
Brains2- do i need to explain this???
Captain Caveman- did you forget you were playing??? hoping the heat will stop if you dont post???
LadyG- your recent posts have brought you back into focus. I think you're a scumbag, disconnected from the group, and desperate to take someone down with you. I thought my Ogre case, along with the fact he was mafium would have bought me a small amount of credibility, instead immediately after the lynch you cast a shadow on me and aledge I'm being mentored by DD. Hogwash. Your top suspect is DD, another reason not to trust you, as i have her leaning innocent.

 

[Lady G]

Ok, guys I just got home from work and am trying to get caught up on everything...can I say OMG, so much posting since I left...the way things were going when I went to work I knew it was going to be crazy!

 

[DeputyChiefJR]

Sorry to butt in, but dear lord I'm so sad I didn't get to play this one.

 

[captaincaveman9]

I can't vote to lynch Lady G, I do think Brains is mafia, but I cant find enough evidence to support my view yet. I need to re read all the posts, and I'll get back to you on why I think he's mafia

So, in case I can't log on tomorrow (spent the entire day traveling to California today), I vote to Lynch Brains