THE PLAY: Mafia #16 'Till death do we part...

Blueiz said:
I dont think we should assume anything. Did judge state that the replacement would be innocent?
Click to expand...

No assumptions, just logic. Why do you think she would replace Sploke with a mafia member?
 
Hooked Newbie said:
Curiousity here... Ice, where'd ya go? Did you get a PM saying you were now mafia and are too busy in a chat to post?
Click to expand...


I pulled the post and bolded the sentence, you must have missed it while skimming.

IceH2O said:
Let the back pedaling begin.

Nice lucky shot too. How in the world did you guess Sploke was something important or did you just get lucky?


I'm going to place my vote as I said I would

I vote to lynch Joander

If you need an explanation then just look over the past days events and the last hours before night fall.

Will also be willing to vote HN,LG, or Jpap.

At least till they show me why I should believe they are innocent.

Going to watch todays Netflix movie, Dead Silence. So probably won't be back on tonight.
Click to expand...

IceH2O said:
Sweet..

But I hope you had enough smarts to name an innocent already in the game as preacher and not Brains 2 lol.
Click to expand...

Made this post while wife paused to put son back into bed


You're not exactly helping clear yourself in my mind HN.

Missing comments.

Trying to point fingers at me for defending an innocent person.

I'm not expecting anyone to assume I'm innocent just because I was able to see through the push for votes on DD. I admit she made some out of norm posts but thats why I figured her innocent. She doesn't screw up like that most of the time. As I said I'm thinking shes just had a bad game, a bit of burn out.



I'd reason that Brains 2 is innocent just because they lost an innocent to a misfire on the hit.



HN I'm going to bed so if I disappear thats why. I bolded it for you so you can't miss it. Maybe you should make an eye appointment and get some glasses.
 
Well, since everyone got so quiet I'm gonna try to graba nap before I have to work tonight. I'll be back later though I may be a bit distracted.
 
IceH2O said:
I pulled the post and bolded the sentence, you must have missed it while skimming.





Made this post while wife paused to put son back into bed


You're not exactly helping clear yourself in my mind HN.
I don't care. All you can do is hit me. A case on me has way too many holes and I am comfortable with being a townie.

Missing comments.

Trying to point fingers at me for defending an innocent person.

I'm not expecting anyone to assume I'm innocent just because I was able to see through the push for votes on DD. I admit she made some out of norm posts but thats why I figured her innocent. She doesn't screw up like that most of the time. As I said I'm thinking shes just had a bad game, a bit of burn out.

Oh my... now you know whether or not someone is innocent even if they make out of norm posts? How do you find mafia then? So far it doesn't seem like you've looked. You put your vote on someone who was not at risk, that you could make a VERY basic case against and have attacked anyone that tried to get a mafia on night one. I guess you expected to be chosen huh? Oh yeah, Charlie... way to follow with the "I'll ride that train". I invite anyone who thinks I am guilty to vote for me, make a case, campaign for me to be gone. I just don't buy it and since I think I'll be gone soon enough..

I Vote to lynch Iceh2o.



I'd reason that Brains 2 is innocent just because they lost an innocent to a misfire on the hit.



HN I'm going to bed so if I disappear thats why. I bolded it for you so you can't miss it. Maybe you should make an eye appointment and get some glasses.
Click to expand...

G'night.
 
Oh lord, my head is spinning....that was an awful night...I need to reread in the morning...I'm surprised about the UD's, but I always am, why sign up in the first place? Just the excitement of being involved? Even though we get a new preacher sploke is a huge loss because he always plays a great det/doc role...More in the morning...
 
Sorry folks I had a work emergency and have not been able to read or post.

Next game, good luck everyone.
 
charlie_stubbs said:
The readers digest version is Joe, Jpap and Lady G busted their tails getting DD lynched.
Click to expand...

I think this statement can be labled the "Great Understatement" for this game.. I had to read through everything twice and out of all of these people in the last several hours was most of the traffic and I saw JoAnder doing most of the pushing..

However other things that concern me are..

1. Yesterday Liz was extremely vocal, but today she is pretty much no where to be found in this thread. I haven't gone looking to see if she has posted elsewhere as of yet and with it being midnight as I type and my day being long again tomorrow I don't have the time but will do so before the next nightfall... Has she taken our advice and is reading previous games?? I don't know but you think we would have at least heard from her today.. I didn't see anything letting us know she was going to be unavailable today.. Did I miss this?? I don't think I did..

2. We saw the vote tied up until this morning which would have left the decision to whomever the Judge is.. If I am understanding that roll correctly.. However then we see some people last hour switching of votes and trying to rationalize things for the switch.. We see DD putting in her vote back on Liz in an attempt to save her life and at least have a 50/50 chance of surviving the night and again putting the Judge roll back into play.. Then the final vote of Kuli which I am not sure if it was a skimming the thread and believing the arguments put there or a mafia tactic to put an innocent over the top as far as votes go.. But those last several votes (other than DD's) are the most disconcerting votes as far as I am concerned. While I do believe that out of the three pushing for DD's demise that there was mafia in there (read the next number for that rational) I think LadyG is simply DD's and her game rivalry that they seem to have. In the last two games I have played they seem to want to butt heads. I don't know about the one inbetween.. So then that leaves Jpap who all of a sudden has gone quiet.. Is that because he got the votes placed where he wanted them and decided to back off and let the chips fall?? Of this I am not certain but as others have posted Jpap and LadyG need to be watched, and I agree but would like to add as well those last hour votes/changes.

3. While I too thought DD was acting mafiaish and that was based on when she was my DON and simular actions/reactions two games ago and is what I based my ultimate vote upon.. However the pushing that Joander did was almost fanatical in a way.. While I understand that we only have these pages to transmit our thoughts/ideas and we all attempt to make a case to me the logical way of doing this is simply making your case and letting those who are playing make up their own mind. When I was mafia I used the exact same tactic on LadyG (to which she eventually let loose that she was the "det" when she was the "doc") but in reality we didn't have a clue to who she was just that we thought she might be a PR at the time.. Or at least I did which is why I pulled that tactic (unfortunately during that game it backfired).. I seeing something simular here.. I picked at that flaw in her game just like Jo picked at the flaw in DD's game..

For right now this is my list and my thoughts.. I am thinking thought that I'll probably end up voting for JoAnder simply due to the fact of the tactics he employed and how hard he played that full court press.. But I want to take tonight and work tomorrow to think on it for a while..

I also want to take some time and read the day before I think.. But its really late now and I need sleep..

Anyway like I said just some thoughts of mine at the moment..
 
OMG!!!! Just got home and read through tonights lynching. I have to say DD I am VERY sorry...you know I love and respect you girl, but I am sorry you have to admit you played so off, I really believed you were mafia and trying to look innocent.

To those of you who say it was a "weak" case, really for a day one no it wasn't, she looked mafia plain and simple and you are the ones I will be focusing on mostly. I don't mean this to sound "if you didn't vote DD you are mafia" that is not my meaning but the ones who refused to even acknowledge there was a case have me worried. Sploke the only known innocent was even on the DD lynch, so don't tell me that Jo, HN and myself were the only ones who saw it, obviously many did.

The late "jumpers" are others I think need looked at.

Again, DD please forgive me for I truly did think you mafia.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom