Mafia #15....The Play....

[joander123]

Hey guys, sorry today has been hectic. I'm not even caught up on the thread, and to be honest i cant get caught up right now because im exhausted. I'm going to throw my vote out there now, just incase tomorrow is as bad as today and i cant get a vote in.... so i vote to lynch coler.

I'm sorry, I'll try to catch up more tomorrow if i can.

Have a good night everyone.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Wow guys, I can't believe that some of you are believing this load from King. And HN to say I haven't put anything into this thread is painful to me as I have built cases for every person I have voted for, which have incidentally all been Mafia. I built a case on brains, on CCM, on Bkw and LG, and on King before he started posting like a mad man on speed. I still have Coler as a strong suspect but I haven't seen enough to vote for him yet and as I have documented King as been much more telling IMO and has shown signs of skimming and confusion. I can't stop anyone from voting for me, but I ask you to at least think about it some.

As far as JM goes, I think she is Innocent, if that makes me Mafia so be it. She has been playing like she always does and I just don't buy it. I think she invested HN and when she freaked out about people suspecting her she blurted out who it was.

C'mon, Brains and CCM and LG to a lessor degree were cheese. Where was your case against BK? I may have missed it. Mind posting the post number for me?

 

[IceH2O]

KOTD since you're so sure Z is mafia and HNs plan is to get a tie between multiple mafia suspects why not move your vote to Z?

 

[johnlarson66]

C'mon, Brains and CCM and LG to a lessor degree were cheese. Where was your case against BK? I may have missed it. Mind posting the post number for me?

I would like to see this also, BKW was a complete suprise to me and I did not see him on many lists at all as being mafia.

 

[ZSandmann]

C'mon, Brains and CCM and LG to a lessor degree were cheese. Where was your case against BK? I may have missed it. Mind posting the post number for me?

I can go back and find the posts for you, but I compared and contrasted the feud between LG and Bkw. I still believe one must of been communicating and one non-communicating.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Wow guys, I can't believe that some of you are believing this load from King. And HN to say I haven't put anything into this thread is painful to me as I have built cases for every person I have voted for, which have incidentally all been Mafia. I built a case on brains, on CCM, on Bkw and LG, and on King before he started posting like a mad man on speed. I still have Coler as a strong suspect but I haven't seen enough to vote for him yet and as I have documented King as been much more telling IMO and has shown signs of skimming and confusion. I can't stop anyone from voting for me, but I ask you to at least think about it some.

As far as JM goes, I think she is Innocent, if that makes me Mafia so be it. She has been playing like she always does and I just don't buy it. I think she invested HN and when she freaked out about people suspecting her she blurted out who it was.

Same post, new thought. She's playing like she always does, but you don't buy it? I find this very contradictory. Almost like a lawyer speaking alot, but not really saying anything...

 

[ZSandmann]

HN let me reword that for you.

As far as JM goes, I think she is Innocent, if that makes me look like I am Mafia I accept that. She has been playing like she always does, I just don't buy that she is Mafia.

I know my southern prose can sometimes be difficult to interpret, so thank you for asking for clarification.

 

[ZSandmann]

Vocal suspects:
brains, plantling, charlie

Quiet suspects:
CCM, BKW, MM

I am more interested in the quiet players than the vocal ones right now. We know MM gives herself away when she is evil so I would really like to hear more from her. I think CCM has outted themselves much like Ogre and brains. I think these are the Mafia that can not talk. I can imagine that is a precarious role, and since we have never had a round like this before they don't seem to know just how to play it.

If Ogre, brains, and CCM are three of the five outsider Mafia, who would everyone pick as the other two? I think I would pick joander and MM. I suspect the four Mafia that are in communion are much more vocal in the game. I guess Ogre could of been one of the 4, but he seemed to be playing rogue to me.

That's a good observation HN. Pretty certain either BKW or LG is Mafia and I am leaning LG Innocent right now after their exchange.

I think he is talking about confirmed Mafia. You voyed Charlie and switched to brains at the end of Day 1. Then Day 2 you voted LG. I can see where he is coming from, right now I have you lower than LG on my list but I am not sure enough about either of you to vote for one yet. I believe we have better suspects.

Holy crap it's a novel in here today. Really good info though. I still have LG and BKW on a see-saw, I am sure one is Mafia of the two, I guess they could both be with the way the game is set up but I don't think they would continue to go at one another if that were the case. I can see the case made for both, and will have to try and determine which I believe is more likely Mafia.

Well we got our daily one off post from CCM, another empty post, no insight, no list, nothing.


That makes no sense King. Yes there had to be Mafia votes on Brains but to say "most"? Why would Mafia put a majority on another Mafia? Then you say "We" are on a roll, I assume you mean the Town here. You can't have it both ways, if the Mafia is voting other Mafia to blend in then how can the Town be on a roll? I would think people not on Brains would be more suspicous to you. Also, MM and CCM are two of my strong suspects, how can I be on a team with them? If I were Mafia would I drag them through the dirt?

CCM: We need information from you if you want to continue in the game, these pop-in posts don't add anything. Are you Innocent or have you accepted your fate?

Yup i still strongly suspect LG and BKW. After their back and forth argument I still find it hard to believe both are Mafia, but with the game format it is possible. If BKW is a non-communicating Mafia that would put LG in the Communicative group. I could possibly put Brains in that group, I think it is obvious Ogre was Non-communicative as he was caught trying to let himself be known.

These are my posts on Bkw. Looking back I guess I didn't put into print as much as I thought out the scenarios and I focused on LG much more than him. But I think we all did. These are from Day 2 till last Night, as you can see I started out thinking only one must be Mafia, but with the twist in the scenario this round I later rationalized that perhaps both were Mafia and just in different groups which now appears to have been the case.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

HN let me reword that for you.

As far as JM goes, I think she is Innocent, if that makes me look like I am Mafia I accept that. She has been playing like she always does, I just don't buy that she is Mafia.

I know my southern prose can sometimes be difficult to interpret, so thank you for asking for clarification.

Been in the South for almost 20 years, lived in every southern state, and never heard anyone use the word "prose'' in conversation... Especially not in the land of boudin and mud bugs.

 

[KingOfTheDeep]

KOTD since you're so sure Z is mafia and HNs plan is to get a tie between multiple mafia suspects why not move your vote to Z?

ok then

i remove my vote on coler and vote to lynch Z

hope it works